Semester 1 2025 - DUE 2 May 2025; 100% correct solutions
and explanations.
Question 1
Critical Analysis:
The key factors that led to Barbara’s job dissatisfaction after
transferring from the neurological ward to the operating room
are rooted in the nature of her tasks and responsibilities and a
mismatch between her expectations and reality:
1. Nature of Tasks and Responsibilities:
In the neurological ward, Barbara had diverse,
meaningful, and autonomous tasks such as monitoring
IVs, charting, dressing changes, patient education, and
coordinating home care. She made decisions, prioritised
patient needs, and developed strong personal relationships
with patients. In contrast, in the operating room, Barbara’s
tasks became narrow, repetitive, and subordinate: she
mostly positioned patients, inserted catheters occasionally,
and followed direct surgeon instructions. This significant
reduction in task variety, autonomy, and meaningful
patient interaction led to her dissatisfaction.
2. Mismatch Between Expectations and Reality:
Barbara initially expected that moving to the operating
room would offer a more relaxed routine after the hectic
shifts in the neurological ward. However, in reality, the
work turned out to be monotonous, isolating, and rigid,
offering her little intellectual or emotional engagement. She
missed the immediate patient feedback, gratitude, and