CLIP
Rights in Design Consolidation
Product design
• Relevant to businesses which manufacture products and invest in their design.
• Products defined as tangible articles:
o Which occupy 3 dimensions in space; and
o Are human-made (as opposed to commodities – raw materials, agricultural etc)
IPRs that can protect product design
• Registered Design Right (RDR): A product design can be registered at the Intellectual Property Office
provided it meets statutory criteria, which are all related to its appearance.
• Unregistered Design Right (UDR): All original products enjoy automatic UDR.
RDR Registrability
1. Design under s.1?
• S.1(2) provides that a design is the ‘appearance of the whole or a part of a product resulting from the
features of, in particular, the lines, contours, colours, shape, texture or materials of the product or its
ornamentation.’
• Consider what is interesting about the product
• Registration protects the design of a product, but not the product itself. This means that a single design
may be applied to different products.
• Exam: describe the product when determining if it is a design under s.1(2). If given wording, use
same wording when defining. If given a picture, then describe.
2. Product under s.1(3)?
• S.1(3) provides that a product may be an ‘industrial or handicraft’ item.
• Some products have protection under the CDPA as a work of artistic craftsmanship and by registering the
design of the product under the RDA.
• Product expressly includes packaging and get up, symbols and typefaces.
• Complex products
o S.1(3) – a complex product is one that has at least two replaceable component parts that can be
taken apart and put back together again.
o Examples = car, computer. High threshold.
o The overall design of a complex product can be registered.
o S.1B(8)(a) → the design of a component part of a complex product will only be registrable if it
remains visible during normal use by the end user.
▪ Ie what is under the bonnet of car isn’t protected.
• Exam: confirm if it is an industrial or handicraft item. Check that it doesn’t fall under one of the computer-
based exceptions in the definition of product.
3. Novelty under s.1B(2), (5), (7)?
• The design must be ‘new’ and hand ‘individual character’ and must not fall within any of the exclusions.
• Novelty
o S.1B(2) – there must be no other identical design (or design whose feature differ only in
immaterial details) made ‘available to the public’ before the ‘relevant date’.
▪ S.1B(5) – ‘made available to the public’ widely construed.
▪ S.1B(7) – ‘relevant date’ = the date of the application to register the design.
o Any public disclosure of the design made before the date of application for registration will
prevent the design from being new – this includes any exhibition.
▪ Unless it could not reasonably have become known’ to persons carrying on business in
the UK and specialising s.1B(6)(a) – a very obscure disclosure will not prevent a design
from being new.
o Before seeking to register a design, the applicant must:
▪ Ensure that they haven’t made the design available to the public (e.g. demonstration)
▪ Check that their design is not exactly the same or virtually identical to other designs that
are already available to the public anywhere in the world.
• Grace period – s.1B(6)(c) and (d)
o The owner of a design has a 12 month period during which they can put the product on the
market before registering the design. They can apply for registration after this, provided the 12
month period hasn’t expired.
o The design will not be protected by registration during the grace period. Instead, the owner will
have to rely in the meantime on the weaker UDR. If a third party independently discloses a
virtually identical design right in that period, the design will not be new at the relevant date – risky.
• Confidentiality – s.1B(6)(b)
o A disclosure of the design under conditions of confidentiality will not destroy the design’s novelty.
Rights in Design Consolidation
Product design
• Relevant to businesses which manufacture products and invest in their design.
• Products defined as tangible articles:
o Which occupy 3 dimensions in space; and
o Are human-made (as opposed to commodities – raw materials, agricultural etc)
IPRs that can protect product design
• Registered Design Right (RDR): A product design can be registered at the Intellectual Property Office
provided it meets statutory criteria, which are all related to its appearance.
• Unregistered Design Right (UDR): All original products enjoy automatic UDR.
RDR Registrability
1. Design under s.1?
• S.1(2) provides that a design is the ‘appearance of the whole or a part of a product resulting from the
features of, in particular, the lines, contours, colours, shape, texture or materials of the product or its
ornamentation.’
• Consider what is interesting about the product
• Registration protects the design of a product, but not the product itself. This means that a single design
may be applied to different products.
• Exam: describe the product when determining if it is a design under s.1(2). If given wording, use
same wording when defining. If given a picture, then describe.
2. Product under s.1(3)?
• S.1(3) provides that a product may be an ‘industrial or handicraft’ item.
• Some products have protection under the CDPA as a work of artistic craftsmanship and by registering the
design of the product under the RDA.
• Product expressly includes packaging and get up, symbols and typefaces.
• Complex products
o S.1(3) – a complex product is one that has at least two replaceable component parts that can be
taken apart and put back together again.
o Examples = car, computer. High threshold.
o The overall design of a complex product can be registered.
o S.1B(8)(a) → the design of a component part of a complex product will only be registrable if it
remains visible during normal use by the end user.
▪ Ie what is under the bonnet of car isn’t protected.
• Exam: confirm if it is an industrial or handicraft item. Check that it doesn’t fall under one of the computer-
based exceptions in the definition of product.
3. Novelty under s.1B(2), (5), (7)?
• The design must be ‘new’ and hand ‘individual character’ and must not fall within any of the exclusions.
• Novelty
o S.1B(2) – there must be no other identical design (or design whose feature differ only in
immaterial details) made ‘available to the public’ before the ‘relevant date’.
▪ S.1B(5) – ‘made available to the public’ widely construed.
▪ S.1B(7) – ‘relevant date’ = the date of the application to register the design.
o Any public disclosure of the design made before the date of application for registration will
prevent the design from being new – this includes any exhibition.
▪ Unless it could not reasonably have become known’ to persons carrying on business in
the UK and specialising s.1B(6)(a) – a very obscure disclosure will not prevent a design
from being new.
o Before seeking to register a design, the applicant must:
▪ Ensure that they haven’t made the design available to the public (e.g. demonstration)
▪ Check that their design is not exactly the same or virtually identical to other designs that
are already available to the public anywhere in the world.
• Grace period – s.1B(6)(c) and (d)
o The owner of a design has a 12 month period during which they can put the product on the
market before registering the design. They can apply for registration after this, provided the 12
month period hasn’t expired.
o The design will not be protected by registration during the grace period. Instead, the owner will
have to rely in the meantime on the weaker UDR. If a third party independently discloses a
virtually identical design right in that period, the design will not be new at the relevant date – risky.
• Confidentiality – s.1B(6)(b)
o A disclosure of the design under conditions of confidentiality will not destroy the design’s novelty.