PA 241 Exam 1 With Complete
Solution
U.S. Patriot Act - ANSWER -Restricts liberty by expanding gov't authority
-"sneak and peek", "fed. DNA registry", email
-2015 fight over USA Freedom Act
USA Freedom Act - ANSWER a U.S. law enacted on June 2, 2015 that restored in
modified form several provisions of the Patriot Act, which had expired the day before.
The act imposes some new limits on the bulk collection of telecommunication metadata
on U.S. citizens by American intelligence agencies, including the National Security
Agency. It also restores authorization for roving wiretaps and tracking lone wolf
terrorists.
Biggest change is the requirement that all communications companies must provide call
data to NSA. HOWEVER, it does mandate that communication companies must retain
this data and provide specific data with proper court authorization
Emile Durkheim (1800's) - ANSWER - sociologist that was interested in why things are
the way they are.....suicide, social meaning of labels, crime
Crime is normal!
Crime is functional!
What do laws do? - ANSWER -Maintain order
-Regulate human interaction
-Enforce moral beliefs
-Define economic environment
-Enhance predictability
-Support powerful
-Promote orderly social change
-Identify wrongdoers, redress wrongs
-Delineate punishment
,Natural Law - ANSWER Sup. Ct. Justice Thomas, Locke, Rousseau
1. Some laws are basic and fundamental to human nature
2. These laws are discoverable by human reason without reference to legislative or
judicial decisions.
3. Fundamental moral principles underlie all legal systems.
4. Governments cannot infringe or deny these.
What are these basic moral principles?
(Natural Law) - ANSWER 1. Freedom of worship, voice in gov't, right of property
2. English Bill of Rights 1689;
Declaration of Independence 1789;
Basis for Bill of Rights 1791;
United Nations Declaration of Human Rights 1948
Problems with Natural Law tradition? - ANSWER 1.Rationality
2.Equality
3.Complexity of society impinges upon natural law precepts.
4.Should focus be individual or social contract made up of individuals.
Positivist School - ANSWER Darwin, Comte, etc.
1. Behavior is deterministic
A. What does this mean for individuals?
2. Types of positivism
- social, psychological, biological -
- implications?
3. Find regularities through scientific investigation.
- What does the data tell us?
Problems of positivist school - ANSWER 1. How to target causes
2. Individual vs. societal
3. Adopts government definition of crime
, 4. Economic and social order is given and can't be changed
Classical School - ANSWER Becarria, Locke, etc.
1. Self interest
2. War of all against all- therefore surrender liberty for safety
3. Punishment deters not rehab.
4. Law is limited and individuals are responsible
Crime Control Model vs. Due Process Model
due process model: - ANSWER "obstacle course"
- holds that criminal offenders should be presumed innoceny, that the courts' 1st priority
is protecting the constitutional rights of the accused, and that granting too much
freedom to law enforcement officials will result in the loss of freedom and civil liberties
for all
crime control model - ANSWER more traditional philosophy
"assembly line"
- views crime as a breakdown of individual responsibility
- places highest importance on repressing criminal conduct and thus protecting society
- persons charged are presumed guilty
- police and prosecutors should have high degree of discretion
- punishment will deter crime
Problems of Classical School - ANSWER 1. Rationality
2. Equality
3. Free Will
3. Punishments (Certainty, Severity, Celerity) Neoclassical
Critical perspectives - ANSWER Marx, Reiman, etc. (? authority)
1. Social order helps determine law
Consensus/Conflict/Pluralist
2. Institutions perpetuate social order
Pyrrhic theory
Solution
U.S. Patriot Act - ANSWER -Restricts liberty by expanding gov't authority
-"sneak and peek", "fed. DNA registry", email
-2015 fight over USA Freedom Act
USA Freedom Act - ANSWER a U.S. law enacted on June 2, 2015 that restored in
modified form several provisions of the Patriot Act, which had expired the day before.
The act imposes some new limits on the bulk collection of telecommunication metadata
on U.S. citizens by American intelligence agencies, including the National Security
Agency. It also restores authorization for roving wiretaps and tracking lone wolf
terrorists.
Biggest change is the requirement that all communications companies must provide call
data to NSA. HOWEVER, it does mandate that communication companies must retain
this data and provide specific data with proper court authorization
Emile Durkheim (1800's) - ANSWER - sociologist that was interested in why things are
the way they are.....suicide, social meaning of labels, crime
Crime is normal!
Crime is functional!
What do laws do? - ANSWER -Maintain order
-Regulate human interaction
-Enforce moral beliefs
-Define economic environment
-Enhance predictability
-Support powerful
-Promote orderly social change
-Identify wrongdoers, redress wrongs
-Delineate punishment
,Natural Law - ANSWER Sup. Ct. Justice Thomas, Locke, Rousseau
1. Some laws are basic and fundamental to human nature
2. These laws are discoverable by human reason without reference to legislative or
judicial decisions.
3. Fundamental moral principles underlie all legal systems.
4. Governments cannot infringe or deny these.
What are these basic moral principles?
(Natural Law) - ANSWER 1. Freedom of worship, voice in gov't, right of property
2. English Bill of Rights 1689;
Declaration of Independence 1789;
Basis for Bill of Rights 1791;
United Nations Declaration of Human Rights 1948
Problems with Natural Law tradition? - ANSWER 1.Rationality
2.Equality
3.Complexity of society impinges upon natural law precepts.
4.Should focus be individual or social contract made up of individuals.
Positivist School - ANSWER Darwin, Comte, etc.
1. Behavior is deterministic
A. What does this mean for individuals?
2. Types of positivism
- social, psychological, biological -
- implications?
3. Find regularities through scientific investigation.
- What does the data tell us?
Problems of positivist school - ANSWER 1. How to target causes
2. Individual vs. societal
3. Adopts government definition of crime
, 4. Economic and social order is given and can't be changed
Classical School - ANSWER Becarria, Locke, etc.
1. Self interest
2. War of all against all- therefore surrender liberty for safety
3. Punishment deters not rehab.
4. Law is limited and individuals are responsible
Crime Control Model vs. Due Process Model
due process model: - ANSWER "obstacle course"
- holds that criminal offenders should be presumed innoceny, that the courts' 1st priority
is protecting the constitutional rights of the accused, and that granting too much
freedom to law enforcement officials will result in the loss of freedom and civil liberties
for all
crime control model - ANSWER more traditional philosophy
"assembly line"
- views crime as a breakdown of individual responsibility
- places highest importance on repressing criminal conduct and thus protecting society
- persons charged are presumed guilty
- police and prosecutors should have high degree of discretion
- punishment will deter crime
Problems of Classical School - ANSWER 1. Rationality
2. Equality
3. Free Will
3. Punishments (Certainty, Severity, Celerity) Neoclassical
Critical perspectives - ANSWER Marx, Reiman, etc. (? authority)
1. Social order helps determine law
Consensus/Conflict/Pluralist
2. Institutions perpetuate social order
Pyrrhic theory