,© 2018 University of South Africa
All rights reserved
Printed and published by the
University of South Africa
Muckleneuk, Pretoria
PVL3704/1/2019–2021
70682402
Shutterstock.com images used
InDesign
HSY_Style
, CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION v
Study unit 1: GENERAL OVERVIEW 1
1.1 INTRODUCTION TO UNJUSTIFIED ENRICHMENT 2
Study unit 2: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ENRICHMENT
LIABILITY 14
2.1 INTRODUCTION 16
2.2 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ENRICHMENT LIABILITY 17
2.3 NATURE AND EXTENT OF ENRICHMENT CLAIMS 28
Study unit 3: CONDICTIO INDEBITI: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS 32
3.1 INTRODUCTION 34
3.2 ROMAN LAW 34
3.3 ROMAN-DUTCH LAW 35
3.4 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 35
Study unit 4: CONDICTIO INDEBITI: SPECIFIC APPLICATIONS 43
4.1 INTRODUCTION 45
4.2 STATUTORY ENRICHMENT ACTION: ALIENATION OF
LAND ACT 45
4.3 THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI AND THE LAW OF SUCCESSION 47
4.4 THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI AND THE LAW OF INSOLVENCY 48
4.5 ULTRA VIRES PAYMENTS AND THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI 49
4.6 PAYMENTS MADE UNDER DURESS AND PROTEST 50
Study unit 5: CONDICTIO OB TURPEM VEL INIUSTAM CAUSAM 53
5.1 INTRODUCTION 54
5.2 ROMAN LAW 55
5.3 ROMAN-DUTCH LAW 55
5.4 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 56
Study unit 6: CONDICTIO CAUSA DATA CAUSA NON SECUTA 63
6.1 INTRODUCTION 64
6.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 64
Study unit 7: CONDICTIO SINE CAUSA SPECIALIS 68
7.1 INTRODUCTION 69
7.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 70
7.3 APPLICATION OF THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI IN
CHEQUE LAW 71
Study unit 8: NEGOTIORUM GESTIO 75
8.1 INTRODUCTION 76
8.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 77
PVL3704/1 (iii)
, Study unit 9: ENRICHMENT BY MEANS OF IMPROVEMENTS
AND ATTACHMENTS (ACCESSIO) 85
9.1 INTRODUCTION 87
9.2 SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 87
Study unit 10: ENRICHMENT BY MEANS OF IMPROVEMENTS
AND ATTACHMENTS (ACCESSIO) – CONTINUED 96
10.1 INTRODUCTION 98
10.2 OCCUPIERS AND HOLDERS (DETENTORES) 99
10.3 OCCUPIERS/HOLDERS AT WILL (PRECARIO HABENS) 106
Study unit 11: RIGHTS OF RETENTION AND LIENS 109
11.1 INTRODUCTION 110
11.2 IMPENSAE NECESSARIAE 112
11.3 IMPENSAE UTILES 112
11.4 IMPENSAE VOLUPTUARIAE 113
Study unit 12: ENRICHMENT ACTION AGAINST AND BY MINORS 115
12.1 INTRODUCTION 116
12.2 SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 116
Study unit 13: COMPENSATION FOR WORK DONE AND
SERVICES RENDERED 119
13.1 INTRODUCTION 120
13.2 CONTRACTS FOR WORK 122
13.3 CONTRACTS FOR SERVICES 123
Study unit 14: GENERAL ENRICHMENT ACTION 126
14.1 INTRODUCTION 127
14.2 COMMON LAW 127
14.3 NORTJÉ V POOL 128
14.4 WAY FORWARD: THREE RECENT SUPREME COURT OF
APPEAL CASES 129
14.5 CONCLUSION 134
GLOSSARY OF LATIN TERMS AND THEIR MEANING 138
(iv)
All rights reserved
Printed and published by the
University of South Africa
Muckleneuk, Pretoria
PVL3704/1/2019–2021
70682402
Shutterstock.com images used
InDesign
HSY_Style
, CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION v
Study unit 1: GENERAL OVERVIEW 1
1.1 INTRODUCTION TO UNJUSTIFIED ENRICHMENT 2
Study unit 2: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ENRICHMENT
LIABILITY 14
2.1 INTRODUCTION 16
2.2 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ENRICHMENT LIABILITY 17
2.3 NATURE AND EXTENT OF ENRICHMENT CLAIMS 28
Study unit 3: CONDICTIO INDEBITI: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS 32
3.1 INTRODUCTION 34
3.2 ROMAN LAW 34
3.3 ROMAN-DUTCH LAW 35
3.4 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 35
Study unit 4: CONDICTIO INDEBITI: SPECIFIC APPLICATIONS 43
4.1 INTRODUCTION 45
4.2 STATUTORY ENRICHMENT ACTION: ALIENATION OF
LAND ACT 45
4.3 THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI AND THE LAW OF SUCCESSION 47
4.4 THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI AND THE LAW OF INSOLVENCY 48
4.5 ULTRA VIRES PAYMENTS AND THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI 49
4.6 PAYMENTS MADE UNDER DURESS AND PROTEST 50
Study unit 5: CONDICTIO OB TURPEM VEL INIUSTAM CAUSAM 53
5.1 INTRODUCTION 54
5.2 ROMAN LAW 55
5.3 ROMAN-DUTCH LAW 55
5.4 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 56
Study unit 6: CONDICTIO CAUSA DATA CAUSA NON SECUTA 63
6.1 INTRODUCTION 64
6.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 64
Study unit 7: CONDICTIO SINE CAUSA SPECIALIS 68
7.1 INTRODUCTION 69
7.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 70
7.3 APPLICATION OF THE CONDICTIO INDEBITI IN
CHEQUE LAW 71
Study unit 8: NEGOTIORUM GESTIO 75
8.1 INTRODUCTION 76
8.2 APPLICATION IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 77
PVL3704/1 (iii)
, Study unit 9: ENRICHMENT BY MEANS OF IMPROVEMENTS
AND ATTACHMENTS (ACCESSIO) 85
9.1 INTRODUCTION 87
9.2 SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 87
Study unit 10: ENRICHMENT BY MEANS OF IMPROVEMENTS
AND ATTACHMENTS (ACCESSIO) – CONTINUED 96
10.1 INTRODUCTION 98
10.2 OCCUPIERS AND HOLDERS (DETENTORES) 99
10.3 OCCUPIERS/HOLDERS AT WILL (PRECARIO HABENS) 106
Study unit 11: RIGHTS OF RETENTION AND LIENS 109
11.1 INTRODUCTION 110
11.2 IMPENSAE NECESSARIAE 112
11.3 IMPENSAE UTILES 112
11.4 IMPENSAE VOLUPTUARIAE 113
Study unit 12: ENRICHMENT ACTION AGAINST AND BY MINORS 115
12.1 INTRODUCTION 116
12.2 SOUTH AFRICAN LAW 116
Study unit 13: COMPENSATION FOR WORK DONE AND
SERVICES RENDERED 119
13.1 INTRODUCTION 120
13.2 CONTRACTS FOR WORK 122
13.3 CONTRACTS FOR SERVICES 123
Study unit 14: GENERAL ENRICHMENT ACTION 126
14.1 INTRODUCTION 127
14.2 COMMON LAW 127
14.3 NORTJÉ V POOL 128
14.4 WAY FORWARD: THREE RECENT SUPREME COURT OF
APPEAL CASES 129
14.5 CONCLUSION 134
GLOSSARY OF LATIN TERMS AND THEIR MEANING 138
(iv)