LPL4801 - MCQ Summary notes 2021
Characteristics of a contract of sale Definition: contract of sale is a reciprocal contract in terms of which the seller undertakes to deliver the thing to the buyer and the buyer undertakes to pay a sum of money in exchange for the thing. 2 essentialia: 1. The parties must agree that one of them will deliver the thing 2. The other party will pay a price Difference between sale and lease: in lease: one party undertakes to deliver the thing and the other undertakes to pay a sum of money – there is a further essentialia: the parties must agree expressly or tacitly that the lessee must restore the thing leased to the lessor at some time. Sale does not have this clause. BUT a contact of sale could be subject to a suspensive or resolutive condition/ right of rescission, in that the thing may be returned to the seller in certain circumstances – this doesn’t arise out of the conclusion of the contract but out of cancellation of the contract. Title: it’s not an essentialia of a contract of sale that the seller of the thing undertake to stand in for his title – a clause in the contract that the seller should guarantee his title – ie. That he is the owner of the thing! THE SELLER DOES NOT NEED TO BE THE OWNER OF THE THING FOR A VALID CONTRACT OF SALE TO TAKE PLACE, NOR DOES DELIVERY NEED TO TAKE PLACE OR PAYMENT TO BE MADE. ALL THAT IS NEEDED IS AN UNDERTAKING BY THE SELLER TO DELIVER AND AN UNDERTAKING BY THE BUYER TO PAY THE PURCHASE PRICE. As long as the parties agree that the seller will, in exchange for payment, give possession of the thing to the buyer = contract of sale, even though both parties are well aware that the seller isn’t the owner = BUT it is a naturalia that the seller stand in for the eviction of the purchaser. Sale: the seller has an obligation to perform = delivery 1. Locatio conduction operas (contract for the letting and hiring of work): is an agreement where an independent contractor undertakes to render the result of his labour to the other party. Contract of sale is distinguished in that the seller’s obligation is one to deliver, while that of a person accepting work is a duty to do something. So if a contract relates to manufacture and delivery of a thing not yet in existence – will only be sale if the manufacturer also provides the materials for the manufacture of the thing. The emptio rei speratae (sale of a future thing) and the empti spei (sale of pure chance: Contract where one party undertakes to deliver a thing not yet in existence to another in exchange for a sum of money – can be a sale even if the thing doesn’t exist at the time of the conclusion of the contract. The seller then has a duty to deliver the thing and also see that the thing materializes. It must be possible to deliver the thing as from the conclusion of ht contract – if not the contract will be of no force and effect = impossibility of performance. 2. Emptio rei speratae: this occurs in the sale of a thing not yet in existence, it’s the intention of the parties that the price be paid only if the thing does come into being – if the thing doesn’t come into existence = no sale. Suspensive condition construction: the full operation of the sale is suspended until an uncertain future event (coming into being of the thing) occurs – if the thing doesn’t come into being the contract comes to an end. The function of the condition construction: a) Explain why the buyer cant claim the thing immediately b) Explain why the risk that the thing sold wont materialize is borne by the seller This is complicated incorrect and unnecessary – in accordance with the intention of the parties an obligation resting on the seller to bring the thing into being and then make delivery – if there is a duty on a contracting party to see that a condition is fulfilled its not a genuine condition. SO this construction must be rejected. Correct construction: a) The buyer cant claim the thing immediately because a party to the contract can claim performance only after a reasonable time has elapsed - the buyer must aloe the seller a reasonable time to prepare the thing b) The seller carries the risk that the thing sold wont materialize, because that is what the parties agreed. 3. Emptio spei When a thing, which hasn’t yet come into existence, is sold and it’s agreed that the buyer will be liable for the purchase price even if the thing never materializes. Sale of expectation/hope – buyer will have to pay whether the thing materializes or not. The seller is entitled to the purchase price. 4. The emptio ad mensuram (sale of a group of things at a price per unit) Deliver a group of things – flock of sheep = the price isn’t fixed but determinable = but the thing is fixed. Land: is often sold at Rx per hectare 5. Sale in the alternative and generic sales The sellers undertaking to deliver a thing need not be an undertaking to deliver a specific thing. Alternative sale: where the seller has to deliver one of several specific things – i.e. X sells one of his 3 horses Generic sale: where the seller has to deliver a thing described according to its nature – sells one sheep for R300.
Document information
- Uploaded on
- October 29, 2021
- Number of pages
- 94
- Written in
- 2021/2022
- Type
- Summary