Chapter 26
Defences
26.1 The basics:
D denying that he is liable to the C because he did nothing wrong-> Volenti non fit injuria (no
wrong is done to the willing)
D arguing he is not liable to the C because, even if he did something wrong to the C, the C
still cannot sue him for reasons of public policy, or the proper administration of justice.
The distinction ^ is important for the purpose of evaluating whether or not a particular
defence should be recognised or not.
The NWDs need no justification.
PPDs (Illegality (ex turpi causa non oritur action)) are in need of very strong justification if
they are to be recognised-> ‘the rule of public policy that has first claim on the loyalty of the
law [is] that wrongs should be remedied.’
26.9 Volenti non fit injuria (no wrong is done to the willing; consent)
A. The rule:
- 1. Fully consenting
- 2. If C willingly took the risk that she would suffer that kind of loss in the way she
suffered it. 2=more controversial
- Morris v Murray [1991] -> two guys getting drunk. D suggests to ‘go on a flight on the
plane’. C agrees. They get on the plane-> it crashes; C very injured. C simply agreed. It
wasn’t going on the plane that caused the injury-> it was D’s careless driving. C didn’t
consent to the specific manoeuvre that resulted in the wreckage. Only consented to
risky actions. The claim fails-> court states that there was enough consent there-> the
consent of getting onto a plane with a drunk pilot is consenting to this kind of risk.
- C consents to, or goes along with, some activity which poses a risk to C if D is negligent
- C must know of the risk and voluntarily take it (cf rescue)
- Depends on gravity of the risk
B. Exceptions to the rule:
- Paternalistic duties-> A owed B a duty to stop B harming herself.
- Traffic accidents-> Road Traffic Act 1988-> “The fact that a [passenger] has
willingly accepted as his the risk of negligence eon the part of the [driver] shall
not be treated as negativing any… liability of the [driver].”
- The fireman’s rule=non exception. Some American states have adopted what is
known as the fireman’s rule under which someone whose job involves the risk of
suffering a particular kind of loss cannot seek to recover compensatory damages
if he actually suffers that kind of loss in doing his job.
- Objectively risky doesn’t count-> C has to know what they are getting into-> free
and voluntary choice to do so. Doesn’t cover cases of rescue
- Attempting to rescue someone and getting injured-> you’ve introduced yourself
to the danger
- Not acting voluntarily there ^-> acting under moral compulsion
- Voluntary=can reasonable say no but choose to get involved-> not the type in
rescue
- Rescuers want to be rewarded
- Certain sorts of risks aren’t pinned on the C who took them
Defences
26.1 The basics:
D denying that he is liable to the C because he did nothing wrong-> Volenti non fit injuria (no
wrong is done to the willing)
D arguing he is not liable to the C because, even if he did something wrong to the C, the C
still cannot sue him for reasons of public policy, or the proper administration of justice.
The distinction ^ is important for the purpose of evaluating whether or not a particular
defence should be recognised or not.
The NWDs need no justification.
PPDs (Illegality (ex turpi causa non oritur action)) are in need of very strong justification if
they are to be recognised-> ‘the rule of public policy that has first claim on the loyalty of the
law [is] that wrongs should be remedied.’
26.9 Volenti non fit injuria (no wrong is done to the willing; consent)
A. The rule:
- 1. Fully consenting
- 2. If C willingly took the risk that she would suffer that kind of loss in the way she
suffered it. 2=more controversial
- Morris v Murray [1991] -> two guys getting drunk. D suggests to ‘go on a flight on the
plane’. C agrees. They get on the plane-> it crashes; C very injured. C simply agreed. It
wasn’t going on the plane that caused the injury-> it was D’s careless driving. C didn’t
consent to the specific manoeuvre that resulted in the wreckage. Only consented to
risky actions. The claim fails-> court states that there was enough consent there-> the
consent of getting onto a plane with a drunk pilot is consenting to this kind of risk.
- C consents to, or goes along with, some activity which poses a risk to C if D is negligent
- C must know of the risk and voluntarily take it (cf rescue)
- Depends on gravity of the risk
B. Exceptions to the rule:
- Paternalistic duties-> A owed B a duty to stop B harming herself.
- Traffic accidents-> Road Traffic Act 1988-> “The fact that a [passenger] has
willingly accepted as his the risk of negligence eon the part of the [driver] shall
not be treated as negativing any… liability of the [driver].”
- The fireman’s rule=non exception. Some American states have adopted what is
known as the fireman’s rule under which someone whose job involves the risk of
suffering a particular kind of loss cannot seek to recover compensatory damages
if he actually suffers that kind of loss in doing his job.
- Objectively risky doesn’t count-> C has to know what they are getting into-> free
and voluntary choice to do so. Doesn’t cover cases of rescue
- Attempting to rescue someone and getting injured-> you’ve introduced yourself
to the danger
- Not acting voluntarily there ^-> acting under moral compulsion
- Voluntary=can reasonable say no but choose to get involved-> not the type in
rescue
- Rescuers want to be rewarded
- Certain sorts of risks aren’t pinned on the C who took them