CMY2604 Assignment 1 Semester 2 2025 | 100% COMPLETE ANSWERS

Dealing with Young Offenders - CMY2604 Assessment 1 Semester 2 2025; 100 % TRUSTED workings, Expert Solved, Explanations and Solutions. For assistance call or W.h.a.t.s.a.p.p us on ...(.+.2.5.4.7.7.9.5.4.0.1.3.2)........... Question 1 (10 Marks) Discuss five (5) developmental factors that must be considered when assessing Devon’s criminal capacity and sentencing prospects, as required by the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008. For each factor, explain why it is relevant in Devon’s case and how it may influence the court’s decision. 3.2. Case Study 2: The Case of Thandi Thandi Mokoena, a 16-year-old girl from Khayelitsha, was arrested for theft of a smartphone valued at R3,500 from a classmate, Lerato, during school hours. The incident occurred at her high school when Lerato left her bag unattended in the classroom. Thandi took the phone and sold it the same day for R1,200 to buy airtime and groceries for her younger siblings. Thandi lives with her unemployed mother and three younger siblings in a two-room informal dwelling. Her father is absent and has not contributed financially for years. Thandi helps care for her siblings and often skips meals so they can eat. She has no prior criminal record and attends school regularly, although she has been struggling academically due to stress and lack of study resources. When questioned by the school principal and a police official, Thandi admitted to taking the phone. She expressed remorse, saying, “I knew it was wrong, but I didn’t know what else to do.” She has since apologised to Lerato, who has indicated a willingness to forgive her and support a restorative approach. The school referred the case to the local prosecutor, who is now considering whether to divert Thandi from the formal criminal justice system under the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008. A probation officer has conducted a pre-trial assessment and confirmed that Thandi: • Acknowledges responsibility, • Was not coerced into admitting guilt, • Has no history of criminal behaviour, • Comes from a high-risk socio-economic environment, • Is at risk of dropping out of school if prosecuted. The prosecutor is considering Level 1 diversion under Section 53 of the Act, which includes options such as community service, restitution, or participation in a life skills programme. Question 2 (15 marks) Discuss five (5) factors that the prosecutor must consider when deciding whether to divert Thandi from the formal criminal justice system, as required by the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008. For each factor, explain why it is relevant in Thandi’s case and how it supports or challenges the decision to divert her. In your answer, include a discussion on the factors influencing the decision to divert and also recommend an appropriate diversion option for Thandi. Justify