MNG3701 Assignment 2 Semester 2 (Comprehensive Answers)

MNG3701
Assignment 2
Semester 2 – 2025
Due: September 2025




Contents
Question 1 ....................................................................................................................... 3
Clicks Group Limited and the Resource-Based View (RBV) Model ............................. 3
Distribution Infrastructure ............................................................................................. 3
ClubCard Loyalty Program .......................................................................................... 3
Private Label and Exclusive Brands ............................................................................ 4
Interconnected Resource Synergies ............................................................................ 4
Strategic Implications ................................................................................................... 4
Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 5

Question 2: Clicks Group Limited Business-Level Strategy ............................................ 6
a) Identified Strategy .................................................................................................... 6
b) Definition of Differentiation Strategy ........................................................................ 6
c) Justification for the Differentiation Strategy ............................................................. 6
d) Evaluation Using the ‘Suitability’ Criterion ............................................................... 7

Question 3: Four-Corner Analysis ................................................................................... 8
a) Explanation of the Four-Corner Analysis ................................................................. 8
b) Major Competitor ..................................................................................................... 8
c) Four-Corner Analysis of Dis-Chem .......................................................................... 8
Critical Reflection ......................................................................................................... 9
Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 10

Question 4: Macro-environmental Factors (PESTEL Analysis of Clicks Group Limited) 11
Economic Factors ...................................................................................................... 11
Political Factors ......................................................................................................... 11
Social Factors ............................................................................................................ 12
Technological Factors ................................................................................................ 12
Environmental Factors ............................................................................................... 12
Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 13

Reference List ............................................................................................................... 14

, Question 1
Clicks Group Limited and the Resource-Based View (RBV) Model

The Resource-Based View (RBV), articulated by Barney (1991), posits that firms achieve
sustainable competitive advantage by developing and protecting resources that are valuable,
rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable (VRIN). Applying the RBV to Clicks Group Limited
demonstrates how its unique internal resources underpin its market dominance within South
Africa’s retail and healthcare industries.

Distribution Infrastructure

Clicks operates over 936 stores and 720 pharmacies, forming one of the most comprehensive
distribution networks in the country. This infrastructure is:

 Valuable: Provides consistent market coverage and ensures accessibility to healthcare
and retail services.
 Rare: Few competitors possess a comparable footprint, given the significant financial
and logistical investments required.
 Inimitable: Building a similar network requires decades of capital investment,
operational expertise, and adaptation to South Africa’s diverse socio-geographic contexts.
 Non-substitutable: Physical presence remains indispensable for pharmacy operations
that require regulatory compliance and face-to-face consultation, which digital platforms
cannot fully replicate.

ClubCard Loyalty Program

The Clicks ClubCard—with more than 11.8 million active members—is an intangible yet
highly strategic resource. It is:

 Valuable: Enhances customer retention, boosts purchase frequency, and generates
actionable consumer insights.
 Rare: Few South African competitors operate loyalty programs with such breadth and
depth of integration.
 Inimitable: The combination of data analytics infrastructure, customer trust, and digital
systems makes replication difficult.
 Non-substitutable: No other marketing tool provides the same level of personalised
engagement, behavioural insight, and sales conversion.

Private Label and Exclusive Brands

Clicks’ private label and exclusive brands account for 25.4% of retail sales, reinforcing
differentiation. These products are:

 Valuable: Offer higher margins and cater to niche needs unmet by national brands.