Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION
Exercise 1.1
Compare and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of making separations using an energy-
separating agent (ESA) versus using a mass-separating agent (MSA).
Exercise 1.2
The system benzene-toluene adheres closely to Raoult’s law. The vapor pressures of benzene
and toluene at 121°C are 300 and 133 kPa.
Calculate the relative volatility.
Exercise 1.3
As a part of the life system support for spacecrafts it is necessary to provide a means of continu-
ously removing carbon dioxide from air. If it is not possible to rely upon gravity in any way to devise
a CO2-air separation process.
Suggest at least two separation schemes, which could be suitable for continuous CO2 removal
from air under zero gravity conditions.
Exercise 1.4
Gold is present in seawater to a concentration level between 10-12 and 10-8 weight fraction, de-
pending upon the location.
Briefly evaluate the potential for recovering gold economically from seawater.
Exercise 1.5
Assuming that the membrane characteristics are not changed as the upstream pressure increases,
will the product-water purity in a reverse-osmosis seawater desalination process increase, remain
constant or decrease?
Exercise 1.6
Propylene and propane are among the light hydrocarbons produced by thermal and catalytic
cracking of heavy petroleum fractions. Although propylene and propane have close boiling points,
they are traditionally separated by distillation. Because distillation requires a large numbers of
stages and considerable reflux and boilup flow rates compared to the feed flow, considerable
attention has been given to the possible replacement of distillation with a more economical and
less energy-intensive option. Based on the properties of both species, propose some alternative
properties that can be exploited to enhance the selectivity of propylene and propane separation.
What separation processes are based on these alternative properties?
Property Propylene Propane
Molecular weight (kg/mol) 0,04208 0,04410
VdWaals volume (m3/mol) 0,0341 0,0376
2
VdWaals area (m /mol) 5,06 5,59
Acentric factor 0,142 0,152
Dipole moment (Debije) 0,4 0,0
Radius of gyration (m·1010) 2,25 2,43
Melting point (K) 87,9 85,5
Boiling point (K) 225,4 231,1
Critical temperature (K) 364,8 369,8
Critical pressure (MPa) 4,61 4,25
,1-2 INTRODUCTION
SOLUTIONS
Exercise 1.1
Compare and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of making separations using an energy-
separating agent (ESA) versus using a mass-separating agent (MSA).
Answer
Advantages Disadvantages
ESA Known technology Energy consumption
Phase separation may be expensive
Relatively simple Heat integration required
MSA High selectivities Recovery of agent requires
possible additional separation
Exercise 1.2
Calculate the relative volatility of benzene-toluene.
Answer
For an ideal system such as benzene-toluene, by definition (Eqs. 1.3 and 1.5)
y B / xB P o 300
SF ≡ α ≡ = B = = 2.26
(1− y B ) /(1− xB ) PTo 133
Exercise 1.3
Suggest at least two separation schemes that could be suitable for continuous CO2 removal from
air under zero gravity conditions.
Answer
a. Adsorption of CO2 on activated carbon. Regeneration by exposing to vacuum outside the
spacecraft.
b. Absorption of CO2 in a suitable solvent at the low temperature outside the vessel. Regeneration
of the loaded solvent at room temperature, releasing the overpressure via a valve to the outer
space.
Exercise 1.4
Briefly evaluate the potential for recovering gold economically from seawater.
Answer
The lower the concentration of the desired substance, the more expensive the required technol-
ogy. At the given extremely low concentrations, huge amounts of seawater have to be treated,
either by evaporation or by (membrane)filtration. Either method is not feasible due to the high-
energy costs or pumping costs.
The thermodynamical basis is given by the change in chemical potential upon mixing, which is
proportional to ln(activity) a negative value, indicating a spontaneous process. Separation of the
mixture, on the other hand, requires at least that amount of work, which is extremely large at very
low values of the activity (or concentration).
, Fundamentals of Industrial Separations, SOLUTIONS TO PROBLEMS 1-3
Exercise 1.5
Assuming that the membrane characteristics are not changed, as the upstream pressure in-
creases, will the product-water purity in a reverse-osmosis seawater desalination process in-
crease, remain constant or decrease?
Answer
The water flux is proportional to ΔPext – ΔΠosm and will increase with increasing ΔPext. The salt flux
is proportional to cfeed – cpermeate and will not be effected by a change in ΔPext. Hence, the product
purity will increase with increasing ΔPext.
Exercise 1.6
Based on the properties of propylene and propane, propose some alternative properties that can
be exploited to enhance the selectivity of propylene and propane separation. What processes are
based on these alternative properties?
Property Propylene Propane
Molecular weight (kg/mol) 0,04208 0,04410
VdWaals volume (m3/mol) 0,0341 0,0376
2
VdWaals area (m /mol) 5,06 5,59
Acentric factor 0,142 0,152
Dipole moment (Debije) 0,4 0,0
Radius of gyration (m·1010) 2,25 2,43
Melting point (K) 87,9 85,5
Boiling point (K) 225,4 231,1
Critical temperature (K) 364,8 369,8
Critical pressure (Mpa) 4,61 4,25
Answer
Difference in molecular weight Ultracentrifuge
Difference in VdWaals volume Kinetic separation by preferential adsorption of the
component with the smallest volume in a molecular
sieve adsorbent
Difference in dipole moment Absorption, adsorption, extraction or extractive
distillation