Abstractb
Accountingbmanipulationsbinbthebbankingbindustrybhasbbroughtbaboutbthebdebatebonbthebneedbfo
rbbetterbaccountingbstandardsbthatbarebinternationallybcomparablebandbcanbensurebtransparencybi
nbfinancialbreportingbsobasbtobreflectbthebtruebpicturebofbthebperformancesbofbbanksbandbthusbrefo
rmbglobalbeconomies.bThisbstudybexaminesbthebeffectbofbmandatorybIFRSbadoptionbthatbstartedbi
nbNigeriabinbyearb2012,bonbthebvaluebrelevancebofbfinancialbreportsbandbpro-
cyclicalitybofb14bselectedbdepositbmoneybbanksbinbNigeria.bThebstudybformulatesbthreebhypothe
sesbandbappliesbcorrelationalbdesign,busingbpanelbdatabsetbtobanalyzebthebrelationshipbbetweenbv
aluebrelevancebandbIFRS,bandbthebrelationshipbbetweenbpro-
cyclicalitybandbIFRS.bThebstudybutilizedbsecondarybdatabextractedbfrombthebfinancialbstatement
sbofbthebbanksbandbthebWorldbBankbdatabaseboverbthebperiodb2006bthroughb2016.bThebresultbofbt
hebfixedbeffectbGLSbprovidesbevidencebthatbbothbthebvaluebrelevancebofbearningsbandbbookbvalu
ebimprovedbafterbIFRSbwasbmandatorilybadoptedbbybthebselectedbDMBs,bandbthebresultbofbthebra
ndombeffectbGLSbforbpro-
cyclicalitybprovidesbevidencebthatbtheblendingbbehaviorbofbthebselectedbbanksbdidbnotbbecomebm
orebpro-
cyclicalbafterbIFRSbadoption.bThebstudybconcludesbthatbadequatebinformationbdobactuallybboostb
investors‟bconfidencebinbthebfinancialbreportingbofbDMBsbafterbmandatorybadoptionbofbIFRS.bB
asedbonbthebfindings,bthebstudybrecommendsbamongbothersbthatbtherebisbneedbforbthebmanagersbo
fbDepositbMoneybBanksbinbNigeriabtobfurtherbimplementbmonetarybpoliciesbthatbaimsbatbenhanci
ngbinvestors‟bconfidencebinbtheirbreportedbearningsbandbbookbvalue.b
ib
b
,
,.b
CHAPTERbONEb
INTRODUCTIONb
1.1b BackgroundbtobthebStudyb
InternationalbFinancialbReportingbStandardsb(IFRS)bhasbbeenbthebfocusbofbmanybfinancialbacco
untingbstudiesbinbrecentbtimes.bThebglobalbconvergencebtobthebusebofbabcommonbsetbofbinternatio
nalbaccountingbstandardsbinbbusinessbentitiesbtobimprovebfinancialbdisclosurebhasbredirectedbres
earchesbtowardsbanalyzingbthebvaluebrelevancebofbfinancialbreportsbandbthebchangebofbthebstanda
rdbforbthebrecognitionbandbmeasurementbofbloanblossbprovisionbwhichbhasbreceivedbconsiderable
b attentionbandbdebatebworldwide,bespeciallybinbdevelopedbeconomies.b
Financialbreportingbisbthebrecordbofbthebbusinessbeconomicbactivitiesbwhichbaimsbatbmakingbavai
lablebaccountingbinformationbtobinvestors,banalystbandbstakeholdersbforbinvestmentbdecisions.bb
Priorbtob2012,bNigerianbbanksbusedbNigerianbGenerallybAcceptedbAccountingbPrinciplesb(GAA
P)binbpreparingbtheirbfinancialbreports.bValuebrelevancebofbfinancialbreportingbisbfundamentalbas
b accountingbinformationbshowsbthebfinancialbhealthbofbthebbusinessbentitybthatbaffectsbtheirbinve
stmentbefficiency.bThebkeybobjectivebofbempiricalbresearchbonbvaluebrelevancebisbtobexaminebth
ebstatisticalbrelationshipbbetweenbfinancialbreportbvariablesbandbmarketbvariables.bInvestors,bana
lystbandbotherbusersbofbfinancialbstatementsbrelybonbabvarietybofbinformationbincludingbearnings,b
productsbandbdatabinbthebeconomy.b
However,bfraudulentbaccountingbmanipulationbthreatensbthebcredibilitybandbreliabilitybofbfinanc
ialbreportingbwhichbaffectbinvestors‟bconfidencebinbaccountingbnumbers.bGlobalbfinancialbcrisis
b likebthatbofbEnronbCorporationbinb2001,btheblargestbcorporatebfailuresbinbhistorybthatbledbtobthebd
issolutionbofbAuthorbAndersonbauditbandbaccountancybpartnershipsbinbthebworldbhavebputbaccou
ntingbpracticesbandbthebprofessionbunderbinspection,basbthesebscandalsbhasbmadebthebreliabilityba
ndbeffectivenessbofbaccountingbstandardsbquestionable.bSuchbtrendbofbmajorbaccountingbscandal
sbalsobshowedbitsbuglybfacebinbNigeriabwithbthebfalsificationbofbthebfinancialbreportsbinb2006bbyb
1b
b
, CadburybNigeriabPlcbandbinbthebbankingbsector,bthebliquidationbofb26bbanksbinb1997bdespitebtheb
effortsbofbthebCentralbBankbofbNigeriab(CBN)binbenhancingbthebfinancialbdisclosurebofbDepositb
MoneybBanksb(DMBs)bbybissuingbprudentialbguidelinesbforbsupervisionbandbspecificbdirectives.
b ItbisbbasedbonbthisbpremisebthatthebWorldbBankb(2006)bopinesbthatbNigerianbbanksbfinancialbrep
ortingbisbverybpoorbandbsomebbanksbarebknownbtobfalsifybtheirbaccounts.bInbadditionbtobthebforeg
oing,bAshamubandbAbiolab(2012),bstatebthatbtheb2007beconomicbcrisisbonbthebbankingbindustrybo
fbNigeriabhasbcausedbdepressionbofbthebcountry‟sbcapitalbmarket,bdecreasedbthebqualitybofbsomeb
partbofbthebcreditbgivenbbybbanksbforbtradingbinbthebcapitalbmarket.bAllbofbthebaforementionedbev
entsbasbwellbasbthebpostbconsolidationbbankingbcrisisbofb2009binbNigeriabfurtherbincreasedbinvest
mentbriskinessbinbthebmindsbofbstakeholdersbandbhasbincreasedbthebcallbforbimprovingbfinancialbd
isclosures.b
Whereas,bBanksbprovidebfinancingbinbeconomiesbacrossbthebglobebasbpartbofbtheirboperationalbac
tivitiesbbybgivingbcreditbtobcustomersbhence,bhelpingbinbtheballocationbofbresourcesbandbThusbact
b asbcatalystbtobeconomicbgrowth.bHowever,bbanksbarebfacedbwithbcreditbriskbarisingbfrombdefault
b frombcustomersbinbpayingbinterestbonbloanbasbwellbasbthebprincipal.bDuebtobthis,bcreditbriskbmana
gementbisbcrucialbtobbanksbbecausebloanbdefaultsbcouldbaffectbtheirbsolvencybandbleadbtobliquidat
ion.bConsequently,bBanksbarebthereforebrequiredbbyblawbtobmakebLoanbLossbprovisionsb(LLP)bt
obcoverbforbloanbdefaults.bThebStatementbofbAccountingbStandardb(SAS),bspecificallybSASb10bu
nderbNigerianbGAAP,bprovidesbthatbNigerianbdepositbmoneybbanksbrecognizebandbmeasurebrep
ortedbLLPbusingbexpectedblossbapproach,busingbhistoricalbcostbaccounting.bThisbapproachbisbfor
wardblookingbandbgivesbbankbmanagersbthebdiscretionbtobmakebloanblossbprovisionsbbasedbonbth
ebexpectationbthatbborrowersbwillbdefault.b
Itbisbhoweverbarguedbthatbthebexpectedblossbmodelsballowbbankbmanagersbtobusebtheirbdiscretionb
tobmanipulatebbanksbLLP,bbybincreasingbtheirbLLPsbinbgoodbyearsbwhenbprofitsbarebhighbsobasbto
b coverbupbforbbadbyearsbwhenbprofitsbareblow,bmakingbstakeholdersbbelievebthebbanksbarebdoingb
2b
b