Oxford Cambridge and RSA
Tuesday 10 June 2025 – Morning
A Level Law
H418/03 The nature of law and human rights
Time allowed: 2 hours
* 1 8 8 4 6 9 3 8 2 4 *
You must have:
• the OCR 12-page Answer Booklet
INSTRUCTIONS
• Use black ink.
• Write your answer to each question in the Answer Booklet. The question numbers must
be clearly shown.
• Fill in the boxes on the front of the Answer Booklet.
• Answer four questions in total:
• Answer one question in Section A.
• Choose one option in Section B. Answer the three questions in either Part 1 or Part 2
from the option you have chosen.
INFORMATION
• The total mark for this paper is 80.
• The marks for each question are shown in brackets [ ].
• Quality of extended response will be assessed in questions marked with an asterisk (*).
• This document has 8 pages.
ADVICE
• Read each question carefully before you start your answer.
© OCR 2025 [603/0706/7] OCR is an exempt Charity
DC (PQ) 355289/2 Turn over
for more: tyrionpapers.com
, 2
Section A
The nature of law
Answer one question using examples from your full course of study.
1* ‘The problem with defining justice is that very few people agree on what justice actually means.’
Discuss how the legal system defines justice given this statement. [20]
2* ‘The rule of law is a deceptive term because there is no single ‘rule’ to follow. It is best
understood as a collection of principles designed to produce fair and just outcomes.’
Discuss this view of the rule of law. [20]
© OCR 2025 H418/03 Jun25
for more: tyrionpapers.com
, 3
Section B
Human rights law
Choose Part 1 or Part 2
Part 1
Answer the three questions.
The first two questions are about the scenarios. The scenarios are related.
Sam is a controversial journalist on a tour promoting his new book Citizens in Action. He does not
allow cameras into his venues. However, at his first venue he is secretly filmed explaining that citizen
action means taking ‘any direct action necessary’ to pursue a goal, including criminal acts. He also
says that ‘any lawyer acting for an asylum seeker should have his house burned down’. The video clip
is posted online and soon goes viral. As a result, the following events happen:
• At his second venue the local council, having viewed the online clips from the first show, withdraw
the license. When he arrives, he finds the venue is closed and his show has been cancelled.
• A government official acting for the Home Office applies for a banning order to prevent Sam’s
book being sold on the grounds that it is spreading hate speech.
• Yana, a protestor, throws green paint over Sam and is arrested and charged with battery.
While Yana is awaiting her trial, her boyfriend, Riley, starts harassing Sam and his family. He spies on
Sam’s home and family taking photographs which he emails to Sam. Sam is very worried about his
family’s safety. Sam’s wife, Amaya, starts to receive anonymous phone calls accusing Sam of being
violent and of having abused his partners over many years. She also receives messages appearing to
be from Sam’s previous girlfriend. In fact, the calls and messages are from Riley.
Amaya is also sent links to a pornographic website containing obscene video material showing Sam
participating in a variety of disturbing and illegal sexual acts. In fact, all the images are fake and have
been created by Riley using an AI (artificial intelligence) video generating programme.
3 Advise Sam whether he will be able to rely on his Article 10 rights to challenge the closure of
the venue and the banning of the book and advise Yana on whether she can rely on her Article
10 rights in relation to the criminal charge for throwing the paint over Sam. Do not consider
Article 11. [20]
4 Advise Sam and Amaya how the law on harassment would apply to Riley’s emails, phone calls
and messages and how the law on obscenity would apply to Riley’s fake video material. [20]
Essay question on human rights law
5* ‘Despite its fundamental significance as a human right, the right to a fair trial under the European
Convention on Human Rights has been far too frequently violated.’
Discuss whether the mechanisms to protect a fair criminal trial are effective given this statement.
[20]
© OCR 2025 H418/03 Jun25 Turn over
for more: tyrionpapers.com
Tuesday 10 June 2025 – Morning
A Level Law
H418/03 The nature of law and human rights
Time allowed: 2 hours
* 1 8 8 4 6 9 3 8 2 4 *
You must have:
• the OCR 12-page Answer Booklet
INSTRUCTIONS
• Use black ink.
• Write your answer to each question in the Answer Booklet. The question numbers must
be clearly shown.
• Fill in the boxes on the front of the Answer Booklet.
• Answer four questions in total:
• Answer one question in Section A.
• Choose one option in Section B. Answer the three questions in either Part 1 or Part 2
from the option you have chosen.
INFORMATION
• The total mark for this paper is 80.
• The marks for each question are shown in brackets [ ].
• Quality of extended response will be assessed in questions marked with an asterisk (*).
• This document has 8 pages.
ADVICE
• Read each question carefully before you start your answer.
© OCR 2025 [603/0706/7] OCR is an exempt Charity
DC (PQ) 355289/2 Turn over
for more: tyrionpapers.com
, 2
Section A
The nature of law
Answer one question using examples from your full course of study.
1* ‘The problem with defining justice is that very few people agree on what justice actually means.’
Discuss how the legal system defines justice given this statement. [20]
2* ‘The rule of law is a deceptive term because there is no single ‘rule’ to follow. It is best
understood as a collection of principles designed to produce fair and just outcomes.’
Discuss this view of the rule of law. [20]
© OCR 2025 H418/03 Jun25
for more: tyrionpapers.com
, 3
Section B
Human rights law
Choose Part 1 or Part 2
Part 1
Answer the three questions.
The first two questions are about the scenarios. The scenarios are related.
Sam is a controversial journalist on a tour promoting his new book Citizens in Action. He does not
allow cameras into his venues. However, at his first venue he is secretly filmed explaining that citizen
action means taking ‘any direct action necessary’ to pursue a goal, including criminal acts. He also
says that ‘any lawyer acting for an asylum seeker should have his house burned down’. The video clip
is posted online and soon goes viral. As a result, the following events happen:
• At his second venue the local council, having viewed the online clips from the first show, withdraw
the license. When he arrives, he finds the venue is closed and his show has been cancelled.
• A government official acting for the Home Office applies for a banning order to prevent Sam’s
book being sold on the grounds that it is spreading hate speech.
• Yana, a protestor, throws green paint over Sam and is arrested and charged with battery.
While Yana is awaiting her trial, her boyfriend, Riley, starts harassing Sam and his family. He spies on
Sam’s home and family taking photographs which he emails to Sam. Sam is very worried about his
family’s safety. Sam’s wife, Amaya, starts to receive anonymous phone calls accusing Sam of being
violent and of having abused his partners over many years. She also receives messages appearing to
be from Sam’s previous girlfriend. In fact, the calls and messages are from Riley.
Amaya is also sent links to a pornographic website containing obscene video material showing Sam
participating in a variety of disturbing and illegal sexual acts. In fact, all the images are fake and have
been created by Riley using an AI (artificial intelligence) video generating programme.
3 Advise Sam whether he will be able to rely on his Article 10 rights to challenge the closure of
the venue and the banning of the book and advise Yana on whether she can rely on her Article
10 rights in relation to the criminal charge for throwing the paint over Sam. Do not consider
Article 11. [20]
4 Advise Sam and Amaya how the law on harassment would apply to Riley’s emails, phone calls
and messages and how the law on obscenity would apply to Riley’s fake video material. [20]
Essay question on human rights law
5* ‘Despite its fundamental significance as a human right, the right to a fair trial under the European
Convention on Human Rights has been far too frequently violated.’
Discuss whether the mechanisms to protect a fair criminal trial are effective given this statement.
[20]
© OCR 2025 H418/03 Jun25 Turn over
for more: tyrionpapers.com
