Summary Change Management
Table of contents CHAPTER 1.............................................................................................................2 PPT: Changing organizations in our complex world............................................................................2 CHAPTER 2.............................................................................................................8 PPT: How to lead organizational change: frameworks........................................................................8 CHAPTER 3...........................................................................................................10 PPT: What to change in an organization: frameworks......................................................................10 CHAPTER 4...........................................................................................................14 PPT: Building and energizing the need for change............................................................................14 CHAPTER 5...........................................................................................................18 PPT: Navigating change through formal structures and systems......................................................18 CHAPTER 6...........................................................................................................23 PPT: Navigating organizational politics and culture..........................................................................23 CHAPTER 7...........................................................................................................29 PPT: Managing recipients of change and influencing internal stakeholders.....................................29 CHAPTER 8...........................................................................................................35 PPT: Becoming a master change agent.............................................................................................35 CHAPTER 9...........................................................................................................40 PPT: Action planning and implementation........................................................................................40 CHAPTER 10.........................................................................................................47 PPT: Get and use data throughout the change process....................................................................47 CHAPTER 11.........................................................................................................53 PPT: The future of organizations and the future of change..............................................................53 CHAPTER 1 PPT: Changing organizations in our complex world Organizational change = the intentional and planned alteration of organizational components to improve organizational effectiveness It’s better to have a moderate strategy that is implemented than having the best strategy that doesn’t get implemented Organization components Organization components include the organization’s: Mission and vision Strategy Goals Structure Processes or systems Technology People When organizations enhance their effectiveness, they increase their ability to generate value for those they serve The knowing-doing Gap = knowing concepts and theories is not enough, managers need to become effective agents of change, possessing the will and skills to make positive change happen Change capability has become a core managerial competency but managers’ abilities to deliver on change are modest at best There is a major “knowing-doing” gap knowing concepts and theories is not enough managers need to become effective agents of change, possessing the will and skills to make positive change happen Why is change a Hot Topic? Environmental forces driving change (PESTEL factors): Political change Economic change Social, cultural and demographic New technologies Legal changes Ecological/environmental factors Turbulence and ambiguity define the landscape for both the public and private sectors Jack Welch: a successful big shot CEO of General Electric (made one of the biggest organizations of the world, always trying to be the number one or number two in what they do) “If the rate of change on the outside exceeds the rate of change on the inside, the end is near” – Jack Welch it used to be true but if this was true today, then a lot of companies would be in much trouble example: Nokia, Kodak Gartner Hype Cycle for Emerging Technologies Trends of 2020 if Facebook was a company, it would be the 3rd largest company Logoritmic/algorithmic curve = 1+1+1+1+1… (those are the curves/trends we are using), there was change but the change was gradually Exponential curve = 2*2*2*2… change occurs faster and more often Martec’s Law Technology changes exponentially (fast), yet organizations change at a logarithmic rate Capacity vs demand New organizational Forms & Management Challenges due to environmental change Macro changes and impact Digitization leading to Faster information transmission Lower cost information storage and transmission Integration of states and opening of markets Geographic dispersion of the value chain All leading to globalization of markets New organizational forms and competitive dynamics Global small and medium-sized enterprises Global constellations of organizations Large, focused global firms All leading to: Spread of autonomous, dislocated teams Digitally enabled structures Intense global rivalry and running faster while seeming to stand still New management challenges Greater diversity Greater synchronization requirements Greater time-pacing requirements Faster decision making, learning and innovation More frequent environmental discontinuities Faster industry life-cycles Faster newness and obsolescence of knowledge Risk of competency traps where old competencies no longer produce desired effects Greater newness and obsolescence of organizations Competitive pressures Make sure you don’t get stuck in the red queen phenomenon: running hard, but for all purposes standing still o Called the Red Queen phenomenon In global competition, what matters is not the firm’s absolute rate of learning and innovation, but the relative pace of its development compared to its rivals Life in a VUCA world V = volatile U = uncertain C = complex A = ambiguous Top challenges when it’s about change: 1 Behaviour of people 2 Culture 3 Technology Four types of organizational change Nature of impact of change Short-term impact/consequences o Direct and indirect effects o Moderating factors Intermediate impact/consequences Long-term impact/consequences The lesson: planned changes don’t always produce the intended results Managers think that change is a switch but it’s much more complicated than that it’s an investment that they don’t want to make (but it’s actually a small investment) Common causes of Difficulty with organizational change Managers don’t do their analytic homework Managers are action oriented and assume others will see the inherent wisdom in the proposed change Managers under or overestimate their own power and influence (and that of others) Managers see transition periods as a cost, not an investment They underestimate the resources & commitment needed to integrate the human dimensions with other aspects of the change Managers are unaware their actions (and those of other key managers) may be sending conflicting messages Managers find human processes unsettling or threatening Managers lack capacity (attitudes, skills, and abilities) to manage complex changes that involve people Managers' critical judgment is impaired due to overconfidence, under confidence, and/or group think - Unanticipated external factors can play a huge role 4 organization change roles Change Initiators Identify need and vision Act as a champion Change Implementers Chart the detailed path forward & make it happen Nurture support and alleviate resistance Change Facilitators Aids in analysis and issue management along the way Provides advice and council Sometimes helps smooth the way through helping resolve issues, alleviate resistance and nurture support Change Recipients Those affected by the change who have little input to the process or content of the organizational change Have to alter behaviours to ensure change success Characteristics and skills of the change leader Formal change leaders (or agents) spearhead the change, and may play any or all of the change roles. Informal change leaders can emerge anytime throughout the change process What are the key characteristics and skills of the change leader? What’s required to be a successful change leader? Keen insight into the external environment and skilled anticipator of what is evolving Rich understanding of organizational systems and processes, power structures and stakeholder networks Excellent analytic, interpersonal and communication skills Driving passion for action, yet patient and persistent Well-developed sense of timing and tactics Ability to assess and manage risk An ability to focus on outcomes while also paying very close attention to process Tolerance for ambiguity and risk taking Emotional maturity and courage Self-confidence and optimism Honest and trustworthy Capacity to engage others and inspire confidence Deep understanding of themselves and their impact Curiosity and strong desire to learn Change leaders embrace change paradoxes Recognize that change leaders sometimes drive change from the front, while at other times they empower others and stay out of the way Recognize resistance to change is both a problem and an opportunity Focus on the outcomes of change, but are very careful about the management of the process Recognize the tension between “getting on with it” and reassessing and changing direction Capacity to balance patience and impatience Recognize the absolute rate of learning is less important than the relative rate of learning in comparison to competitors Critical questions when considering change 1 What is the environment telling you prior to, at the beginning, during and following the implementation of the change? In particular: a. What is the broader environment telling you about future economic, social and technological conditions and trends? b. What are your customers or clients (both inside and outside the organization) telling you? c. What are your competitors doing and how are they responding to you? d. What are the partners within your network doing and how are they responding to you? e. What do the people who will potentially be the leaders, managers and recipients of change want and need? 2 Why is change needed? Who sees this need? 3 What is your purpose and agenda? a. How does that purpose project to a worthwhile vision that goes to the heart of the matter? 4 How will you implement and manage the change? a. How will you resource the change initiative? b. How will you select and work with your change team? c. How will you work with the broader organization? d. How will you monitor progress so that you can steer, alter speed and course, if necessary? 5 How will you ensure that you act (and are seen to act) ethically and with integrity? What have I learned about change and how can I remember it for the future? How can I pass on what I learned? 6 Once the change is completed, what comes next? The completion of one change simply serves as the starting point for the next. Summary Need for change often originates in the external environment. Change upsets the internal equilibrium in an organization and thus may be resisted. People can play many different change roles. How they play these roles makes a significant difference! Time for a mindshift! V = volatile V = vision U = uncertain U = understanding C = complex C = clarity A = ambiguous A = agility CHAPTER 2 PPT: How to lead organizational change: frameworks Getting a handle on the change challenge Two distinct aspects in any change management situation need to be addressed: WHAT needs to change HOW to bring about that change Sigmoid Curve Nature of managed organizational change Lewin’s view Kotter’s Eight-Stage process 1 Establishing a sense of urgency 2 Creating a guiding coalition 3 Developing a vision and strategy 4 Communicate the change vision 5 Empower employees 6 Generate short-term wins 7 Consolidate gains and produce more change 8 Anchor the new approaches in the culture Duck’s five-stage change curve Stagnation Preparation Implementation Determination Fruition Beckhard and Harris’ change process model The change path model Awakening = why change? What data helps to wake people up? Mobilization = Gap analysis – the desired future state and the present state Acceleration = getting there from here – action planning and implementation Institutionalization = monitoring, measuring the change, and helping to make the change stick Summary We need to differentiate between WHAT needs to change and HOW to change This module has focused on the HOW change is accomplished, i.e, the process The HOW of change is all about managing the process. This module gives us ways of thinking about this process with particular attention to the Change Path Model CHAPTER 3 Open systems perspective Organizations exchange information, material & energy with their environment, they are NOT isolated A system is the product of its interrelated and interdependent parts It represents a complex web of interrelationships, not a chain of linear cause-effect relationships Dynamic complexity because systems are: Constantly changing Tightly coupled Governed by feedback Nonlinear History-dependent Self-organizing Adaptive Characterized by trade-offs Counterintuitive Policy resistant A system seeks equilibrium and one at equilibrium will only change if energy is applied Individuals within a system may have views of the system’s function and purpose that differ greatly from those of others Things that occur within and/or to open systems should not be viewed in isolation. See them as interconnected, interdependent components of a complex system Nadler & Tushman’s Organizational Congruence Model Linear event view of the world Issues and problems with the linear view: Time delays and lag effects related to variables and outcomes you are trying to manage (e.g., inventory stocks and flows, customer satisfaction and purchase decisions) Complexity makes cause–effect relationships difficult to predict and track Attribution Errors and False Learning often result from the above A feedback model But Feedback Models are Messier Quinn’s competing values framework Greiner’s Five Phases of Organizational Growth Stacy’s Complexity Theory and Organizational Change Organizations are webs of nonlinear feedback loops that are connected with individuals and organizations through similar webs These feedback systems operate in stable and unstable states of equilibrium, even to the point at which chaos ensues Organizations are inherently paradoxes, pulled by forces of stability and instability If organizations give into forces of stability, they become ossified and change impaired If organizations succumb to forces of instability, they will disintegrate Success is when organizations exist between frozen stability and chaos Short-term dynamics (or noise) are characterized by irregular cycles and discontinuous trends, but long-term trends are identifiable A successful organization faces an unknowable specific future because things can and do happen Agents can’t control the long-term future—they can only act in relation to the short term Long-term development is a spontaneous, self-organizing process that may give rise to new strategic directions It is through this process that managers create and come to know the environments and long-term futures of their organizations Summary When assessing organizations, think of them as open systems—webs of interconnected and interdependent relationships that interact with the environment Change often originates in the external environment. Change upsets the internal equilibrium in an organization and thus may beresisted. Both evolutionary and revolutionary change is needed for organizational growth We need to understand the WHY and WHAT of change. Models in this chapter have focused on the WHAT of change Change is not clean and linear—it is messy CHAPTER 4 Recognizing the need for change is not enough! There is no shortage of things needing change Recognizing the need for change is not sufficient “Why change” is aided by solid analysis of what needs to change and why its important to expend resources on this area, but… We need to be able to craft a compelling vision of: o Where we want to go (the desired change) o Why it is worth the effort Have you done your homework? What is your assessment of the need for change and the important dimensions and issues that underpin it? Have you investigated fully the perspectives of internal and external stakeholders? Can the different perspectives be integrated in ways that offer the possibility for collaborative solutions? Have you developed and communicated the need for change in ways that will heighten readiness and willingness to change? Readying and organization for change Need for change is identified in terms of the gap between the current state and the desired state People must believe that the proposed change is the right change People must believe they can accomplish the change The change is supported by key individuals that organizational members look to “What’s in it for me?” has been addressed A second look at readiness 1 Leadership viewed as trustworthy by followers 2 Followers viewed as trustworthy and able to dissent by leaders 3 Have capable Champions of Change 4 Involved middle management 5 Innovative culture 6 Accountable culture 7 Effective communications 8 Systems thinking Rate the organization’s readiness for change Total scores can range from −25 to +50 The higher the score, the more ready the organization is for change o Organizations that score below +10 are likely not ready for change, making change very difficult o Use scores from each area as a guide to focus your attention on those lowscoring sections. What could be done to increase readiness? This tool’s purpose is to raise awareness of the organization’s readiness for change. It is not meant to be used as a formal research tool! Creating awareness of the need for change Create awareness that a crisis is near, or create a crisis that needs to be addressed Develop a transformational vision for the change based on compelling values Find a transformational leader to champion the change Focus on common or shared goals and work out ways to achieve them Create dissatisfaction with status quo through information and education Barriers to recognizing the need for change (“Active Inertia”) Mental models about the world become blinders Past successes reinforce existing practices Existing values and corporate culture may harden into dogma Leadership practices may impede recognition of need for change Embedded systems and processes can harden into unquestioned routines and habits Existing relationships can become shackles that impede the ability to respond to a changing environment Groupthink Illusion of invulnerability Construct rationalizations Morality of position is unquestioned Stereotypes—distort image of other parties Pressure applied to those who express doubts about the group’s position Self-censorship—deviations from consensus are avoided Illusion of unanimity Mind-guards: leaders and fellow members protected from adverse information Overcoming Groupthink Have the leader play an impartial role Actively seek dissenting views. Have members play the role of devil’s advocate Actively discuss and assess the costs, benefits and risks of diverse alternatives Establish a methodical decision-making process at the beginning Ensure an open climate and solicit input from informed outsiders and experts Allow time for reflection and do not mistake silence for consent What is your experience with vision statements? What makes for a good vision statement? What is the difference between a vision for the organization and one for change? What does the organization and senior management want from the vision? How much time, energy and resources should be devoted to creating a vision? Who should be involved? Vision statement = an attempt to articulate what a desired future for a company would look like… an organizational dream. Visions are big pictures According to Tichy and Devanna: Vision statement provides a conceptual framework for understanding the organization’s purpose—the vision includes a road map It has emotional appeal with which people can identify A vision’s value lies in its ability to guide behavior According to Simons: A vision without task is a dream world, and task without vision is drudgery. Approaches to visions for change: Leader-developed vision Leader-senior team-developed vision Bottom-up visioning Thoughts on organizational vision: How do you think an organization should go about developing a vision? Bottom up? Top down? To whom should it be communicated? How should it be communicated? When does an organization need to consider or revisit its vision? Good visions: Clear, concise, easily understandable Memorable Exciting and inspiring Challenging Excellence-centered Stable but flexible Implementable and tangible Why is it necessary to have a vision? A vision enhances performance measures It promotes change and provides a basis for a strategic plan It motivates individuals and facilitates recruitment It establishes a context for decision making What is a useful vision? A useful vision focuses on the future Vision integrates three factors: o Mission: What business are we in? What’s our reason for being and our fundamental values? o Culture: The enactment of who we are in our values, beliefs, rituals, etc., relative to ourselves, our coworkers and our clients o Strategy: How are we to achieve our mission and our competitive advantage? Why do visions fail? Senior management’s walk doesn’t match the talk Ignores needs of those putting it into practice Unrealistic expectations develop that can’t be met Lacks grounding in the reality of the present Either too abstract or too concrete Lack of creative input Poor management of participation Complacency—no sense of urgency The vision trap Watch for vision creep Get back to basics: o Language people can identify with o Language people can do something with and focus upon o Vision that engages and energizes and is not abstract and ambiguous Organizational vision and change vision The approach to vision crafting remains the same but the focus shifts and becomes more specific around the particular change you have in mind The change leader’s goals are advanced when they develop or facilitate the development of a compelling change vision that appeals to groups critical to the change initiative and effectively communicate it to them Checklist for creating the readiness for change What is the objective need for change? What are the consequences to the organization of changing or not changing? Are people aware of these risks? Are members aware of the need for change? Do they feel the need for change or do they deny its need? How can they be informed? Individuals are motivated toward change when they perceive the benefits as outweighing the costs. Do they see the benefits as outweighing the costs? What can you do to ensure this is the case? If individuals believe the benefits outweigh the costs, do they also believe the probability of success is great enough to warrant the risk taking and needed investment of time and energy? Are there other alternatives that are more attractive to them? What is it about their costs, benefits, and risks? How should these alternatives be addressed by the change leader? Summary Change occurs when there is an understanding of the need for change, the vision of where the organization should go, and a commitment to action Change leaders need to address the question “Why change?” and develop both a sound rationale for the change and a compelling vision of a possible future. To develop the rationale, you need to do your homework! Careful assessment is used to understand and communicate the need for change and the organization’s readiness for change. The motives and interests of key stakeholders forms part of this assessment. CHAPTER 5 PPT: Navigating change through formal structures and systems How do structures and systems relate to change management? Existing formal structures and systems need to be understood when assessing the need for change. Need to understand how Structures and Systems facilitate or hinder change Need to understand how Structures and Systems can be used to gain approval for change Need to understand how Structures and Systems can be used to gain acceptance and promote for organizational change Need to understand how to create more adaptive Structures and Systems Making sense of organizational structures and systems Mechanistic vs organic organizational forms
Información del documento
- Subido en
- 12 de febrero de 2024
- Número de páginas
- 48
- Escrito en
- 2023/2024
- Tipo
- Examen
- Contiene
- Preguntas y respuestas