SOLUTION MANUAL FOR
Matching Supply with Demand An Introduction to Operations Management, 5th Edition Cachon
Chapter 2-19
Chapter 2
The Process View of the Organization
Q2.1 Dell
The following steps refer directly to Exhibit 2.1.
#1: For 2001, we find in Dell’s 10-k: Inventory = $400 (in million)
#2: For 2001, we find in Dell’s 10-k: COGS = $26,442 (in million)
26, 442$/ year
#3: Inventory turns 66.105 turns per year
400$
40% per year
#4: Per unit Inventory cost 0.605% per year
66.105 per year
Q2.2. Airline
We use Little’s law to compute the flow time, since we know both the flow rate as well
as the inventory level:
Flow Time Inventory/ Flow Rate 35 passengers/ 255 passengers per hour 0.137 hours
8.24 minutes
Q2.3 Inventory Cost
(a) Sales $60,000,000 per year / $2000 per unit 30,000 units sold per year
Inventory $20,000,000 / $1000 per unit 20,000 units in inventory
Flow Time Inventory/ Flow Rate 20,,000 per year year 8 months
Turns 1/ Flow Time 1/( year) 1.5 turns per year
Note: we can also get this number directly by writing: Inventory turns COGS / Inventory
(b) Cost of Inventory: 25% per year /1.5 turns 16.66%. For a $1000 product, this would
make an absolute inventory cost of $166.66 .
Q2.4. Apparel Retailing
(a) Revenue of $100M implies COGS of $50M (because of the 100% markup).
Turns COGS/ Inventory $50M/ $5M 10 .
(b) The inventory cost, given 10 turns, is 40%/10 4% . For a 30$ item, the inventory
cost is 0.4 $30 $1.20 per unit .
Q2.5. La Villa
(a) Flow Rate Inventory / Flow Time 1200 skiers /10 days 120 skiers per day
(b) Last year: on any given day, 10% (1 of 10) of skiers are on their first day of skiing
© McGraw Hill LLC. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of
McGraw Hill LLC.
, This year: on any given day, 20% (1 of 5) of skiers are on their first day of skiing
Average amount spent in local restaurants (per skier)
Last year 0.1$50 0.9$30 $32
This year 0.2$50 0.8$30 $34
% change ($34 $32) / $32 6.25% increase
Q2.6. Highway
We look at 1 mile of highway as our process. Since the speed is 60 miles per hour, it
takes a car 1 minute to travel through the process (flow time).
There are 24 cars on ¼ of a mile, i.e. there are 96 cars on the 1 mile stretch (inventory).
Inventory = Flow Rate * Flow Time: 96 cars = Flow Rate * 1 minute
Thus, the Flow Rate is 96 cars per minute, corresponding to 96*60 = 5760 cars per hour.
Q2.7. Strohrmann Baking
The bread needs to be in the oven for 12 minutes (flow time). We want to produce at a
flow rate of 4000 breads per hour, or 4000/60 = 66.66 breads per minute.
Inventory = Flow Rate * Flow Time: Inventory = 66.66 breads per minute* 12 minutes
Thus, Inventory = 800 breads, which is the required size of the oven.
Q2.8. Mt Kinley Consulting
We have the following information available from the question:
Level Inventory (number of consultants at Flow Time (time spent at that
that level) level)
Associate 200 4 years
Manager 60 6 years
Partner 20 10 years
(a) We can use Little’s law to find the flow rate for associate consultants: Inventory =
Flow Rate * Flow Time; 200 consultants = Flow Rate * 4 years; thus, the flow rate is
50 consultants per year, which need to be recruited to keep the firm in its current size
(note: while there are also 50 consultants leaving the associate level, this says nothing
about how many of them are dismissed vs how many of them are promoted to
Manager level).
(b) We can perform a similar analysis at the manager level, which indicates that the flow
rate there is 10 consultants. In order to have 10 consultants as a flow rate at the
manager level, we need to promote 10 associates to manager level (remember, the
firm is not recruiting to the higher ranks from the outside). Hence, every year, we
dismiss 40 associates and promote 10 associates to the manager level (the odds at that
level are 20%)
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.
, Now,s3considers3thes3partners3level.s3Thes3flows3rates3theres3iss32s3consultantss3pers3years3
(obtaineds3vias3thes3sames3calculationss3ass3before).s3Thus,s3froms3thes310s3managers3case
ss3wes3evaluates3everys3year,s38s3ares3dismisseds3ands32s3ares3promoteds3tos3partners3(thes3
oddss3ats3thats3levels3ares3therebys3alsos320%).
Ins3orders3tos3finds3thes3oddss3ofs3as3news3hires3tos3becomes3partner,s3wes3needs3tos3multip
lys3thes3promotions3probabilities:s30.2*0.2s3=s30.04.s3Thus,s3as3news3hires3hass3as34%s3chan
ces3ofs3makings3its3tos3partner.
Q2.9.s3Majors3USs3Retailers
a. Products3stayss3ons3averages3fors331.9s3dayss3ins3Costco’ss3inventory
b. Costcos3hass3fors3as3$5s3products3ans3inventorys3costs3ofs3$0.1311s3whichs3comparess3tos3a
$0.2049s3 ats3Wal-Mart
Q2.10.s3McDonald’s
a. Inventorys3turnss3fors3McDonald’ss3weres392.3.s3Theys3weres330.05s3fors3Wendy’s.
b. McDonald’ss3hass3pers3units3inventorys3costss3ofs30.32%,s3whichs3fors3as33$s3meals3about
$0.00975.s3Thats3comparess3tos30.998%s3ats3Wendy’ss3wheres3thes3costs3pers3meals3iss 3 $0.0299s3
.
Q2.11.s3BCH
Is3=s3400s3associates,s3Ts3=s32s3years.s3Rs3s3Is3/s3Ts3s3400s3associatess3/s32s3yrss3s3200s3associatess3/s3yrs
3.
Q2.12.s3Kroger
Turnss3s3Rs3/s3Is3 s376858s3/s36244s312.3
Matchings3Supplys3withs3Demand:s3Ans3Introductions3tos3Operationss3Managem
ents35e
Solutionss3tos3Chapters3Problemss3C
hapters33
Understandings3thes3Supplys3Process:s3Evaluatings3Processs3Capacity
Q3.1s3Processs3Analysiss3withs3Ones3Flows3Unit
(a) Capacitys3ofs3thes3threes3resourcess3ins3unitss3pers3hours3ares 3 602s3/10s312s3,s 3 60
1/s36s310;s3603s3/16s311.25s3.s3Thes3bottlenecks3iss3thes3resources3withs3thes3low
ests3capacity,s3whichs3iss3resources32.
(b) Thes3processs3capacitys3iss3thes3capacitys3ofs3thes3bottleneck,s3whichs3iss 3 10s3units/hrs3.
(c) Ifs 3 s 3 demands3 s38s3unitss3/s3hrs3,s3thens3thes3processs3iss3demands3constraineds3ands3thes3flows3rates3i
s
8s3units/hr
(d) Utilizations3=s3Flows3Rates3/s3Capacitys3.s3Fors3thes3threes3resourcess3theys3ares 3 8s3/s312s3,s 3 8s3/s310s3,s3an
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.
, d
8s3/11.25s3.
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.
Matching Supply with Demand An Introduction to Operations Management, 5th Edition Cachon
Chapter 2-19
Chapter 2
The Process View of the Organization
Q2.1 Dell
The following steps refer directly to Exhibit 2.1.
#1: For 2001, we find in Dell’s 10-k: Inventory = $400 (in million)
#2: For 2001, we find in Dell’s 10-k: COGS = $26,442 (in million)
26, 442$/ year
#3: Inventory turns 66.105 turns per year
400$
40% per year
#4: Per unit Inventory cost 0.605% per year
66.105 per year
Q2.2. Airline
We use Little’s law to compute the flow time, since we know both the flow rate as well
as the inventory level:
Flow Time Inventory/ Flow Rate 35 passengers/ 255 passengers per hour 0.137 hours
8.24 minutes
Q2.3 Inventory Cost
(a) Sales $60,000,000 per year / $2000 per unit 30,000 units sold per year
Inventory $20,000,000 / $1000 per unit 20,000 units in inventory
Flow Time Inventory/ Flow Rate 20,,000 per year year 8 months
Turns 1/ Flow Time 1/( year) 1.5 turns per year
Note: we can also get this number directly by writing: Inventory turns COGS / Inventory
(b) Cost of Inventory: 25% per year /1.5 turns 16.66%. For a $1000 product, this would
make an absolute inventory cost of $166.66 .
Q2.4. Apparel Retailing
(a) Revenue of $100M implies COGS of $50M (because of the 100% markup).
Turns COGS/ Inventory $50M/ $5M 10 .
(b) The inventory cost, given 10 turns, is 40%/10 4% . For a 30$ item, the inventory
cost is 0.4 $30 $1.20 per unit .
Q2.5. La Villa
(a) Flow Rate Inventory / Flow Time 1200 skiers /10 days 120 skiers per day
(b) Last year: on any given day, 10% (1 of 10) of skiers are on their first day of skiing
© McGraw Hill LLC. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of
McGraw Hill LLC.
, This year: on any given day, 20% (1 of 5) of skiers are on their first day of skiing
Average amount spent in local restaurants (per skier)
Last year 0.1$50 0.9$30 $32
This year 0.2$50 0.8$30 $34
% change ($34 $32) / $32 6.25% increase
Q2.6. Highway
We look at 1 mile of highway as our process. Since the speed is 60 miles per hour, it
takes a car 1 minute to travel through the process (flow time).
There are 24 cars on ¼ of a mile, i.e. there are 96 cars on the 1 mile stretch (inventory).
Inventory = Flow Rate * Flow Time: 96 cars = Flow Rate * 1 minute
Thus, the Flow Rate is 96 cars per minute, corresponding to 96*60 = 5760 cars per hour.
Q2.7. Strohrmann Baking
The bread needs to be in the oven for 12 minutes (flow time). We want to produce at a
flow rate of 4000 breads per hour, or 4000/60 = 66.66 breads per minute.
Inventory = Flow Rate * Flow Time: Inventory = 66.66 breads per minute* 12 minutes
Thus, Inventory = 800 breads, which is the required size of the oven.
Q2.8. Mt Kinley Consulting
We have the following information available from the question:
Level Inventory (number of consultants at Flow Time (time spent at that
that level) level)
Associate 200 4 years
Manager 60 6 years
Partner 20 10 years
(a) We can use Little’s law to find the flow rate for associate consultants: Inventory =
Flow Rate * Flow Time; 200 consultants = Flow Rate * 4 years; thus, the flow rate is
50 consultants per year, which need to be recruited to keep the firm in its current size
(note: while there are also 50 consultants leaving the associate level, this says nothing
about how many of them are dismissed vs how many of them are promoted to
Manager level).
(b) We can perform a similar analysis at the manager level, which indicates that the flow
rate there is 10 consultants. In order to have 10 consultants as a flow rate at the
manager level, we need to promote 10 associates to manager level (remember, the
firm is not recruiting to the higher ranks from the outside). Hence, every year, we
dismiss 40 associates and promote 10 associates to the manager level (the odds at that
level are 20%)
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.
, Now,s3considers3thes3partners3level.s3Thes3flows3rates3theres3iss32s3consultantss3pers3years3
(obtaineds3vias3thes3sames3calculationss3ass3before).s3Thus,s3froms3thes310s3managers3case
ss3wes3evaluates3everys3year,s38s3ares3dismisseds3ands32s3ares3promoteds3tos3partners3(thes3
oddss3ats3thats3levels3ares3therebys3alsos320%).
Ins3orders3tos3finds3thes3oddss3ofs3as3news3hires3tos3becomes3partner,s3wes3needs3tos3multip
lys3thes3promotions3probabilities:s30.2*0.2s3=s30.04.s3Thus,s3as3news3hires3hass3as34%s3chan
ces3ofs3makings3its3tos3partner.
Q2.9.s3Majors3USs3Retailers
a. Products3stayss3ons3averages3fors331.9s3dayss3ins3Costco’ss3inventory
b. Costcos3hass3fors3as3$5s3products3ans3inventorys3costs3ofs3$0.1311s3whichs3comparess3tos3a
$0.2049s3 ats3Wal-Mart
Q2.10.s3McDonald’s
a. Inventorys3turnss3fors3McDonald’ss3weres392.3.s3Theys3weres330.05s3fors3Wendy’s.
b. McDonald’ss3hass3pers3units3inventorys3costss3ofs30.32%,s3whichs3fors3as33$s3meals3about
$0.00975.s3Thats3comparess3tos30.998%s3ats3Wendy’ss3wheres3thes3costs3pers3meals3iss 3 $0.0299s3
.
Q2.11.s3BCH
Is3=s3400s3associates,s3Ts3=s32s3years.s3Rs3s3Is3/s3Ts3s3400s3associatess3/s32s3yrss3s3200s3associatess3/s3yrs
3.
Q2.12.s3Kroger
Turnss3s3Rs3/s3Is3 s376858s3/s36244s312.3
Matchings3Supplys3withs3Demand:s3Ans3Introductions3tos3Operationss3Managem
ents35e
Solutionss3tos3Chapters3Problemss3C
hapters33
Understandings3thes3Supplys3Process:s3Evaluatings3Processs3Capacity
Q3.1s3Processs3Analysiss3withs3Ones3Flows3Unit
(a) Capacitys3ofs3thes3threes3resourcess3ins3unitss3pers3hours3ares 3 602s3/10s312s3,s 3 60
1/s36s310;s3603s3/16s311.25s3.s3Thes3bottlenecks3iss3thes3resources3withs3thes3low
ests3capacity,s3whichs3iss3resources32.
(b) Thes3processs3capacitys3iss3thes3capacitys3ofs3thes3bottleneck,s3whichs3iss 3 10s3units/hrs3.
(c) Ifs 3 s 3 demands3 s38s3unitss3/s3hrs3,s3thens3thes3processs3iss3demands3constraineds3ands3thes3flows3rates3i
s
8s3units/hr
(d) Utilizations3=s3Flows3Rates3/s3Capacitys3.s3Fors3thes3threes3resourcess3theys3ares 3 8s3/s312s3,s 3 8s3/s310s3,s3an
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.
, d
8s3/11.25s3.
©s3McGraws3Hills3LLC.s3Alls3rightss3reserved.s3Nos3reproductions3ors3distributions3withouts3thes3priors3wr
ittens3consents3ofs3McGraws3Hills3LLC.