H
andimportantideasinLordoftheFlies?
riteabout:
W
.WhatPiggysaysanddoesthatcanbeseenasusefulandimportant
.HowfarGoldingpresentsPiggyasacharacterwithusefulandimportantideas
[30marks]
A04[4marks]
InGolding’spost-warallegory‘LordoftheFlies’,toafarextent,Piggyispresentedasoneofthe
fewboyswhoconsistentlyvalueslogic,moralityandcivilisation.ThroughPiggy’srationalideas
andwarnings,Goldingsuggeststhatintelligenceandgoodnessareessentialforsocietyto
function.However,GoldingalsopresentsPiggy’sideasasultimatelypowerlessagainst
humanity’sattractiontosavageryandviolence.
irstly,GoldingpresentsPiggy’sideasasintellectuallyandmorallyvaluablebecauseheisone
F
oftheonlyboyswhorecognisesthedangeroflosingcivilisation.ThisisevidentinChapter5
whenheisventingaboutthegroup’sactionswhenhesays‘Whatarewe?Humans?Or
animals?Orsavages?’.Thislistof4rhetoricalquestionsreflectPiggy’sinnerturmoilandhope
fortheboystosayhumane.Ithighlightsthespectrumoftheirbehaviourandthetensionthat
Piggyrecognisesthatisgrowingwithintheboysbetweencivilisedandinstinctivedrive.It
perhapssymbolisesPiggy’sawarenessattheircollectivetransformation.Thefactthatthenoun
‘savages’,ismoredemoralisingthan‘animal’,reinforceshosetheiridentitymaybestrippedinto
unimaginableunrecognisablecreatures.Itisasthoughhighlightingtheirbloodthirstynatureand
lossofidentityperhapshintingatthethemeofcivilisationvsSavagery.Therhetoricalquestions
reinforcehisdisbeliefanddesperationfortheboystonotgodownthatpath.Thisismaybe
foreshadowingthelatershiftintheboy’smentalitieswhenregressintocommittingmurders.
PerhapsGoldingisattemptingtoconveyhowdespitetherecognitionoflossofhumanityand
morals,itiseasilyforgottenduetothetemptationofsavagery.ThisperhapslinkstoFreud’s
perspectivewheretheid,thesymbolofbasicdesires’,ultimatelyoverpowerseverythingelse
ThuspresentingPiggy’sideasasimportantthroughhissingularabilitytorecognisethedanger
ofthelossofcivilisation.
oreover,GoldingdepictsPiggy’sideasasinsightfulandimportantbecauseheunderstands
M
thatfearandevilcomefromhumansthemselvesratherthanexternalforces.Thisisevidentin
Chapter5whenRalphhascalledameetingandPiggyisattemptingtorationalisetheboy’sfear.
Thisisevidentwhenhesays‘Iknowthereisn’tnobeast,withclawsandallthat…Unlesswe
getfrightenedofpeople.’ThisdismissivetoneemphasisesPiggy’sintelligenceandlogic
reinforcinghowherecognisesthechildishnatureofamaterialisedmonsterbeingactually
presentontheisland.Itsuggestshisdoubtabouttheboys’fearstrulybeingpartofhuman
naturethroughhisscepticism,perhapsreflectinghowhebelieveshumansthemselvesarethe
truedanger.Theverb‘frightened’createsafearfulandperplexedtone,asthoughreiteratingthe
factthatPiggyfeelstheverynotionaboutbeingfrightenedofpeopleisstupidandillogical.This