OpenStax Astronomy 2e Instructor Answer Guide
Chapter 27: Active Galaxies, Quasars, and Supermassive Black Holes
Review Questions
1. Describe some differences between quasars and normal galaxies.
Answer
Normal galaxies host anywhere from thousands of stars in the smallest galaxies to trillions of
stars in the largest ones. Quasars appear to be single, solitary energy sources. Normal galaxies
are observed throughout the universe, while quasars are generally found only at very large
distances with very high redshifts. Luminous quasars are typically 100 times brighter than a large
galaxy. Large galaxies can be hundreds of thousands of light-years in diameter, while quasars are
typically much less than 1 light-year in diameter. Normal galaxies do not emit much energy at
radio frequencies, while many quasars are extremely luminous at radio frequencies.
2. Describe the arguments supporting the idea that quasars are at the distances indicated by their
redshifts.
Answer
Quasars have extremely large redshifts, indicating that they are receding from us at large
fractions of the speed of light. Any objects moving this rapidly from a nearby galaxy would
easily achieve escape speeds from even the largest host galaxies. Hubble Space Telescope
observations have shown that quasars sit in the middle of host galaxies, and the host galaxies
have the same redshifts as their quasars, confirming that quasars obey Hubble’s law and their
high redshifts are due to their distance.
3. In what ways are active galaxies like quasars but different from normal galaxies?
Answer
Like quasars, active galaxies have very luminous central regions that emit prodigious amounts of
energy, particularly in the radio region of the spectrum. Both quasars and active galaxies are
powered by infalling material that forms an accretion disk around a central supermassive black
hole. Both quasars and active galaxies emit jets of mass and energy perpendicular to the plane of
the host galaxy’s disk.
4. Why could the concentration of matter at the center of an active galaxy like M87 not be made
of stars?
Answer
To explain the large masses in the centers of galaxies that we observe, there would have to be at
least a million stars in a region about the size of the solar system. This requires that they would
have be only two star-diameters apart, meaning there would be constant collisions between stars.
Those stars would then merge, and soon, the resulting giant star or stars would collapse into a
black hole.
5. Describe the process by which the action of a black hole can explain the energy radiated by
quasars.
Answer
Quasars are galaxies that contain a supermassive black hole, surrounded by an accretion disk in
which material is heated to extreme temperatures. Because the gravity of the black hole is very
strong near its event horizon, material in the accretion disk is falling in and releasing a huge
amount of gravitational energy as it falls. It is this energy that powers the glowing accretion disk
and explains the luminosity of quasars. Quasars represent an early stage in the development of
galaxies,when vastly more material, mostly interstellar gas and dust, fell into the central
supermassive black hole during the galaxy’s accretion stage. Quasars can also be “reborn” when
, OpenStax Astronomy 2e Instructor Answer Guide
another galaxy collides with the quasar host, and its material provides new fuel for the quasar
accretion disk.
6. Describe the observations that convinced astronomers that M87 is an active galaxy.
Answer
M87 possesses jets that stream from a very luminous and compact center perpendicular to the
plane of the galactic disk. In addition, Hubble Space Telescope observations show a disk of hot
material circling the central black holes in M87, and Doppler shift measurements indicate that
this black hole is 3.5 billion solar masses, about 1000 times more massive than the Milky Way’s
central supermassive black hole, and more than sufficient to produce the tremendous energy we
observe radiating from the galaxy in its radio jets.
7. Why do astronomers believe that quasars represent an early stage in the evolution of galaxies?
Answer
Quasars and their host galaxies all have very large redshifts, indicating that they are at least 1
billion light-years away, and often much farther. When we recall that light travels at a finite
speed, we see that looking out in space is the same thing as looking back in time. Because all the
quasars we see are so far away, the light we see from them today must have left the quasar
billions of years ago, back when the universe was much younger than it is today. Thus, we are
seeing galaxies in an early stage of their formation. The number of quasars increases as we look
further back in time and was greatest when the universe was about 20% of its current age.
8. Why were quasars and active galaxies not initially recognized as being “special” in some way?
Answer
Prior to the advent of radio telescopes, quasars were generally thought to be stars (after all, they
looked like points of light on a photograph). Most active galaxies did not look significantly
different from normal galaxies at visible wavelengths. When radio telescopes came onto the
scene, astronomers detected much more activity in quasars than they did from stars, and much
more activity from active galaxies than normal galaxies. The surprising “radio loud” objects
invited more intense scrutiny, including analyses of their spectra and observations in many other
regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. These observations then began to show astronomers
how different these objects actually were.
9. What do we now understand to be the primary difference between normal galaxies and active
galaxies?
Answer
Normal galaxies have very little material feeding their central supermassive black holes and thus
very little activity near or from their centers. Active galaxies have gas and dust falling into an
accretion disk around their central supermassive black holes. These days, we understand that the
material to make the core of a galaxy active comes from a galaxy that collided with the one that
became active.
10. What is the typical structure we observe in a quasar at radio frequencies?
Answer
At radio frequencies, quasars have a very small but extremely luminous center that coincides
with the center of its host galaxy. There are often two very narrow but bright jets that extend in
opposite directions from the center of the host galaxy and which terminate by spreading out into
two large amorphous bright radio lobes.
11. What evidence do we have that the luminous central region of a quasar is small and compact?
Answer
Chapter 27: Active Galaxies, Quasars, and Supermassive Black Holes
Review Questions
1. Describe some differences between quasars and normal galaxies.
Answer
Normal galaxies host anywhere from thousands of stars in the smallest galaxies to trillions of
stars in the largest ones. Quasars appear to be single, solitary energy sources. Normal galaxies
are observed throughout the universe, while quasars are generally found only at very large
distances with very high redshifts. Luminous quasars are typically 100 times brighter than a large
galaxy. Large galaxies can be hundreds of thousands of light-years in diameter, while quasars are
typically much less than 1 light-year in diameter. Normal galaxies do not emit much energy at
radio frequencies, while many quasars are extremely luminous at radio frequencies.
2. Describe the arguments supporting the idea that quasars are at the distances indicated by their
redshifts.
Answer
Quasars have extremely large redshifts, indicating that they are receding from us at large
fractions of the speed of light. Any objects moving this rapidly from a nearby galaxy would
easily achieve escape speeds from even the largest host galaxies. Hubble Space Telescope
observations have shown that quasars sit in the middle of host galaxies, and the host galaxies
have the same redshifts as their quasars, confirming that quasars obey Hubble’s law and their
high redshifts are due to their distance.
3. In what ways are active galaxies like quasars but different from normal galaxies?
Answer
Like quasars, active galaxies have very luminous central regions that emit prodigious amounts of
energy, particularly in the radio region of the spectrum. Both quasars and active galaxies are
powered by infalling material that forms an accretion disk around a central supermassive black
hole. Both quasars and active galaxies emit jets of mass and energy perpendicular to the plane of
the host galaxy’s disk.
4. Why could the concentration of matter at the center of an active galaxy like M87 not be made
of stars?
Answer
To explain the large masses in the centers of galaxies that we observe, there would have to be at
least a million stars in a region about the size of the solar system. This requires that they would
have be only two star-diameters apart, meaning there would be constant collisions between stars.
Those stars would then merge, and soon, the resulting giant star or stars would collapse into a
black hole.
5. Describe the process by which the action of a black hole can explain the energy radiated by
quasars.
Answer
Quasars are galaxies that contain a supermassive black hole, surrounded by an accretion disk in
which material is heated to extreme temperatures. Because the gravity of the black hole is very
strong near its event horizon, material in the accretion disk is falling in and releasing a huge
amount of gravitational energy as it falls. It is this energy that powers the glowing accretion disk
and explains the luminosity of quasars. Quasars represent an early stage in the development of
galaxies,when vastly more material, mostly interstellar gas and dust, fell into the central
supermassive black hole during the galaxy’s accretion stage. Quasars can also be “reborn” when
, OpenStax Astronomy 2e Instructor Answer Guide
another galaxy collides with the quasar host, and its material provides new fuel for the quasar
accretion disk.
6. Describe the observations that convinced astronomers that M87 is an active galaxy.
Answer
M87 possesses jets that stream from a very luminous and compact center perpendicular to the
plane of the galactic disk. In addition, Hubble Space Telescope observations show a disk of hot
material circling the central black holes in M87, and Doppler shift measurements indicate that
this black hole is 3.5 billion solar masses, about 1000 times more massive than the Milky Way’s
central supermassive black hole, and more than sufficient to produce the tremendous energy we
observe radiating from the galaxy in its radio jets.
7. Why do astronomers believe that quasars represent an early stage in the evolution of galaxies?
Answer
Quasars and their host galaxies all have very large redshifts, indicating that they are at least 1
billion light-years away, and often much farther. When we recall that light travels at a finite
speed, we see that looking out in space is the same thing as looking back in time. Because all the
quasars we see are so far away, the light we see from them today must have left the quasar
billions of years ago, back when the universe was much younger than it is today. Thus, we are
seeing galaxies in an early stage of their formation. The number of quasars increases as we look
further back in time and was greatest when the universe was about 20% of its current age.
8. Why were quasars and active galaxies not initially recognized as being “special” in some way?
Answer
Prior to the advent of radio telescopes, quasars were generally thought to be stars (after all, they
looked like points of light on a photograph). Most active galaxies did not look significantly
different from normal galaxies at visible wavelengths. When radio telescopes came onto the
scene, astronomers detected much more activity in quasars than they did from stars, and much
more activity from active galaxies than normal galaxies. The surprising “radio loud” objects
invited more intense scrutiny, including analyses of their spectra and observations in many other
regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. These observations then began to show astronomers
how different these objects actually were.
9. What do we now understand to be the primary difference between normal galaxies and active
galaxies?
Answer
Normal galaxies have very little material feeding their central supermassive black holes and thus
very little activity near or from their centers. Active galaxies have gas and dust falling into an
accretion disk around their central supermassive black holes. These days, we understand that the
material to make the core of a galaxy active comes from a galaxy that collided with the one that
became active.
10. What is the typical structure we observe in a quasar at radio frequencies?
Answer
At radio frequencies, quasars have a very small but extremely luminous center that coincides
with the center of its host galaxy. There are often two very narrow but bright jets that extend in
opposite directions from the center of the host galaxy and which terminate by spreading out into
two large amorphous bright radio lobes.
11. What evidence do we have that the luminous central region of a quasar is small and compact?
Answer