RCE2601
Assignment 2
EXCEPTIONAL ANSWERS
Due 13 June 2025
, RCE2601 Assignment 2
Due: 13 June 2025
Task 1: Strategic Source Evaluation for a Postgraduate Literature Review
For Sarah’s rigorous postgraduate literature review, the peer-reviewed journal article
and the government report constitute the foundational and primary sources, given their
inherent academic rigor and authoritative provenance. Conversely, the blog post and
Wikipedia page, by their very nature, necessitate either cautious, supplementary usage
or outright exclusion due to significant concerns regarding their reliability, academic
rigor, and potential for unverified content. The subsequent evaluation delineates the
distinct attributes of each source type across critical dimensions: reliability, authorship,
publication process, and academic value.
• Peer-Reviewed Journal Article
• Reliability: Peer-reviewed articles undergo an exceptionally rigorous and
systematic scrutiny process by domain experts (scholars, researchers) prior to
publication. This stringent editorial and review mechanism ensures the
methodological soundness, empirical validity, and conceptual accuracy of the
research presented. Published in reputable academic journals, these articles
adhere to stringent ethical guidelines and scholarly conventions, thereby
establishing a high benchmark for scientific credibility.
• Authorship: The authors are invariably established scholars, senior researchers,
or leading academics with profound disciplinary expertise in the subject matter
(e.g., AI in education). Their affiliations with accredited academic or research
institutions, coupled with their advanced degrees and publication records, vouch
for their intellectual authority and scholarly contributions.
• Publication Process: The peer-review process typically involves multiple rounds
of blind or double-blind evaluation, wherein submissions are critically assessed
by independent experts. This rigorous gatekeeping mechanism serves to mitigate
Assignment 2
EXCEPTIONAL ANSWERS
Due 13 June 2025
, RCE2601 Assignment 2
Due: 13 June 2025
Task 1: Strategic Source Evaluation for a Postgraduate Literature Review
For Sarah’s rigorous postgraduate literature review, the peer-reviewed journal article
and the government report constitute the foundational and primary sources, given their
inherent academic rigor and authoritative provenance. Conversely, the blog post and
Wikipedia page, by their very nature, necessitate either cautious, supplementary usage
or outright exclusion due to significant concerns regarding their reliability, academic
rigor, and potential for unverified content. The subsequent evaluation delineates the
distinct attributes of each source type across critical dimensions: reliability, authorship,
publication process, and academic value.
• Peer-Reviewed Journal Article
• Reliability: Peer-reviewed articles undergo an exceptionally rigorous and
systematic scrutiny process by domain experts (scholars, researchers) prior to
publication. This stringent editorial and review mechanism ensures the
methodological soundness, empirical validity, and conceptual accuracy of the
research presented. Published in reputable academic journals, these articles
adhere to stringent ethical guidelines and scholarly conventions, thereby
establishing a high benchmark for scientific credibility.
• Authorship: The authors are invariably established scholars, senior researchers,
or leading academics with profound disciplinary expertise in the subject matter
(e.g., AI in education). Their affiliations with accredited academic or research
institutions, coupled with their advanced degrees and publication records, vouch
for their intellectual authority and scholarly contributions.
• Publication Process: The peer-review process typically involves multiple rounds
of blind or double-blind evaluation, wherein submissions are critically assessed
by independent experts. This rigorous gatekeeping mechanism serves to mitigate
