LAW QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS WITH
SOLUTIONS 2024
UkufakwaF-
FANSWERFentailsFaFsituationFwhereFaFrelativeFofFaFwoman'sFfatherF(brother,Funcle,Fcousin,Fnephew),FtakesFt
heFresponsibilitiesFofFtheFfatherFandFensuresFthatFtheFcustomaryFtraditionsFandFceremoniesFrelatedFtoFtheF
initiationFand/orFmarriageFofFtheFfather'sFdaughterFareFcarriedFoutFasFifFtheFrelativeFhimselfFwasFtheFfather.
FThisFentitlesFtheFrelativeFtoFaFproFrataFportionFofFtheFvalueFofFtheFloboloFgoods,FexpectedFfromFtheFmarriag
eFgoodsFdeliverableFwhenFtheFdaughterFgetsFmarried,ForFreceivedFasFfinesFimposedFasFaFresultFofFdelictsFco
mmittedFonFthatFdaughter
TheFrelativeFtherebyFgetsFentitledFtoFsuchFportionFasFofFright,FdirectlyFfromFitsFsourceF(thatFis,FasFtheFgoodsF
areFidentifiedFforFdeliveryFasFloboloFgoods,FtheFrelevantFportionFalreadyFatFthatFstage,FbelongsFtoFtheFrelati
ve.FThisFisFtoFsay,FthatFportionFneverFstartsFbelongingFtoFtheFfatherFfromFtheFbeginningFandFtheFfatherFdoesF
notFhaveFaccessFtoFit.FToFtheFextentFofFthisFportion,FtheFrelativeFbecomesFtheFfatherFofFtheFdaughterFinFhisF
ownFright.FHeFdoesFnotFhaveFtoFclaimFtheFportionFfromFtheFpropertyFofFtheFfatherFsinceFitFalreadyFbelongsFt
oFhim.
MabuzaFvFMbathaF-FANSWERFLegalFqF-
FWhetherFseSwatiFcustomaryFmarriagesFcanbeFvaildFwithoutFtheFobservanceFofFtheFukumekezaFcustom?
ReasonsFforFjudgementF-
FaFproperlyFconstitutedFcustomaryFmarriageFcanFstandFwhereFtheFspousesFwaivedFtheFobservanceFofFtheFu
kumekezaFcustom,FparticularlyFasFtheFurbanFconditionsFareFnotFevenFsuitableFforFtheFperformanceFofFsuchF
aFcustom,FwhichFwasFsuitableFforFtheFruralFconditionsFofFtheFpast
DecisionFofFcourtF-FtheFvalidityFofFtheFcustomaryFmarriageFwasFupheld
MabenaFvFLetsoaloF-FANSWERFLegalFqF-
FwhetherFaFcustomaryFmarriageFisFvaludFwhereFaFyoungFman,FinFtheFabsenceFofFhisFfather,FnegociatedFhisFo
wnFcustomaryFmarriage,FtogettherFwithFhisFprosepecticeFmother-in-
law,FwhoFactedFasFtheFguardianFofFtheFprospectiveFbride,FinFtheFabsenceFofFherFhusband
reasonsFforFjudgementF-
FanFadultFandFindeptendeFmanFisFqualifiedFtoFnegociateFhisFownFcustomaryFmarriage,FinFtheFabsenceFofFhisF
father;FandFtheFmotherFofFtheFbrideFasFanFadultFguardianFofFherFdaughterFisFequallyFqualifiedFtoFnegociateF
, theFcustomaryFmarriageFandFtoFacceptFdelivieryFofFtheFmarriageFgoods,FinFtheFabsenceFofFherFhudbandFwh
oFhasFdissertedFtheFfamily.F
decisionFofFcourtF-FtheFvalidityFofFtheFcustomaryFmarriageFwasFupheld
NgwenyamaFvFMayelaneF-FANSWERFLegalFqF-
FtheFSCAFwasFasekdFwhetherFtheFjudgementFofFtheFHighFCourtFisFvalidFwhereFitFheldFthatFaFcustomaryFmarr
iageFconcludedFwithoutFseekingFcourtFapprovalFforFtheFsectionF7(6)FofFtheFRCMAFapplicationFisFinvalid?
reasonsFforFjudgementF-
FtheFSCAFheld:FnonFobservanceFofFtheFsectionF7(6)FofFtheFRCMAFprovsionsFcannotFrenderFaFcustomaryFmarr
iageFinvlaidFasFtheseFareFnotFrequirementsFforFvalidity.FTheFvalidityFrequirementsFareFsetFoutFinFsectionF7(6
)FofFtheFRCMAFandFwereFproperlyFcompliedFwith.FNonFobservanceFofFtheFsectionF7(6)FofFtheFRCMAFprovisi
onsFcanFatFmostFrenderFtheFcustomaryFmarriageFoutFofFcommunityFofFproperty.F
DecsionFofFcourtF-FtheFSCAFupheldFtheFappeal
MayelaneFvFNgwenyamaF-FANSWERFLegalFqF-
FinFanFappeal,FtheFConFCourtFwasFaskedFwhetherFtheFSCAFwasFcorrectFinFholdingFthatFnon-
observanceFofFtheFsectionF7(6)FofFtheFRCMAFprovisionsFcannotFrenderFaFcustomaryFmarriageFinvalidFasFthe
seFareFnotFrequiremetnsFforFvalidity;FandFthatFtheFvalidityFrequirementsFasFsetFoutFinFsectionF3FofFtheFRCM
AFhadFbeenFproperlyFcompliedFwith.
reasonsFforFjudgementF-
FtheFConCourtFendorsedFtheFSCA'sFdecisionFthatFtheFnonFobservanceFofFtheFsectionF7(6)FofFtheFRCMAFprovi
sionsFcannotFrenderFaFcustomaryFmarraigeFasFtheseFareFnotFrequirementsFforFvalidity
DecisionFofFcourtF-FConCourtFdismissedFtheFappealFandFconfirmedFtheFdecisionFofFtheFSCA.
BheFvFMagistrateFKhayelitshaF-FANSWERFLegalFqF-
FtheFConCourtFwasFaskedFtoFconfirmFaFWesternFCapeFhighFCourtFdecisionFtogetherFwithFaFNorthFGauengFHi
ghFCourtFdecisionFbothFofFwhichFhadFdeclaredFtheFmaleFprimogenitireFruleFwhichFpreferedFseniorFmalesFinF
theFcustomaryFlawFofFintestateFsuccessionFunconsitutionalFandFsetFitFaside