• Wrong document? Swap it for free
  • Written by students who passed
  • Immediately available after payment
  • Read online or as PDF
Sell
Where do you study
Your language
Document preview thumbnail
Preview 3 out of 25 pages
Exam (elaborations)

Constitutional Law

Document preview thumbnail
Preview 3 out of 25 pages

Modalities of interpretation - answer-Textual - words of the con Structural - how the con. fits together (separation of powers) Historical - Original intent of the frmaers. (original meaning and traditions) (interpreted in accordance with history or background) Doctrine/precedent - what the court's have generally decided Ethical/National values/moral - Moral values Prudential/practical/pragmatic- What are the consequences of the ruling? (pragmatic consequences) Three functions of the constitution - answer-Sets up limited enumerated powers Article 1: sets out congress and grants them power to legislate and make laws. Article 2: executive branch, President, qualifications: Commander in chief, veto, appointments, treaties etc. Article 3: Judicial branch, creates the SC, defines SC jurisdiction Marbury v. Madison - answer-First decision to declare a federal law unconstitutional Established principle of judicial review - ability of courts to engage in review of legislative and executive actions SC has the power to review the constitutionality of the other branches The judiciary can compel the executive what to do if it concerns an administrative duty that the prez. owes Constitution is regulatory and limits congress Constitution is regulatory and imposes meaningful limits on the government Article 3 limits judicial power - court cannot exceed the constraints of article 3 even if congress says it can Judiciary can compel executive action of those things that are ministerial (when there is a duty owed to some person) Holding: marbury loses out b/c scotus said they couldn't rule on the case b/c they only had appellate jurisdiction and the case should have been in the lower court first. However section 13 was unconstitutional b/c he should not have been allowed to file directly in the SC. reasoning: Appointments never got delivered. Marshall makes an ethical argument Marshall's statement in Marbury v. Madison that it is "emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is," is perhaps the most oft-cited passage in the opinion. Martin v. Hunter's Lessee - answer-The supreme court has the power to review state court decisions. Article 3 says the judicial power shall be vested into one supreme court and judicial power includes reviewing determinations of federal questions Sct. makes a textual argument (power vested in ONE supreme court) must hear all cases Theorizes that S. Ct can hear cases from state court Supremacy clause - answer-Constitution is the supreme law of the land Uniformity of decision - answer-Needs to ensure uniformity in the interpretation of federal law For a state decision to go to the SC it must be a federal issue Federal issue - answer-Statute, treaty, compact between states, administrative regulation, constitutional issue etc. SC can't review state court decision concerning state law Adequate state grounds - answer-If there are adequate and independent state grounds for a decision the SC cannot review it State court could have been totally wrong on the federal issue 4 corners - not adequate and independent if they didn't in the four corners of the document specifically state that they weren't relying on state law Virginia state cort. ruled on 2 state grounds (fed treaty does not apply, you didn't raise the federal treaty properly Adequate means the state law part would sustain judgment. Independent - want a plain statement of independence if there is some plain meaning Justiciability doctrine - answer-Places a limit on the federal judicial power determines which matters the FC can hear and which must be dismissed Prohibition against advisory opinions, standing, ripeness, mootness, and PQ doctrine two limitations of the Justic. doctrine - answer-Must be an actual case or controversy (must be true lawsuits between individuals with a personal stake in the outcome) to achieve some personal right or remedy Prudential - policy goes against judicial review sometimes Prohibition against advisory opinions - answer-Actual dispute between litigants - cannot be a request for advice substantial likelihood judgment will have some effect in favor of P The FC cannot issue advisory opinions Advis. opinion: lawsuit that seeks the court's opinion on a question and asks them to render a declaratory judgment (essentially a request for advice) Arguments against Advisory opnions: Textual - case and controversies Structural - separation of powers Precedent/history prudential Waste of courts time If the SC made advisory opinions it would erode their authority. They would be making laws instead of congress. It would violate the separation of powers. To avoid being an AOpinion: Must be an actual controversy, between adverse litigants, that have an interest in the outcome, court's decision must have possibility to bring a change or effect. Standing - answer-Determination of whether a specific person is the proper party to bring matter for adjudication or challenge some form of government action. You must ask: WHO is the proper party to bring the lawsuit? Elements: Injury in fact: must be actual or imminent, concrete and particularized Causation: fairly traceable to defendant's conduct Redressability: decision will likely redress P's injury Injury in fact - answer-actual or imminent - cannot be hypothetical Cannot be someday,injury must have happened. A mere interest in the problem is not enough (Lujan v. defenders) Concrete and particularized - certain types of injuries (cannot be harm to society) - can be money damages, civil rights violation, unconstitutional tax under establishment clause (Flash v. Cohen), any common law injury, physical injury, injunctive remedy Generalized grievance - must be more than a complaint that the gov. if not following the law. Frothingham v. Melon (injury shared with citizens) Causation - answer-Must be fairly traceable to D's conduct and not some third party d's conduct must have caused the injury Redressability - answer-Likelihood that the problem will be fixed (relief or redress available from the court) Prohibition on third party standing - answer-Person has been injured but doesn't have a good claim so he tries to assert someone else's right to rectify his harm concerns: person who suffered from the legal interest should bring the claim judiciary might not have to deal with these issues when they don't have to Physicians allowed to sue on mother's rights under an abortion statute (singleton v. wuff) Third party claim - answer-Exception that allows one to assert another's rights: allowed to assert someone else's right if there is a close relationship between the litigant and the third party's rights Obstacles to them bringing suit, impediment to original party placing the claim Litigant and third party both suffer some type of injury Ripeness - answer-Matter is premature for review, because the injury is speculative and may never occur ASK: is it too early?(has the injury occurred yet?) Ripeness determines when a party can seek pre-enforcement challenge to a statute (party wants to engage in conduct that might violate the statute) Mixture of Con. and prudential concerns: How likely will there be enforcement of the statute? Look for a genuine threat of immediate harm Three situations where a hardship is found and there will be ripeness: Person faced with a choice b/w foregoing allegedly lawful behavior and risking likely prosecution with substantial consequences Enforcement of a statute or regulation is certain There are collateral injuries Mootness - answer-Means the injury has ceased Someone WAS injured, but no longer so English v. arizona examples of moot claims: challenge a statute and it gets repealed, criminal defendant dies, settlement, change in facts that ends controversy fourt exceptions where a case will not be moot: recurring issue yet it evades review (When there is a reasonable expectation that the same complaining party will be subjected to the same action again and would again be unable to resolve the issue because of the short duration of the action) - pregnancy in Roe v. Wade Evading review : timeliness aspect, issue happens too fast for the court to render a judgment (must be capable of repetition) Voluntary cessation but could reoccur, class action or multiple parties, collateral consequences will exist. Political question - answer-Subject matter is inappropriate for judicial review. Allegations of unconstitutional gov. conduct should not be ruled on by the F courts. Con. interpretation should let other branches do it. ASK: is this question solely and exclusively a province of the political branches? (if yes, judiciary needs to stay away) policy reasons: separation of powers, there has been a commitment of the issue to another branch. (or can we come up with a rule of law that governs these things?) Prudential : mutual respect among branches, don't want to piss other branches off. PQ are those that are issues committed by the CON to another branch of the gov. Decision by judiciary could create some crisis or chaos. Political gerrymandering is NOT a political question Section 13 of the judiciary act says scotus can issue a writ of mandamus in the case of marbury. Jurisdictional limitations - answer-Article 3 specifies that congress can influence the court's decision It is constitutional for congress to withdraw jurisdiction from the courts which there is another avenue of review (Ex parte McCardle) Two things Congress cannot do: (use their jurisdiction rules to compel courts to reach certain results in certain cases and violate any other provision of the constitution) Article 1 section 8 (congress powers) - answer-The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States; To borrow money on the credit of the United States; To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes; To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, and uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States; To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures; To provide for the Punishment of counterfeiting the Securities and current Coin of the United States; To establish Post Offices and Post Roads; To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries; To constitute Tribunals inferior to the supreme Court; To define and punish Piracies and Felonies committed on the high Seas, and Offenses against the Law of Nations; To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water; To raise and support Armies, but no Appropriation of Money to that Use shall be for a longer Term than two Years; To provide and maintain a Navy; To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces; To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions; To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of Powers and duties of the president of the united states - answer-... LUJAN v. DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE - answer-Solidifies the idea of standing (constitutional standing)

Content preview

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW QUESTIONS AND ANWERS
Modalities of interpretation - answer-Textual - words of the con
Structural - how the con. fits together (separation of powers)
Historical - Original intent of the frmaers. (original meaning and traditions) (interpreted
in accordance with history or background)
Doctrine/precedent - what the court's have generally decided
Ethical/National values/moral - Moral values
Prudential/practical/pragmatic- What are the consequences of the ruling? (pragmatic
consequences)

Three functions of the constitution - answer-Sets up limited enumerated powers
Article 1: sets out congress and grants them power to legislate and make laws.
Article 2: executive branch, President, qualifications: Commander in chief, veto,
appointments, treaties etc.
Article 3: Judicial branch, creates the SC, defines SC jurisdiction

Marbury v. Madison - answer-First decision to declare a federal law unconstitutional
Established principle of judicial review - ability of courts to engage in review of legislative
and executive actions
SC has the power to review the constitutionality of the other branches
The judiciary can compel the executive what to do if it concerns an administrative duty
that the prez. owes
Constitution is regulatory and limits congress

Constitution is regulatory and imposes meaningful limits on the government

Article 3 limits judicial power - court cannot exceed the constraints of article 3 even if
congress says it can

Judiciary can compel executive action of those things that are ministerial (when there is
a duty owed to some person)

Holding: marbury loses out b/c scotus said they couldn't rule on the case b/c they only
had appellate jurisdiction and the case should have been in the lower court first.
However section 13 was unconstitutional b/c he should not have been allowed to file
directly in the SC.

reasoning: Appointments never got delivered.

Marshall makes an ethical argument

Marshall's statement in Marbury v. Madison that it is "emphatically the province and duty
of the judicial department to say what the law is," is perhaps the most oft-cited passage
in the opinion.

Martin v. Hunter's Lessee - answer-The supreme court has the power to review state
court decisions.

,Article 3 says the judicial power shall be vested into one supreme court and judicial
power includes reviewing determinations of federal questions

Sct. makes a textual argument (power vested in ONE supreme court) must hear all cases
Theorizes that S. Ct can hear cases from state court

Supremacy clause - answer-Constitution is the supreme law of the land

Uniformity of decision - answer-Needs to ensure uniformity in the interpretation of
federal law

For a state decision to go to the SC it must be a federal issue

Federal issue - answer-Statute, treaty, compact between states, administrative
regulation, constitutional issue etc.

SC can't review state court decision concerning state law

Adequate state grounds - answer-If there are adequate and independent state grounds
for a decision the SC cannot review it

State court could have been totally wrong on the federal issue

4 corners - not adequate and independent if they didn't in the four corners of the
document specifically state that they weren't relying on state law

Virginia state cort. ruled on 2 state grounds (fed treaty does not apply, you didn't raise
the federal treaty properly

Adequate means the state law part would sustain judgment.
Independent - want a plain statement of independence if there is some plain meaning

Justiciability doctrine - answer-Places a limit on the federal judicial power
determines which matters the FC can hear and which must be dismissed
Prohibition against advisory opinions, standing, ripeness, mootness, and PQ doctrine

two limitations of the Justic. doctrine - answer-Must be an actual case or controversy
(must be true lawsuits between individuals with a personal stake in the outcome) to
achieve some personal right or remedy

Prudential - policy goes against judicial review sometimes

Prohibition against advisory opinions - answer-Actual dispute between litigants - cannot
be a request for advice

substantial likelihood judgment will have some effect in favor of P

The FC cannot issue advisory opinions

, Advis. opinion: lawsuit that seeks the court's opinion on a question and asks them to
render a declaratory judgment (essentially a request for advice)

Arguments against Advisory opnions:
Textual - case and controversies
Structural - separation of powers
Precedent/history
prudential

Waste of courts time

If the SC made advisory opinions it would erode their authority. They would be making
laws instead of congress. It would violate the separation of powers.

To avoid being an AOpinion: Must be an actual controversy, between adverse litigants,
that have an interest in the outcome, court's decision must have possibility to bring a
change or effect.

Standing - answer-Determination of whether a specific person is the proper party to
bring matter for adjudication or challenge some form of government action.

You must ask: WHO is the proper party to bring the lawsuit?

Elements:
Injury in fact: must be actual or imminent, concrete and particularized
Causation: fairly traceable to defendant's conduct
Redressability: decision will likely redress P's injury

Injury in fact - answer-actual or imminent - cannot be hypothetical

Cannot be someday,injury must have happened. A mere interest in the problem is not
enough (Lujan v. defenders)

Concrete and particularized - certain types of injuries (cannot be harm to society) - can
be money damages, civil rights violation, unconstitutional tax under establishment
clause (Flash v. Cohen), any common law injury, physical injury, injunctive remedy

Generalized grievance - must be more than a complaint that the gov. if not following the
law.

Frothingham v. Melon (injury shared with citizens)

Causation - answer-Must be fairly traceable to D's conduct and not some third party
d's conduct must have caused the injury

Redressability - answer-Likelihood that the problem will be fixed (relief or redress
available from the court)

Document information

Uploaded on
September 7, 2024
Number of pages
25
Written in
2024/2025
Type
Exam (elaborations)
Contains
Questions & answers
$10.99

Wrong document? Swap it for free Within 14 days of purchase and before downloading, you can choose a different document. You can simply spend the amount again.
Written by students who passed
Immediately available after payment
Read online or as PDF

Seller avatar
Reputation scores are based on the amount of documents a seller has sold for a fee and the reviews they have received for those documents. There are three levels: Bronze, Silver and Gold. The better the reputation, the more your can rely on the quality of the sellers work.
TOPDOCTOR
5.0
(1)
Sold
10
Followers
5
Items
3387
Last sold
1 year ago




Why students choose Stuvia

Created by fellow students, verified by reviews

Quality you can trust: written by students who passed their tests and reviewed by others who've used these notes.

Didn't get what you expected? Choose another document

No worries! You can instantly pick a different document that better fits what you're looking for.

Pay as you like, start learning right away

No subscription, no commitments. Pay the way you're used to via credit card and download your PDF document instantly.

Student with book image

“Bought, downloaded, and aced it. It really can be that simple.”

Alisha Student

Working on your references?

Create accurate citations in APA, MLA and Harvard with our free citation generator.

Working on your references?

Frequently asked questions