, CMY3704 ASSIGNMENT 1 (COMPLETE ANSWERS) Semester 2
2025 – DUE August 2025 ;100% trusted ,comprehensive and
complete reliable solution with clear explanation
1. Introduction
South Africa’s penal system is increasingly under scrutiny, not only due
to rising crime rates but also because of enduring systemic challenges
such as prison overcrowding, limited rehabilitative resources, and the
need for more effective sentencing alternatives. These issues raise
important questions about the purpose and effectiveness of
imprisonment as a form of punishment, especially in a democratic
society that values human dignity, social justice, and rehabilitation.
The case of Thabo Mokoena, a convicted offender, presents a valuable
opportunity to critically examine the various forms of imprisonment
recognised within the South African legal framework. By analysing the
nature and types of imprisonment available to the courts, this assignment
aims to assess whether the sentence imposed on Mokoena aligns with
the principles of justice, proportionality, and rehabilitation.
Furthermore, the assignment will explore the legal definitions of key
sentencing concepts, the practical application of imprisonment, and the
social consequences of incarceration. Consideration will also be given to
the broader socioeconomic context in which sentencing decisions are
made—highlighting issues such as poverty, inequality, and their impact
on crime and punishment. In doing so, this paper will provide a holistic
understanding of how imprisonment functions in South Africa and
whether it meets the objectives of criminal justice.
2025 – DUE August 2025 ;100% trusted ,comprehensive and
complete reliable solution with clear explanation
1. Introduction
South Africa’s penal system is increasingly under scrutiny, not only due
to rising crime rates but also because of enduring systemic challenges
such as prison overcrowding, limited rehabilitative resources, and the
need for more effective sentencing alternatives. These issues raise
important questions about the purpose and effectiveness of
imprisonment as a form of punishment, especially in a democratic
society that values human dignity, social justice, and rehabilitation.
The case of Thabo Mokoena, a convicted offender, presents a valuable
opportunity to critically examine the various forms of imprisonment
recognised within the South African legal framework. By analysing the
nature and types of imprisonment available to the courts, this assignment
aims to assess whether the sentence imposed on Mokoena aligns with
the principles of justice, proportionality, and rehabilitation.
Furthermore, the assignment will explore the legal definitions of key
sentencing concepts, the practical application of imprisonment, and the
social consequences of incarceration. Consideration will also be given to
the broader socioeconomic context in which sentencing decisions are
made—highlighting issues such as poverty, inequality, and their impact
on crime and punishment. In doing so, this paper will provide a holistic
understanding of how imprisonment functions in South Africa and
whether it meets the objectives of criminal justice.
