• ¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis
  • Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
  • Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
  • Leer en línea o como PDF
Vender
¿Dónde estudias?
Tu idioma
Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 12 páginas
Study guide

Hobbes

Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 12 páginas

Hobbes - government is justified because without it we will destroy each other. What reason do you have to agree to be subject to government and its laws? Isn’t it much better to be free and do your own thing? Hobbes made a name for himself by arguing that if you were free of government, chances are that you would not be able to do your own thing at all. Without government, there’s nothing stopping others from killing you, or taking what you possess, or bursting your balloon. You and everyone else would all be living in what he called a ‘state of nature’, in which you could not count for protection on anyone but yourself. Given that the state of nature would be pretty awful, you have reason to agree to be subject to the power of a ‘Sovereign’, as long as everyone else agrees to be subject to the same power.

Vista previa del contenido

Lecture:
State, government and coercion:
- Topic: the justification of coercion & governmental authority.
- We will ask:
o Can we justify coercive political authority?
o If so, what ought such authority to look like?
 Are we okay with democratic authority but not archaic?
o How can we achieve just and stable political institutions?
 To survive
- We begin with the richest tradition in political theory
o Political authority rests on a ‘Social Contract’
o Hobbes; Kant; Rawls; Rousseau
The ‘social contract’ as a liberal idea:
- Liberalism… in justifying government:
o Does not appeal to God, the ‘spirit of the people’, the ‘common good’
o Puts individuals at the centre
 Justifying government to each and every person who is subject under the authority
o Treats justification of government as owed to every person under it
o Takes all persons to be free and equal
 Assumption
 Because they’re free, burden of justifying government placed on the one trying to impose a government
- The challenge for liberals
o Find one story that justifies government to every person
- Candidate story #1: ‘Political authority rests on consent’
o Problems of this story:
 No existing authority meets test fully, but test itself may be too strict
 People are born into systems- no-one is asked whether they’re okay with having a government
 What if you give your consent but then change your mind? Logistical struggle
 Should there be checks of consent?
o Not all coercion needs consent (e.g. self-defence, duties of care etc)
o Some persons unable to give consent (babies; unconscious patients)
o Obtaining/giving consent for everything can be cumbersome (GDPR)
From consent to social contract:
- Candidate #2: ‘Political authority rests on hypothetical consent’
o If you have reason to want government to be democratic, and your government already is democratic, government is
justified to you.
o But: having reason to want something ≠ consent (e.g. contracts)
 Shouldn’t be bound just because certain conditions are met
 Need to be able to back out
o A hypothetical agreement is not an agreement at all’ (Dworkin)
 Not asking view at all- just saying, well you have reason to agree to you should agree. Individual not
involved in the transaction - merely passive and receiving which isn’t liberalism
- Candidate #3: ‘Political authority rests on implicit consent’
o If you want some things (security; fairness; freedoms etc), and getting them requires existence of government, you
consent to government.
 If you want the end [government], then you also want the means.
o Social contract: implicit social agreement to live under government
o Different ways to identify existence & content of that agreement
o Rawls: ‘contract’ metaphor reminds us that our social agreement is
 Public
 Between equals
 Not a list of our preferences, but of our commitments to others [contracts] - record of what you’re
committed to.
Hobbes:
- Born in 1588, dies in 1679.
- From 1640 to 1651 flees English civil war between Parliamentarians and Royalists, lives in France.
o The fragility of politics
- Influenced by the ‘new science’ of Galileo and Descartes
- Enlightenment person: Hobbes tries to construct a rational and scientific account of political authority, without any resort to
the supernatural.

Información del documento

Estudio
Subido en
18 de marzo de 2020
Número de páginas
12
Escrito en
2019/2020
Tipo
Study guide
$4.71

¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis Dentro de los 14 días posteriores a la compra y antes de descargarlo, puedes elegir otro documento. Puedes gastar el importe de nuevo.
Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
Leer en línea o como PDF

Seller avatar
Los indicadores de reputación están sujetos a la cantidad de artículos vendidos por una tarifa y las reseñas que ha recibido por esos documentos. Hay tres niveles: Bronce, Plata y Oro. Cuanto mayor reputación, más podrás confiar en la calidad del trabajo del vendedor.
topqualitynotes
4.5
(2)
Vendido
59
Seguidores
43
Artículos
97
Última venta
2 semanas hace



Por qué los estudiantes eligen Stuvia

Creado por compañeros estudiantes, verificado por reseñas

Calidad en la que puedes confiar: escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron y evaluado por otros que han usado estos resúmenes.

¿No estás satisfecho? Elige otro documento

¡No te preocupes! Puedes elegir directamente otro documento que se ajuste mejor a lo que buscas.

Paga como quieras, empieza a estudiar al instante

Sin suscripción, sin compromisos. Paga como estés acostumbrado con tarjeta de crédito y descarga tu documento PDF inmediatamente.

Student with book image

“Comprado, descargado y aprobado. Así de fácil puede ser.”

Alisha Student

Preguntas frecuentes