• Wrong document? Swap it for free
  • Written by students who passed
  • Immediately available after payment
  • Read online or as PDF
Sell
Where do you study
Your language
Document preview thumbnail
Preview 3 out of 24 pages
Class notes

FUR2601 - Summarised Cases (Bundle)

Document preview thumbnail
Preview 3 out of 24 pages

A summary of the following cases in Fundamental Rights: Soobramoney v Minister of Health; Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign; Ferreira v Levin; Du Plessis v De Klerk; Khumalo v Holomisai; Carmichele v Minister of Safety and Security; De Lille v Speaker of the National Assembly; Govender v Minister of Safety and Security; Daniels v Campbell; Ex parte Minister of Safety and Securtiy: in re S v Walters; Afrox Healthcare v Strydom; Bhe v Magistrate, Khaylitsha; S v Mhlungu; S v Makwanyane; Ferreira v Levin; Soobramoney v Minister of Health; etc

Content preview

FUR2601
Fundamental Rights
CASE LAW




Revision PACK
Summary Bundle

, CASES: FUR2601
Study Unit 1: Introduction to the Constitution
and the Bill of Rights
1. Ex parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Judgment → Decline to certify the text.
Assembly: in re Certification of the
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa The CC held → The provisions relating to provincial
1996. (First Certification judgment) 1996 powers, local government, entrenchment of the Bill of
Rights and Public Service Commission did not comply
with the Constitutional Principles.

Instead of an outright transmission of power there would
be a 2-stage transition. The interim government under the
interim  would govern the country on a coalition basis
while the final  was being drafted. An elected national
legislature would draft the new.

2. Certification of the Amended Text of the Judgment → Accepted the text to be consistent with the
Constitution fo the Republic of South Africa Constitutional Principles.
1996 (Second Certification judgment) 1997.
The CC held → Once the  was certified - it is not
possible to object to the amendments of the 1996
Constitution on the basis of not complying with the
Principles.

→ A court should approach the meaning of the relevant
provision of the  as assigned by the CC in the
certification process and should not be departed from save
in the most compelling circumstances.

3. South African Association of Personal Injury The CC held → There is no doubt the  provides for
Lawyers v Heath 2001 such a separation of powers and that laws inconsistent
with the  are invalid. Further, that the principle is an
implied or implicit provision and drawn from the structure
of other provisions.

4. Executive Council of the Western Cape The CC held → Any law or conduct not in accordance
Legislature v President of the Republic of with the , either for procedural or substantive reasons,
South Africa 1995. will therefore not have the force of law.

The CC held → The “manner & form” provisions of the
 prevent Parliament form delegating to the executive
the power to amend provisions of the enabling Act of
Parliament. This implies when the executive is
empowered to amend or repeal Acts - the doctrine of


1

, separation of functions will be undermined.

Therefore the court held that the executive may not make
this type of law.

5. Soobramoney v Minister of Health (KZN) Judgment → CC refused to order the state to provide
1998. expensive dialysis treatment to keep patient alive.

The CC held → That difficult & agonizing judgments
have to be made as to how a limited budget is best
allocated to the max advantage of the max number of
patients, and this is not a judgment a court can make.

6. Pharmaceuritcal Manufacturers Association Legal question → On what basis is the Presidents conduct
of SA: In re Ex parte President of the of signing an Act into operation constitutionally
Republic of South Africa 2000. reviewable - where the power given to him was granted by
an Act of Parliament.

The CC held → The power was not administrative action
although derived form legislation. The conduct was an
exercise of public power which had to be carried out
consistently with the provisions of the .

Legal question → What constraints does the  place on
the exercise of public power.

The CC held → It is a requirement of the rule of law that
the exercise of public power not be arbitrary. Decision
must be related to the purpose for which the power was
given.

The CC did not reach the rule of law principle until it
decided the conduct was not administrative (Note:
sequence of analysis).

7. Minister of Health v Treatment Action The courts approach to human rights issues →
Campaign 2002.
The CC will not hesitate to issue mandatory relief which
affects policy and has cost implications when reaching the
conclusion that the state has not performed its
constitutional obligations.




2

Document information

Uploaded on
April 5, 2022
Number of pages
24
Written in
2022/2023
Type
Class notes
Professor(s)
Cases summary
Contains
All classes
$2.92

Wrong document? Swap it for free Within 14 days of purchase and before downloading, you can choose a different document. You can simply spend the amount again.
Written by students who passed
Immediately available after payment
Read online or as PDF

Seller avatar
Reputation scores are based on the amount of documents a seller has sold for a fee and the reviews they have received for those documents. There are three levels: Bronze, Silver and Gold. The better the reputation, the more your can rely on the quality of the sellers work.
StuddyScene
4.0
(1302)
Sold
8359
Followers
3664
Items
2390
Last sold
2 days ago




Why students choose Stuvia

Created by fellow students, verified by reviews

Quality you can trust: written by students who passed their tests and reviewed by others who've used these notes.

Didn't get what you expected? Choose another document

No worries! You can instantly pick a different document that better fits what you're looking for.

Pay as you like, start learning right away

No subscription, no commitments. Pay the way you're used to via credit card and download your PDF document instantly.

Student with book image

“Bought, downloaded, and aced it. It really can be that simple.”

Alisha Student

Working on your references?

Create accurate citations in APA, MLA and Harvard with our free citation generator.

Working on your references?

Frequently asked questions