UvA
Arresten en RO’s
IER 2025-2026
, Table of Contents
1. ICJ, North Sea Continental Shelf.................................................4
Samenvatting...............................................................................4
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen..................................................4
Overweging 74..............................................................................4
Overweging 77..............................................................................5
2. ICJ, Nicaragua v. United States...................................................6
Samenvatting...............................................................................6
Overweging 177............................................................................6
Overweging 188............................................................................7
Overweging 209............................................................................7
3. ICJ, Reparation for Injuries.........................................................8
Samenvatting...............................................................................8
4. East Timor v Netherlands (Arrondissementsrechtbank Den Haag)
.............................................................................................. 10
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 10
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................10
Overwegingen 3 en 4...................................................................10
Overweging 7.............................................................................. 11
5. Supreme Court of Canada, Secession of Quebec........................12
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 12
Overwegingen 111 en 126............................................................12
Overweging 138..........................................................................12
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................13
6. C-26/62, Van Gend en Loos.......................................................14
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 14
7. Costa/ENEL.............................................................................. 15
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 15
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................16
8. C-643/15 & C-647/15, Slowakije en Hongarije v. Raad
(Quotumzaak).........................................................................16
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 16
,Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................17
Overwegingen 62 en 66...............................................................17
Overweging 78............................................................................18
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................18
9. C-106/77 Simmenthal II............................................................19
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 19
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................19
Overweging 17............................................................................19
Overweging 24............................................................................19
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................20
10. C-282/10, Dominguez.............................................................21
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 21
Overweging 24............................................................................21
Overwegingen 38 en 39...............................................................21
11. 80/86 Strafzaak t. Kolpinghuis................................................23
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 23
Overweging 10............................................................................23
Overwegingen 13 en 14...............................................................23
12. C-201/02, Delena Wells...........................................................25
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 25
Overweging 57............................................................................25
Overwegingen 64 en 65...............................................................25
13. C-91/92 Faccini Dori................................................................27
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 27
Overweging 20............................................................................27
Overweging 24............................................................................27
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................27
14. C 569/16 en C-570/16, Bauer...................................................28
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 28
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................28
Overweging 84............................................................................28
Overweging 85............................................................................28
, 15. C 6/90 en C-9/90, Francovich...................................................30
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 30
Overwegingen 35 en 37...............................................................30
Overweging 40............................................................................30
16. C 46/93 en C-48/93 Brasserie du Pêcheur & Factortame............32
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 32
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................32
Overwegingen 32 en 36...............................................................32
Overweging 55............................................................................33
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................33
17. HR 29 november 2002, Danikovic e.a. tegen Staat der
Nederlanden...........................................................................34
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 34
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................34
Overweging 3.3...........................................................................34
De conclusie van de AG (blz. 220, laatste alinea)...........................34
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................35
18. HR 10 oktober 2014, Staat tegen CAN (Club Actieve Nietroker). 36
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 36
Overweging 3.5.2........................................................................36
Overweging 3.5.3........................................................................36
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................37
Arresten en RO’s
IER 2025-2026
, Table of Contents
1. ICJ, North Sea Continental Shelf.................................................4
Samenvatting...............................................................................4
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen..................................................4
Overweging 74..............................................................................4
Overweging 77..............................................................................5
2. ICJ, Nicaragua v. United States...................................................6
Samenvatting...............................................................................6
Overweging 177............................................................................6
Overweging 188............................................................................7
Overweging 209............................................................................7
3. ICJ, Reparation for Injuries.........................................................8
Samenvatting...............................................................................8
4. East Timor v Netherlands (Arrondissementsrechtbank Den Haag)
.............................................................................................. 10
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 10
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................10
Overwegingen 3 en 4...................................................................10
Overweging 7.............................................................................. 11
5. Supreme Court of Canada, Secession of Quebec........................12
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 12
Overwegingen 111 en 126............................................................12
Overweging 138..........................................................................12
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................13
6. C-26/62, Van Gend en Loos.......................................................14
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 14
7. Costa/ENEL.............................................................................. 15
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 15
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................16
8. C-643/15 & C-647/15, Slowakije en Hongarije v. Raad
(Quotumzaak).........................................................................16
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 16
,Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................17
Overwegingen 62 en 66...............................................................17
Overweging 78............................................................................18
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................18
9. C-106/77 Simmenthal II............................................................19
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 19
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................19
Overweging 17............................................................................19
Overweging 24............................................................................19
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................20
10. C-282/10, Dominguez.............................................................21
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 21
Overweging 24............................................................................21
Overwegingen 38 en 39...............................................................21
11. 80/86 Strafzaak t. Kolpinghuis................................................23
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 23
Overweging 10............................................................................23
Overwegingen 13 en 14...............................................................23
12. C-201/02, Delena Wells...........................................................25
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 25
Overweging 57............................................................................25
Overwegingen 64 en 65...............................................................25
13. C-91/92 Faccini Dori................................................................27
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 27
Overweging 20............................................................................27
Overweging 24............................................................................27
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................27
14. C 569/16 en C-570/16, Bauer...................................................28
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 28
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................28
Overweging 84............................................................................28
Overweging 85............................................................................28
, 15. C 6/90 en C-9/90, Francovich...................................................30
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 30
Overwegingen 35 en 37...............................................................30
Overweging 40............................................................................30
16. C 46/93 en C-48/93 Brasserie du Pêcheur & Factortame............32
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 32
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................32
Overwegingen 32 en 36...............................................................32
Overweging 55............................................................................33
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................33
17. HR 29 november 2002, Danikovic e.a. tegen Staat der
Nederlanden...........................................................................34
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 34
Belangrijkste rechtsoverwegingen................................................34
Overweging 3.3...........................................................................34
De conclusie van de AG (blz. 220, laatste alinea)...........................34
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................35
18. HR 10 oktober 2014, Staat tegen CAN (Club Actieve Nietroker). 36
Samenvatting.............................................................................. 36
Overweging 3.5.2........................................................................36
Overweging 3.5.3........................................................................36
Kernbegrippen en definities.........................................................37
