Moral Status: Case Analysis
After reading of the "Case Study: Fetal Abnormality" and the specific moral status theories
in the topic Resources, respond to the following prompts, using only citations from the
case and topic Resources:
1. Based on the case and specific moral status theories in the topic Resources, in 450-
500 words, what is the Christian view of the nature of human persons, and which
theory of moral status is it compatible with? How is this related to the intrinsic human
value and dignity?
The Christian faith upholds the belief that humans are created in the image of God,
as stated in Genesis 1:27. This principle highlights the responsibility to hold
ourselves accountable and treat others with dignity and respect. Everyone
inherently possesses worth and dignity merely by being made in the image of God.
Therefore, it is crucial to nurture relationships with both God and others. This
perspective, which emphasizes the value of every human being, aligns closely with
the theory based on human properties, particularly in the context of human life's
intrinsic value.
The theory of human properties maintains that humans possess unique qualities that
make them valuable, regardless of their physical or mental capabilities. This aligns
with the Christian belief of being created in God's image, which underscores the
inherent worth and dignity of every human being. Both the theory of human
properties and the Christian worldview emphasize the importance of individual
accountability and treating others with respect and dignity. The belief in humanity's
intrinsic value is foundational to both advocating for the protection of human life
and opposing actions that violate the sanctity of life. Ultimately, the theory of
human properties and the Christian perspective converge on the understanding that
all life is valuable and deserving of empathy, compassion, and respect.
The theory that human life is valuable, regardless of any physical or mental
limitations, is a central belief held by many Christians. According to this
viewpoint, any actions that are deemed to be against divine teachings, such as
abortions or euthanasia, are rejected as they are considered to be a violation of the
inherent worth of every human being. This principle is based on the notion that no
one should assume the role of God, as each human being holds an intrinsic value
that cannot be measured or disregarded. As such, Christians who share this
viewpoint believe in the sanctity of life and the importance of protecting it in all its
forms.
The concept of intrinsic value is a fundamental belief that posits that every human
being has inherent worth and dignity. This idea is deeply rooted in the Christian
faith, which holds that every person is made in the image of God and therefore
deserves to be treated with respect and compassion. This belief extends even to
fetuses and unborn babies, who are seen as bearers of divine likeness and therefore
entitled to life and protection. For many Christians, this ethical principle forms the
© 2024. Grand Canyon University. All Rights Reserved.
, cornerstone of their moral code, guiding their actions and inspiring them to show
love, kindness, and respect to every human being they encounter.
Ultimately, the understanding that all life is valuable, rooted in their creation in
God's image, calls for unconditional love and empathy, free from prejudice or
discrimination. As individuals evolve spiritually and physically, they should be
embraced with dignity and encouraged to discern the divine will for their lives.
Thus, humanity's intrinsic value transcends and affirms every person's multifaceted
worth.
2. Based on the case, in 200-250 words, which specific moral status theory or theories
from the topic Resources are being used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to
determine the moral status of the fetus? What from the case study specifically leads you
to believe that they hold the theory or each of the theories you identified?
Based on the case study, it appears that the family ultimately subscribes to the
theory Based on Human Properties due to their strong religious beliefs. However,
they do express moments of concern regarding the future of their child and their
own if the child is born with a disability. Maria exhibits faith in God and believes
that prayer will provide answers. It seems the family views their child as a miracle
from God and trusts that if it is His plan, they will accept it. They will seek
guidance from God and rely on their faith to make a difficult decision for both the
family and their child.
Jessica
Jessica employs the Relationship Theory of Moral Statues in her approach. This is
evident in her concern for the child's future quality of life and the potential impact
on the family's well-being. The theory underscores the importance of emotional and
relational bonds and is seen in Jessica's concern for their future and the baby's
future.
Marco
Marco holds the belief that all life is a miracle from God, and that we come from
God. He is presenting the Theory of Moral Statues based on Human Properties. He
also presents with the Moral agency theory when trying to protect his wife from the
news until she is emotionally sound to deal with it.
Maria
Maria is using the Human Properties’ Theory of Moral Status to guide her
decision-making process. She believes that the final decision for her family
should be left to God alone and therefore relies heavily on prayer to discern God's
will.
Dr. Wilson
After reading of the "Case Study: Fetal Abnormality" and the specific moral status theories
in the topic Resources, respond to the following prompts, using only citations from the
case and topic Resources:
1. Based on the case and specific moral status theories in the topic Resources, in 450-
500 words, what is the Christian view of the nature of human persons, and which
theory of moral status is it compatible with? How is this related to the intrinsic human
value and dignity?
The Christian faith upholds the belief that humans are created in the image of God,
as stated in Genesis 1:27. This principle highlights the responsibility to hold
ourselves accountable and treat others with dignity and respect. Everyone
inherently possesses worth and dignity merely by being made in the image of God.
Therefore, it is crucial to nurture relationships with both God and others. This
perspective, which emphasizes the value of every human being, aligns closely with
the theory based on human properties, particularly in the context of human life's
intrinsic value.
The theory of human properties maintains that humans possess unique qualities that
make them valuable, regardless of their physical or mental capabilities. This aligns
with the Christian belief of being created in God's image, which underscores the
inherent worth and dignity of every human being. Both the theory of human
properties and the Christian worldview emphasize the importance of individual
accountability and treating others with respect and dignity. The belief in humanity's
intrinsic value is foundational to both advocating for the protection of human life
and opposing actions that violate the sanctity of life. Ultimately, the theory of
human properties and the Christian perspective converge on the understanding that
all life is valuable and deserving of empathy, compassion, and respect.
The theory that human life is valuable, regardless of any physical or mental
limitations, is a central belief held by many Christians. According to this
viewpoint, any actions that are deemed to be against divine teachings, such as
abortions or euthanasia, are rejected as they are considered to be a violation of the
inherent worth of every human being. This principle is based on the notion that no
one should assume the role of God, as each human being holds an intrinsic value
that cannot be measured or disregarded. As such, Christians who share this
viewpoint believe in the sanctity of life and the importance of protecting it in all its
forms.
The concept of intrinsic value is a fundamental belief that posits that every human
being has inherent worth and dignity. This idea is deeply rooted in the Christian
faith, which holds that every person is made in the image of God and therefore
deserves to be treated with respect and compassion. This belief extends even to
fetuses and unborn babies, who are seen as bearers of divine likeness and therefore
entitled to life and protection. For many Christians, this ethical principle forms the
© 2024. Grand Canyon University. All Rights Reserved.
, cornerstone of their moral code, guiding their actions and inspiring them to show
love, kindness, and respect to every human being they encounter.
Ultimately, the understanding that all life is valuable, rooted in their creation in
God's image, calls for unconditional love and empathy, free from prejudice or
discrimination. As individuals evolve spiritually and physically, they should be
embraced with dignity and encouraged to discern the divine will for their lives.
Thus, humanity's intrinsic value transcends and affirms every person's multifaceted
worth.
2. Based on the case, in 200-250 words, which specific moral status theory or theories
from the topic Resources are being used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to
determine the moral status of the fetus? What from the case study specifically leads you
to believe that they hold the theory or each of the theories you identified?
Based on the case study, it appears that the family ultimately subscribes to the
theory Based on Human Properties due to their strong religious beliefs. However,
they do express moments of concern regarding the future of their child and their
own if the child is born with a disability. Maria exhibits faith in God and believes
that prayer will provide answers. It seems the family views their child as a miracle
from God and trusts that if it is His plan, they will accept it. They will seek
guidance from God and rely on their faith to make a difficult decision for both the
family and their child.
Jessica
Jessica employs the Relationship Theory of Moral Statues in her approach. This is
evident in her concern for the child's future quality of life and the potential impact
on the family's well-being. The theory underscores the importance of emotional and
relational bonds and is seen in Jessica's concern for their future and the baby's
future.
Marco
Marco holds the belief that all life is a miracle from God, and that we come from
God. He is presenting the Theory of Moral Statues based on Human Properties. He
also presents with the Moral agency theory when trying to protect his wife from the
news until she is emotionally sound to deal with it.
Maria
Maria is using the Human Properties’ Theory of Moral Status to guide her
decision-making process. She believes that the final decision for her family
should be left to God alone and therefore relies heavily on prayer to discern God's
will.
Dr. Wilson
