, CAS3701
ASSIGNMENT 8 (PORTFOLIO) 2026
DUE 30 OCTOBER 2026
CAS3701 Assessment 8: Complete Answer Book
Student Number: [Insert your student number]
Module: CAS3701 – Capstone in Accounting Sciences
Assessment: 8 (October/November 2026)
Due Date: 30 October 2026
Question 1: Real Problem and Board Regularisation Decision
Required element Student response
Management frames the matter as an urgent production recovery problem. The CFO
memorandum states that the plant cannot absorb another month of reduced
throughput, that a 21-day delay risks missing the October export window and
What management says
triggering R14.7 million in customer penalties, and that covenant headroom of R31
the problem is
million is narrow (KAC, 2026:8). Management presents Marula as a commercially
necessary emergency appointment, with outstanding documents to be completed
during mobilisation (KAC, 2026:8).
The real problem is not a future approval; it is a retrospective regularisation of
work already performed. Two trial loads were completed before board approval
under a letter of intent signed by Operations, not a full contract (KAC, 2026:12). The
weighbridge was offline for 11 hours and manual slips were used (KAC, 2026:6).
Driver induction is incomplete (22 of 51), insurance is missing, bank verification is
What has already unverified, and a conflict declaration remains unresolved (KAC, 2026:12). Internal
happened and the real Audit explicitly states the board is “being asked to regularise an action already partly
board problem taken” (KAC, 2026:13). The board is therefore being asked to legitimise a fait
accompli, not to authorise a prospective decision. This distinction is central to the
committee’s fiduciary duty under section 76(3) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 to
act in the best interests of the company and with care, skill and diligence (South
Africa, 2008: s76(3)).
, Required element Student response
The urgency is real and quantifiable. Furnace 2 availability has fallen to 68%,
inventory days have risen to 79, and revenue at risk is R86 million (KAC, 2026:6).
Export penalty exposure is R14.7 million, and a 21-day delay could reduce revenue by
Commercial urgency a further R34 million (KAC, 2026:8–9). Covenant headroom has fallen from R118
evidence million (2025 actual) to a forecast R31 million, with net debt rising from R940 million
to R1 210 million (KAC, 2026:9). Finance costs are forecast to increase from R81
million to R108 million (KAC, 2026:9). These figures confirm that the operational and
financial pressure is genuine.
The evidence gaps are material and go to the heart of lawful and safe mobilisation.
The supplier file is missing insurance confirmation, full contract, pricing benchmark,
complete driver induction, bank verification, and a resolved conflict declaration (KAC,
2026:12). Diesel route logs are inconsistently signed, undermining diesel rebate and
cost allocation support (KAC, 2026:13). The school-road near miss at Ga-Moraba
Evidence/control
village demonstrates that community risk is already live, not hypothetical (KAC,
weakness
2026:13). Internal Audit rates supplier onboarding, manual weighbridge slips, and
road-safety control as “High” risk (KAC, 2026:13). These weaknesses matter because
commercial urgency can explain why evidence is incomplete; it cannot substitute for
evidence when the board is asked to approve payment, VAT claims, and public safety
outcomes (KAC, 2026:8).
First, no further loads should move until the insurance confirmation is received
and driver induction is completed for all 51 drivers, with a signed register
evidencing completion. Uninsured, uninducted drivers on a road passing a school
Two urgent corrections create unacceptable safety and liability exposure. Second, a road-safety plan with
before wider funded controls must be approved and implemented before any increase in
mobilisation haulage frequency: traffic marshals at school crossing hours, temporary signage, dust
suppression, and a liaison officer, with costs recognised above the line rather than
deferred (KAC, 2026:14). These two corrections address the most immediate risks to
life and to the audit trail.
Conditional approval of a 45-day bridge arrangement (aligned with Option D),
subject to evidence gates. The board should not grant unrestricted three-month
approval (Option B), nor stop Marula entirely (Option A), nor run an accelerated
tender (Option C) that would trigger the very delay the company cannot absorb.
Recommended board
Conditional approval recognises the commercial urgency while refusing to convert
stance
urgency into a blanket waiver of evidence. This stance is defensible under King IV
Principle 16, which requires a stakeholder-inclusive approach balancing the needs of
material stakeholders in the best interests of the organisation over time (IoDSA, 2016:
Principle 16).
ASSIGNMENT 8 (PORTFOLIO) 2026
DUE 30 OCTOBER 2026
CAS3701 Assessment 8: Complete Answer Book
Student Number: [Insert your student number]
Module: CAS3701 – Capstone in Accounting Sciences
Assessment: 8 (October/November 2026)
Due Date: 30 October 2026
Question 1: Real Problem and Board Regularisation Decision
Required element Student response
Management frames the matter as an urgent production recovery problem. The CFO
memorandum states that the plant cannot absorb another month of reduced
throughput, that a 21-day delay risks missing the October export window and
What management says
triggering R14.7 million in customer penalties, and that covenant headroom of R31
the problem is
million is narrow (KAC, 2026:8). Management presents Marula as a commercially
necessary emergency appointment, with outstanding documents to be completed
during mobilisation (KAC, 2026:8).
The real problem is not a future approval; it is a retrospective regularisation of
work already performed. Two trial loads were completed before board approval
under a letter of intent signed by Operations, not a full contract (KAC, 2026:12). The
weighbridge was offline for 11 hours and manual slips were used (KAC, 2026:6).
Driver induction is incomplete (22 of 51), insurance is missing, bank verification is
What has already unverified, and a conflict declaration remains unresolved (KAC, 2026:12). Internal
happened and the real Audit explicitly states the board is “being asked to regularise an action already partly
board problem taken” (KAC, 2026:13). The board is therefore being asked to legitimise a fait
accompli, not to authorise a prospective decision. This distinction is central to the
committee’s fiduciary duty under section 76(3) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 to
act in the best interests of the company and with care, skill and diligence (South
Africa, 2008: s76(3)).
, Required element Student response
The urgency is real and quantifiable. Furnace 2 availability has fallen to 68%,
inventory days have risen to 79, and revenue at risk is R86 million (KAC, 2026:6).
Export penalty exposure is R14.7 million, and a 21-day delay could reduce revenue by
Commercial urgency a further R34 million (KAC, 2026:8–9). Covenant headroom has fallen from R118
evidence million (2025 actual) to a forecast R31 million, with net debt rising from R940 million
to R1 210 million (KAC, 2026:9). Finance costs are forecast to increase from R81
million to R108 million (KAC, 2026:9). These figures confirm that the operational and
financial pressure is genuine.
The evidence gaps are material and go to the heart of lawful and safe mobilisation.
The supplier file is missing insurance confirmation, full contract, pricing benchmark,
complete driver induction, bank verification, and a resolved conflict declaration (KAC,
2026:12). Diesel route logs are inconsistently signed, undermining diesel rebate and
cost allocation support (KAC, 2026:13). The school-road near miss at Ga-Moraba
Evidence/control
village demonstrates that community risk is already live, not hypothetical (KAC,
weakness
2026:13). Internal Audit rates supplier onboarding, manual weighbridge slips, and
road-safety control as “High” risk (KAC, 2026:13). These weaknesses matter because
commercial urgency can explain why evidence is incomplete; it cannot substitute for
evidence when the board is asked to approve payment, VAT claims, and public safety
outcomes (KAC, 2026:8).
First, no further loads should move until the insurance confirmation is received
and driver induction is completed for all 51 drivers, with a signed register
evidencing completion. Uninsured, uninducted drivers on a road passing a school
Two urgent corrections create unacceptable safety and liability exposure. Second, a road-safety plan with
before wider funded controls must be approved and implemented before any increase in
mobilisation haulage frequency: traffic marshals at school crossing hours, temporary signage, dust
suppression, and a liaison officer, with costs recognised above the line rather than
deferred (KAC, 2026:14). These two corrections address the most immediate risks to
life and to the audit trail.
Conditional approval of a 45-day bridge arrangement (aligned with Option D),
subject to evidence gates. The board should not grant unrestricted three-month
approval (Option B), nor stop Marula entirely (Option A), nor run an accelerated
tender (Option C) that would trigger the very delay the company cannot absorb.
Recommended board
Conditional approval recognises the commercial urgency while refusing to convert
stance
urgency into a blanket waiver of evidence. This stance is defensible under King IV
Principle 16, which requires a stakeholder-inclusive approach balancing the needs of
material stakeholders in the best interests of the organisation over time (IoDSA, 2016:
Principle 16).