Alternative dispute resolution, or ADR, is another way to settle a dispute
without going to court. There are four types; negotiation, mediation,
conciliation, and arbitration. Negotiation is a direct negotiation with the
other party they are in dispute with, which can be done online, in writing
or face to face. The agreement can be a verbal one or one that is more
formally set down in writing, and the negotiation can be done by the
parties themselves, their representatives, their lawyers or any
combination of the above. If the negotiation is unsuccessful, it can still be
used in a court hearing to simplify the case.
Mediation is when a neutral mediator helps the parties to reach a
solution to the dispute. The parties can be in separate locations and the
mediator acts as a facilitator, shuttling between the two parties to put
forward points and opinions, or the parties can attend the mediation
together (seen moreso in family cases with no domestic violence). The
parties can withdraw at any time, and the mediator will not offer an
opinion unless expressly asked to do so. A successful mediation will be a
compromise and both parties contributing. This form of ADR is used in
family and financial disputes, where the parties have to show they have
tried mediation before court. Financial aid is available through charities
like the Centre for Effective Dispute Resolution (CEDR). A more formal
method of mediation is a mini trial, where each side presents their case to
a panel which is made of a neutral party and a decision-making executive
from each party in dispute. Once the submissions have been made, a
decision will be made between the executives, and if there cannot be a
decision made the neutral party will act as a mediator. Over 80% of
mediation cases are settled.
Conciliation is similar to mediation with a neutral third party helps to
resolve the dispute, but the conciliator plays an active role. They will
discuss the issues with parties and suggest grounds for compromise or
settlement, and the parties can still withdraw at any time. Both parties
must agree to a final compromise, which does not have to be a resolution.
ACAS is an example of a conciliation service where it tries to encourage
the parties in an employment dispute to reach a settlement, and it also
gets involved in industrial disputes, such as trade unions. Conciliation
does not necessarily lead to a resolution and it may be necessary to
continue with court action.
Arbitration is where both parties voluntarily agree to let their dispute be
left to the judgement of a neutral arbitrator, or a panel of them. The
agreement will usually be in writing and will be legally binding under the
arbitration cause, known as the scott v avery clause. This is governed by