NTP666 Exam 1 With Complete
Solution
behavioral definition of Consciousness - Answer The availability of of a rich behavioral
repertoire
Functional Definition of Consciousness - Answer The ability to perform certain cognitive
functions
Neurological definition of consciousness - Answer Brain activity with behavior
Neural Correlate of Consciousness - Answer The minimal neuronal mechanisms jointly
sufficient for any one conscious perception
Specific NCC - Answer And physical mechanisms (neurons) whose activity determines a
particular phenomenal distinction within an experience. There is a one to one
correspondence between an experience and a NCC
Full NCC - Answer Physical substrate supporting conscious experience in tier entirety
Theoretical - Answer An experience is a cause-effect structure
A theory of consciousness should have - Answer Should have as a scope consciousness
as subjective experience
Should be logical and self-consistent
Should account for known facts about consciousness and the brain
Should make testable predictions (ideally using a mathematical framework) allowing
researchers to further challenge it or validate it in counter-intuitive cases
Neuroscience techniques to investigate consciousness - Answer Lesion studies -
Causal/strong evidence for any given structure, but plasticity may lead to functional
reorganization in chronic cases
Stimulation studies: perturbational - immediate effects provide strong evidence for a
given structure being causally involved but not specific effects may be related to
network recruitment
Recording and Neuroimaging Studies: Correlational - can help study a large number of
different conditions but evidence is correlational
Strong Evidence so far - Answer Cerebellum or hippocampus not NCC
Cortico-thalmic system is important
,Posterior brain regions are important
Feedback connections are important
Debate goes on - Answer Role of the striatum
Role of the thalamus
Role of the claustrum
Role of primary versus higher-level cortical regions
Role of prefrontal cortex
Role of different cell types or cortical layers
Cortico-thalamic system - Answer Widespread lesions of the cortico-thalamic region
causes irreversible coma
Ablation of Cerebellum does not cause loss of consciousness
Hippocampal lesions does not cause loss of consciousness but impair some
consciousness contents
Bilateral basal ganglia lesions/degeneration do not cause unconsciousness
Cortex vs activating systems - Answer Ach increases during REM sleep
But arousal in VG state
Dreaming 2/3 of the time in NREM
Claustrum stimulation causes unconsciousness
But bilateral claustrum lesion do not cause unconsciousness
Cortex vs Thalamus - Answer Coma/VS can be observed after bilateral thalamic lesions
but these lesions also recruit neighboring white matter tracks to the brain stem and
arousal centers
Pure thalamic lesions do not cause coma
Loss of consc during anesthesia coincides with cortical slowing while thalamus is
awake.
During REM sleep there is preserved cortical arousal while the thalamus sleeps
Primary vs higher level cortical areas - Answer V1 can track stimulus properties but less
reliably consciousness contents
Lesions in V1 can induce blindsight
, TMS can induce phosphenes in the absence of V1
Primary sensory cortices activity preserved in loss of consc during deep sleep and
anesthesia
Higher-level areas can be activated by blindsight too
High decodability for Consc Contents in V1-V2 in some working memory studies
Dorsal Vs. Ventral Stream - Answer Lesion in one stream may have effects on the other
stream such as through overall cortical thinning
Dorsal stream can also be activated for 'what'
unconscious activation of ventral stream can occur.
So ventral stream activation is not sufficient for consciousness
Lateral-fronto vs. medial default systems - Answer Common decrease in fronto-parietal
metabolism in coma, VS, anesthesia and sleep
Anticorrelations decrease with unconsc
But lower-level sensory networks best differentiate MCS from VS patients at the
single-subject level
Posterior vs Anterior PFC - Answer Large prefrontal cortex resections/lesions do not
cause unconsciousness
Persistent vegitative state after posterior traumatic brain injury
Restricted diffusion in posterior brain (Occipital, Parietal, and Puntamen) predicts
outcome after anoxic brain injury
Large PFC lesions does not predict unconsciousness
But large posterior brain lesions do predict unconsciousness
Feedforward vs feedback - Answer Decreased feedback connectivity during loss of
consciousness induced by anesthesia and VS
In particular, blockade of cortical feedback to apical dendrites of cortical neurons may
be responsible for LOC during anesthesia (up and down)
Increased feedback activity for perceived vs unperceived somatosensory stimuli
Backward masking disrupts feedback connectivity and suppresses stimulus perception
Stimulus perception is also disrupted by by TMS blocking feedback activity on V1
Phosphenes can be induced by mimicking feedback connectivity from V5 to V1 using
TMS
Solution
behavioral definition of Consciousness - Answer The availability of of a rich behavioral
repertoire
Functional Definition of Consciousness - Answer The ability to perform certain cognitive
functions
Neurological definition of consciousness - Answer Brain activity with behavior
Neural Correlate of Consciousness - Answer The minimal neuronal mechanisms jointly
sufficient for any one conscious perception
Specific NCC - Answer And physical mechanisms (neurons) whose activity determines a
particular phenomenal distinction within an experience. There is a one to one
correspondence between an experience and a NCC
Full NCC - Answer Physical substrate supporting conscious experience in tier entirety
Theoretical - Answer An experience is a cause-effect structure
A theory of consciousness should have - Answer Should have as a scope consciousness
as subjective experience
Should be logical and self-consistent
Should account for known facts about consciousness and the brain
Should make testable predictions (ideally using a mathematical framework) allowing
researchers to further challenge it or validate it in counter-intuitive cases
Neuroscience techniques to investigate consciousness - Answer Lesion studies -
Causal/strong evidence for any given structure, but plasticity may lead to functional
reorganization in chronic cases
Stimulation studies: perturbational - immediate effects provide strong evidence for a
given structure being causally involved but not specific effects may be related to
network recruitment
Recording and Neuroimaging Studies: Correlational - can help study a large number of
different conditions but evidence is correlational
Strong Evidence so far - Answer Cerebellum or hippocampus not NCC
Cortico-thalmic system is important
,Posterior brain regions are important
Feedback connections are important
Debate goes on - Answer Role of the striatum
Role of the thalamus
Role of the claustrum
Role of primary versus higher-level cortical regions
Role of prefrontal cortex
Role of different cell types or cortical layers
Cortico-thalamic system - Answer Widespread lesions of the cortico-thalamic region
causes irreversible coma
Ablation of Cerebellum does not cause loss of consciousness
Hippocampal lesions does not cause loss of consciousness but impair some
consciousness contents
Bilateral basal ganglia lesions/degeneration do not cause unconsciousness
Cortex vs activating systems - Answer Ach increases during REM sleep
But arousal in VG state
Dreaming 2/3 of the time in NREM
Claustrum stimulation causes unconsciousness
But bilateral claustrum lesion do not cause unconsciousness
Cortex vs Thalamus - Answer Coma/VS can be observed after bilateral thalamic lesions
but these lesions also recruit neighboring white matter tracks to the brain stem and
arousal centers
Pure thalamic lesions do not cause coma
Loss of consc during anesthesia coincides with cortical slowing while thalamus is
awake.
During REM sleep there is preserved cortical arousal while the thalamus sleeps
Primary vs higher level cortical areas - Answer V1 can track stimulus properties but less
reliably consciousness contents
Lesions in V1 can induce blindsight
, TMS can induce phosphenes in the absence of V1
Primary sensory cortices activity preserved in loss of consc during deep sleep and
anesthesia
Higher-level areas can be activated by blindsight too
High decodability for Consc Contents in V1-V2 in some working memory studies
Dorsal Vs. Ventral Stream - Answer Lesion in one stream may have effects on the other
stream such as through overall cortical thinning
Dorsal stream can also be activated for 'what'
unconscious activation of ventral stream can occur.
So ventral stream activation is not sufficient for consciousness
Lateral-fronto vs. medial default systems - Answer Common decrease in fronto-parietal
metabolism in coma, VS, anesthesia and sleep
Anticorrelations decrease with unconsc
But lower-level sensory networks best differentiate MCS from VS patients at the
single-subject level
Posterior vs Anterior PFC - Answer Large prefrontal cortex resections/lesions do not
cause unconsciousness
Persistent vegitative state after posterior traumatic brain injury
Restricted diffusion in posterior brain (Occipital, Parietal, and Puntamen) predicts
outcome after anoxic brain injury
Large PFC lesions does not predict unconsciousness
But large posterior brain lesions do predict unconsciousness
Feedforward vs feedback - Answer Decreased feedback connectivity during loss of
consciousness induced by anesthesia and VS
In particular, blockade of cortical feedback to apical dendrites of cortical neurons may
be responsible for LOC during anesthesia (up and down)
Increased feedback activity for perceived vs unperceived somatosensory stimuli
Backward masking disrupts feedback connectivity and suppresses stimulus perception
Stimulus perception is also disrupted by by TMS blocking feedback activity on V1
Phosphenes can be induced by mimicking feedback connectivity from V5 to V1 using
TMS