PEN1502 Assignment 1
(COMPLETE ANSWERS)
Semester 1 2025 - DUE 19
March 2025
100% GUARANTEEED
, PEN1502 Assignment 1 (COMPLETE
ANSWERS) Semester 1 2025 - DUE 19 March
2025
QUESTION 1 1.1 What theories of punishment (e.g.,
retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation,
incapacitation) justify John Z.’s death sentence?
1.2 Does John Z.’s punishment align with the
principle of proportionality in sentencing? Explain
how. 1.3 Is the death penalty the most appropriate
form of punishment for John z., or would life
imprisonment be a more just alternative? Provide
justifications, 1.4 What are the potential moral and
ethical concerns surrounding John Z.’s execution?
25 Marks
1.1 Theories of Punishment Justifying John Z.’s Death Sentence
Several theories of punishment could be used to justify John Z.'s death sentence:
Retribution: This theory argues that punishment should be proportionate to
the crime. If John Z. committed a particularly heinous crime (e.g., murder),
the death penalty could be justified as "just deserts."
Deterrence: The death penalty is believed to prevent others from
committing similar crimes due to fear of severe punishment. If John Z.’s
execution serves as a deterrent, it may justify the sentence.
Incapacitation: This theory focuses on preventing the offender from
committing further crimes. Execution ensures that John Z. can never harm
society again.
Rehabilitation: Unlike the other theories, rehabilitation focuses on
reforming the offender, which the death penalty does not allow. Therefore,
this theory does not support John Z.'s execution.
1.2 Proportionality in Sentencing
(COMPLETE ANSWERS)
Semester 1 2025 - DUE 19
March 2025
100% GUARANTEEED
, PEN1502 Assignment 1 (COMPLETE
ANSWERS) Semester 1 2025 - DUE 19 March
2025
QUESTION 1 1.1 What theories of punishment (e.g.,
retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation,
incapacitation) justify John Z.’s death sentence?
1.2 Does John Z.’s punishment align with the
principle of proportionality in sentencing? Explain
how. 1.3 Is the death penalty the most appropriate
form of punishment for John z., or would life
imprisonment be a more just alternative? Provide
justifications, 1.4 What are the potential moral and
ethical concerns surrounding John Z.’s execution?
25 Marks
1.1 Theories of Punishment Justifying John Z.’s Death Sentence
Several theories of punishment could be used to justify John Z.'s death sentence:
Retribution: This theory argues that punishment should be proportionate to
the crime. If John Z. committed a particularly heinous crime (e.g., murder),
the death penalty could be justified as "just deserts."
Deterrence: The death penalty is believed to prevent others from
committing similar crimes due to fear of severe punishment. If John Z.’s
execution serves as a deterrent, it may justify the sentence.
Incapacitation: This theory focuses on preventing the offender from
committing further crimes. Execution ensures that John Z. can never harm
society again.
Rehabilitation: Unlike the other theories, rehabilitation focuses on
reforming the offender, which the death penalty does not allow. Therefore,
this theory does not support John Z.'s execution.
1.2 Proportionality in Sentencing
