• ¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis
  • Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
  • Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
  • Leer en línea o como PDF
Vender
¿Dónde estudias?
Tu idioma
Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 16 páginas
Resumen

Summary Causation

Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 16 páginas

Considers causation within tort law- extremely important for problem questions.

Vista previa del contenido

Chapter 9

Causation:

9.1 The basics:

 The victim of a breach of a duty of care will not be able to sue in negligence unless she can
show that the breached caused her to suffer an actionable loss.
 ^ If not, compensatory damages no awarded.
 The ‘but for’ test.
 ^ Inadequate-> often paradoxical.
- Limits of the ‘but for’ test:
1. Over-determination-> when C’s injury was brought about by 2 different causes; both of
which would’ve been sufficient to bring the injury. E.g., two gunmen shooting C at the
same time-> the test allows them to both say that ‘but for’ my action, C would’ve died
due to the other gunmen-> no causation found for either. Lambton v Mellish [1894] 3 Ch
163-> example of a court finding causation in an over-determination case.
2. Pre-emption -> cases where although the C’s injury are brought about by D’s action, if
the D hadn’t performed that action, some other force would’ve come into action that
would’ve caused the same result. D’s actions were a pre-emption. For example, D
crashes his car into C (who was on his way to the airport) and who then died. The plane
crashes and everyone dies. C would’ve died regardless; pre-emption. American case->
Dillion v Twin State Gas & Electric.
3. False positive result; e.g. Footballer scores a last minute goal. Gambler loses his bet.
Gambler gets angry and stabs someone in a pub. Cannot be said that Footballer made
Gambler stab someone in a pub, even though Gambler wouldn’t have had been angry
had Footballer not scored that last goal.
 Main additional tests to the ‘but for’ test-> break in the chain of causation test and the
material increase in risk test.
o Break in the chain of causation test-> used to explain the Footballer-Gambler
example. Gambler’s actions were deliberate, informed and voluntary (also
unreasonable).
o Material increase to risk-> Fairchild v Glenhaven [2003]
 The tests may still produce undesirable outcomes. The application of the alternative tests
mean that a breach of a particular duty of care would never give rise to a liability to pay
compensatory damages to the victim of the breach, because the D breaching the duty of
care could always rely on these tests to say that his breach did not cause the victim of the
breach to suffer any loss.
 Chain of causation argument;
Possible for more than one person to cause something to happen.
Academics try to express the distinction between the ‘but for’ test for causation and
tests that are designed to modify or supplement the ‘but for’ test by saying that the
‘but for’ test is concerned with factual causation while tests like the ‘break in the
chain of causation’ and the ‘material increase to risk’ test are concerned with legal
causation. McBride + Bagshaw =/ fans of this distinction because:
1. Doesn’t make sense for the alternative tests to have no bearing on the issue of
whether the D’s actions in fact caused a particular outcome to occur.
2. The distinction between fact and legal causation doesn’t add to our
understanding of the law. Lawyers as prone to lying about causation-> refusing

Libro relacionado
 image
Nicholas J. Mcbride, Roderick Bagshaw Tort Law
Editorial: Desconocido ISBN: 9781292071237 Edición: 5

Información del documento

Estudio
¿Un libro?
Desconocido
Subido en
27 de septiembre de 2019
Número de páginas
16
Escrito en
2017/2018
Tipo
Resumen
$4.71

¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis Dentro de los 14 días posteriores a la compra y antes de descargarlo, puedes elegir otro documento. Puedes gastar el importe de nuevo.
Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
Leer en línea o como PDF

Seller avatar
Los indicadores de reputación están sujetos a la cantidad de artículos vendidos por una tarifa y las reseñas que ha recibido por esos documentos. Hay tres niveles: Bronce, Plata y Oro. Cuanto mayor reputación, más podrás confiar en la calidad del trabajo del vendedor.
topqualitynotes
4.5
(2)
Vendido
59
Seguidores
43
Artículos
97
Última venta
2 semanas hace



Por qué los estudiantes eligen Stuvia

Creado por compañeros estudiantes, verificado por reseñas

Calidad en la que puedes confiar: escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron y evaluado por otros que han usado estos resúmenes.

¿No estás satisfecho? Elige otro documento

¡No te preocupes! Puedes elegir directamente otro documento que se ajuste mejor a lo que buscas.

Paga como quieras, empieza a estudiar al instante

Sin suscripción, sin compromisos. Paga como estés acostumbrado con tarjeta de crédito y descarga tu documento PDF inmediatamente.

Student with book image

“Comprado, descargado y aprobado. Así de fácil puede ser.”

Alisha Student

Preguntas frecuentes