- Task 2 Simulation
CASE BACKGROUND: MAPLE VALLEY HOSPITAL (MVH)
Organizational Profile:
● Maple Valley Hospital (MVH): 150-bed, not-for-profit community hospital in a mid-sized
suburban market
● Mission: "To improve the health and well-being of our community through compassionate,
high-quality, accessible care"
● Current Financial Status: Operating margin of 2.1%; seeking service line diversification to
improve sustainability
● Service Area: Primary Service Area (PSA) = 250,000 residents; Secondary Service Area (SSA) =
additional 180,000
Proposed Service Line:
The Maple Valley Bariatric Surgery Center of Excellence — A comprehensive, multidisciplinary
program offering:
● Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass (RYGB)
● Sleeve Gastrectomy (SG)
● Revisional bariatric procedures
● Integrated medical weight management program
● Long-term follow-up and support services
Strategic Context:
● Adult obesity rate in PSA: 35% (vs. state average: 30%)
● Current market leakage: 65% of bariatric candidates travel 45+ miles to "Metro Surgical
Institute" (competitor)
● No accredited bariatric program within 40 miles of MVH
● Local employer demand: Three major employers (total 12,000 employees) have expressed
interest in enhanced weight management benefits
PHASE 1: MARKET & NEEDS ASSESSMENT
Questions 1-8: Analyzing market opportunity, competitive landscape, and community need
,Q1: Market Demand Calculation [Numerical Entry]
Data Provided:
● PSA Population: 250,000 adults
● Adult obesity rate: 35%
● National bariatric surgery candidacy rate among obese adults: 2% annually
● Historical conversion rate from candidate to scheduled surgery (national benchmark): 40%
● MVH capture goal (Year 3): 25% of converted candidates
Calculate the estimated Year 3 target surgical volume for MVH based on market potential
alone.
Your Answer: __________ procedures
Correct Answer: 175 procedures
Rationale:
1. Calculate total obese population: 250,000 × 0.35 = 87,500 obese adults
2. Identify surgical candidates: 87,500 × 0.02 = 1,750 candidates annually
3. Apply conversion rate (candidates who actually pursue surgery): 1,750 × 0.40 = 700 actual
surgical seekers
4. Apply MVH capture goal (25% market share): 700 × 0.25 = 175 procedures
Strategic Insight: This represents a conservative, market-driven volume projection. The 25%
capture rate assumes MVH can compete effectively with Metro Surgical Institute, which
currently dominates the market. This volume would position MVH as a significant regional
player while acknowledging the 12-18 month ramp-up period typical for new surgical
programs.
Common Errors:
● Using 2% directly on total population (ignoring obesity rate) = 5,000 (overestimation)
● Forgetting conversion rate = 437.5 (underestimation of actual surgical demand)
● Using 100% capture = 700 (unrealistic market assumption)
Q2: Data Interpretation [Graph Analysis]
Exhibit 1: Age Distribution of Obese Adults in PSA vs. State Average
TableCopy
, Age Group PSA Obesity % State Obesity % PSA Population
18-34 28% 25% 62,500
35-49 38% 32% 75,000
50-64 42% 36% 68,750
65+ 31% 28% 43,750
Which age group represents both the highest absolute number of obese adults AND the
highest surgical candidacy potential?
A. 18-34
B. 35-49 [CORRECT]
C. 50-64
D. 65+
Correct Answer: B (35-49 age group)
Rationale:
1. Calculate absolute obese adults per group:
● 18-34: 62,500 × 0.28 = 17,500
● 35-49: 75,000 × 0.38 = 28,500 ← Highest absolute number
● 50-64: 68,750 × 0.42 = 28,875
● 65+: 43,750 × 0.31 = 13,563
2. Surgical candidacy considerations:
● 35-49 age group has optimal risk-benefit profile for bariatric surgery
● Higher employer-sponsored insurance coverage (commercial payers = better
reimbursement)
● Longer life expectancy to realize health benefits (ROI for payers)
● 50-64 group, while slightly higher in absolute obese numbers, has higher surgical risk
and more Medicare/payer mix challenges
Strategic Business Implication: The 35-49 demographic should be the primary target for
marketing and physician outreach. This group offers the best combination of volume, payer
mix, and clinical outcomes—directly impacting both financial sustainability and quality
metrics.
, Q3: Payer Mix Analysis [SATA - Select All That Apply]
Current PSA Commercial Insurance Market Share:
● BlueCross BlueShield: 45%
● UnitedHealthcare: 25%
● Aetna: 15%
● Cigna: 10%
● Medicare: 35% of 65+ population (not age-adjusted for under 65)
● Medicaid: 12% of total PSA population
● Uninsured: 8%
MVH's preliminary payer mix projection for bariatric surgery shows:
● Commercial: 60%
● Medicare: 25%
● Medicaid: 10%
● Self-pay: 5%
Which factors would VALIDATE this projected payer mix as realistic for a bariatric surgery
program? (Select THREE)
A. Employer weight management benefit expansions will drive commercially insured volume
[CORRECT]
B. Medicare covers bariatric surgery only for BMI >35 with comorbidities, limiting eligibility
[CORRECT]
C. Medicaid coverage for bariatric surgery is inconsistent and often requires 6+ months of
documented medical weight management attempts [CORRECT]
D. The 35-49 age demographic (primary target) is predominantly Medicare-eligible
E. Self-pay patients typically represent 20-25% of bariatric volume in community hospitals
F. Commercial reimbursement rates are 40-60% higher than Medicare for bariatric procedures
Correct Answers: A, B, C
Rationale:
A. [CORRECT] — Strategic validation. The case states three major employers (12,000
employees) expressed interest in enhanced benefits. Commercial patients are the financial
lifeblood of bariatric surgery due to superior reimbursement rates. This validates the 60%
commercial projection.
B. [CORRECT] — Regulatory constraint. Medicare's National Coverage Determination (NCD
100.1) restricts coverage to patients with BMI ≥35 with at least one obesity-related