Case Study: Speciation and the Threespine Stickleback
112
Giarrocco
Part I – Background
One of the ways that speciation can occur is when a population is split by a geographical barrier
(allopatric speciation). After separation, each population accumulates genetic differences through
the four mechanisms of genetic divergence (founder effect, genetic drift, mutation, natural
selection). If the two populations reunite, there are three possible outcomes: (1) they are a single
species, (2) they are separate species, or (3) they are in the process of speciating.
In this case study, we examine a sh called the threespine stickleback. We focus on Paxton Lake,
a lake where two populations of these sh that were once geographically separated came
together again.
Threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) are minnow-sized sh that live in coastal
marine environments throughout Europe, Asia, and North America. Marine threespine
sticklebacks are named for the three dorsal spines that help protect them against predators. In
coastal areas, many freshwater lakes and streams are also home to populations of sticklebacks
that have become adapted to local freshwater conditions. One such lake is Paxton Lake on
Texada Island, British Columbia.
The origin of the freshwater sticklebacks on Texada Island dates back to glaciation around
13,000 years ago when the weight of glaciers lowered coastal land relative to sea level and the
current Gulf Islands were submerged. As glaciers melted and retreated, the land rebounded and
the islands emerged from the ocean, trapping water in lakes that gradually became fresh over
time. Throughout the Gulf Islands, freshwater lakes are home to threespine stickleback
populations that became trapped and isolated from marine populations as the Gulf Islands
formed.
Interestingly, Paxton Lake is home to not one but two different forms of threespine sticklebacks.
The evidence supports a double invasion hypothesis. This proposes that after the rst marine
population of sticklebacks was trapped and became adapted to local conditions in the lake,
additional marine sticklebacks made their way upstream from the ocean into the lake. Paxton
Lake is now home to two related but distinct populations of sticklebacks, both descended from a
marine ancestor.
In Paxton Lake, the two populations of sticklebacks—limnetic and benthics—are named for the
areas of the lake in which they live and feed. Limnetic sticklebacks feed on zooplankton in the
limnetic zone, the open waters of the lake near the surface and away from shore. Benthic
sticklebacks feed on larger invertebrates in the benthic zone, the muddy lake bottom in the
shallow water near the edge of the lake.
Limnetic sticklebacks are slim with narrow mouths. Like their marine ancestors, they have a
protective armor of dorsal and pelvic spines, pelvic girdle, and many lateral plates. This armor
This study source was downloaded by 570403 from cliffsnotes.com on 01-12-2025 09:09:57 GMT -06:00
https://www.cliffsnotes.com//study-notes/6311651
fi fi fi fi
112
Giarrocco
Part I – Background
One of the ways that speciation can occur is when a population is split by a geographical barrier
(allopatric speciation). After separation, each population accumulates genetic differences through
the four mechanisms of genetic divergence (founder effect, genetic drift, mutation, natural
selection). If the two populations reunite, there are three possible outcomes: (1) they are a single
species, (2) they are separate species, or (3) they are in the process of speciating.
In this case study, we examine a sh called the threespine stickleback. We focus on Paxton Lake,
a lake where two populations of these sh that were once geographically separated came
together again.
Threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) are minnow-sized sh that live in coastal
marine environments throughout Europe, Asia, and North America. Marine threespine
sticklebacks are named for the three dorsal spines that help protect them against predators. In
coastal areas, many freshwater lakes and streams are also home to populations of sticklebacks
that have become adapted to local freshwater conditions. One such lake is Paxton Lake on
Texada Island, British Columbia.
The origin of the freshwater sticklebacks on Texada Island dates back to glaciation around
13,000 years ago when the weight of glaciers lowered coastal land relative to sea level and the
current Gulf Islands were submerged. As glaciers melted and retreated, the land rebounded and
the islands emerged from the ocean, trapping water in lakes that gradually became fresh over
time. Throughout the Gulf Islands, freshwater lakes are home to threespine stickleback
populations that became trapped and isolated from marine populations as the Gulf Islands
formed.
Interestingly, Paxton Lake is home to not one but two different forms of threespine sticklebacks.
The evidence supports a double invasion hypothesis. This proposes that after the rst marine
population of sticklebacks was trapped and became adapted to local conditions in the lake,
additional marine sticklebacks made their way upstream from the ocean into the lake. Paxton
Lake is now home to two related but distinct populations of sticklebacks, both descended from a
marine ancestor.
In Paxton Lake, the two populations of sticklebacks—limnetic and benthics—are named for the
areas of the lake in which they live and feed. Limnetic sticklebacks feed on zooplankton in the
limnetic zone, the open waters of the lake near the surface and away from shore. Benthic
sticklebacks feed on larger invertebrates in the benthic zone, the muddy lake bottom in the
shallow water near the edge of the lake.
Limnetic sticklebacks are slim with narrow mouths. Like their marine ancestors, they have a
protective armor of dorsal and pelvic spines, pelvic girdle, and many lateral plates. This armor
This study source was downloaded by 570403 from cliffsnotes.com on 01-12-2025 09:09:57 GMT -06:00
https://www.cliffsnotes.com//study-notes/6311651
fi fi fi fi