Jurisprudentie Burgerlijk recht 2
Week 2a – Nakoming/niet-nakoming in het algemeen toerekening en non-conformiteit...............6
1. Oerlemans/Driessen................................................................................................................. 6
Essentie................................................................................................................................. 6
Samenvatting........................................................................................................................ 6
Hoge Raad............................................................................................................................ 7
Conclusie A-G....................................................................................................................... 8
2. Brok/Hubberts......................................................................................................................... 11
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 11
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 11
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 11
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 12
3. Matatag/De Schelde...............................................................................................................14
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 14
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 14
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 14
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 15
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 16
Week 2b – Ingebrekestelling vereist? Andere aspecten van afdeling 6.1.6................................18
4. Kinheim/Pelders..................................................................................................................... 18
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 18
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 18
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 19
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 20
5. Schwartz/Gnjatovic.................................................................................................................23
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 23
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 23
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 23
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 25
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 26
6. Endlich/Bouwmachines........................................................................................................... 29
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 29
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 29
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 30
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 31
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 34
1
,Week 3a – Ontbinding en opschorting........................................................................................38
7. Woningstichting Eigen Haard..................................................................................................38
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 38
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 38
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 39
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 42
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 43
Week 3b – Verjaring, rechtsverwerking en afstand.....................................................................46
8. Saelman/Academische Ziekenhuis.........................................................................................46
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 46
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 46
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 47
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 48
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 48
Week 4a – Rechtgevolgen van de overeenkomsten ten aanzien van partijen............................50
9. Curaçao/Boyé......................................................................................................................... 50
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 50
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 50
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 51
10. Khaly/Freezer, Deka-Hanno/Citroenas................................................................................52
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 52
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 52
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 52
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 53
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 55
11. Wierts/Visseren.................................................................................................................... 57
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 57
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 57
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 58
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 60
Week 4b – Overdracht, (voorwaardelijke) titel, beschikkingsbevoegdheid en levering...............61
12. Keereweer/Sogelease......................................................................................................... 61
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 61
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 61
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 62
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 63
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 64
2
,13. Hoogovens/Matex................................................................................................................ 66
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 66
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 66
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 67
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 68
14. Rabobank/Reuvers.............................................................................................................. 70
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 70
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 71
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 72
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 75
Week 5a – Levering registergoederen en derdenbescherming...................................................77
15. Eelder Woningbouw/Van Kammen c.s.................................................................................77
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 77
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 77
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 78
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 78
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 79
Week 6a – Levering vorderingen op naam (bij voorbaat) en derdenbescherming......................81
16. WUH/Emmerig q.q............................................................................................................... 81
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 81
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 81
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 81
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 82
17. De Liser de Morsain/Rabobank...........................................................................................85
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 85
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 85
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 85
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 86
18. Coface/Intergamma.............................................................................................................88
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 88
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 88
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 89
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 93
19. X Holding/Heijmans Infra.....................................................................................................94
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 94
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 94
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 94
3
, Het bepaaldheidsvereiste.............................................................................................94
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 96
Week 6b – Gemeenschap..........................................................................................................97
20. Warnaar/Wubben c.s...........................................................................................................97
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 97
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 97
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 98
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 99
Week 7a – Natrekking, zaaksvorming en (oneigenlijke) vermenging........................................101
21. Texeira de Mattos.............................................................................................................. 101
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 101
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 101
Noot................................................................................................................................... 102
22. Breda/Antonius..................................................................................................................105
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 105
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 105
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 105
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 107
Noot................................................................................................................................... 108
23. Dépex/Curatoren Bergel c.s...............................................................................................110
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 110
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 110
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 110
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 111
24. Portacabin......................................................................................................................... 113
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 113
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 113
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 114
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 114
25. Zalco III.............................................................................................................................. 117
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 117
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 117
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 119
(i) Het stellen van een redelijke termijn.......................................................................119
Beschikkingsbevoegdheid pandgever........................................................................120
Zaaksvorming.............................................................................................................121
Natrekking van roerende zaken..................................................................................121
4
, Verbinding/samensmelting.........................................................................................122
Vermenging................................................................................................................122
Pandrecht................................................................................................................... 122
Cassatie..................................................................................................................... 123
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 125
Week 7b – Verjaring en bezit....................................................................................................127
26. Rodewijn/Bouwman...........................................................................................................127
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 127
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 127
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 129
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 129
27. Mulder q.q./Hoogheemraadschap van Schieland en de Krimpenerwaard..........................131
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 131
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 131
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 132
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 134
28. Vogelzang c.s./Gemeente Landgraaf.................................................................................135
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 135
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 135
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 136
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 138
29. Gemeente Heusden/M. c.s................................................................................................139
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 139
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 139
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 141
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 143
5
Week 2a – Nakoming/niet-nakoming in het algemeen toerekening en non-conformiteit...............6
1. Oerlemans/Driessen................................................................................................................. 6
Essentie................................................................................................................................. 6
Samenvatting........................................................................................................................ 6
Hoge Raad............................................................................................................................ 7
Conclusie A-G....................................................................................................................... 8
2. Brok/Hubberts......................................................................................................................... 11
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 11
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 11
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 11
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 12
3. Matatag/De Schelde...............................................................................................................14
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 14
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 14
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 14
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 15
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 16
Week 2b – Ingebrekestelling vereist? Andere aspecten van afdeling 6.1.6................................18
4. Kinheim/Pelders..................................................................................................................... 18
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 18
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 18
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 19
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 20
5. Schwartz/Gnjatovic.................................................................................................................23
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 23
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 23
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 23
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 25
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 26
6. Endlich/Bouwmachines........................................................................................................... 29
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 29
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 29
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 30
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 31
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 34
1
,Week 3a – Ontbinding en opschorting........................................................................................38
7. Woningstichting Eigen Haard..................................................................................................38
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 38
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 38
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 39
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 42
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 43
Week 3b – Verjaring, rechtsverwerking en afstand.....................................................................46
8. Saelman/Academische Ziekenhuis.........................................................................................46
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 46
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 46
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 47
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 48
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 48
Week 4a – Rechtgevolgen van de overeenkomsten ten aanzien van partijen............................50
9. Curaçao/Boyé......................................................................................................................... 50
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 50
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 50
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 51
10. Khaly/Freezer, Deka-Hanno/Citroenas................................................................................52
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 52
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 52
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 52
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 53
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 55
11. Wierts/Visseren.................................................................................................................... 57
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 57
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 57
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 58
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 60
Week 4b – Overdracht, (voorwaardelijke) titel, beschikkingsbevoegdheid en levering...............61
12. Keereweer/Sogelease......................................................................................................... 61
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 61
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 61
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 62
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 63
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 64
2
,13. Hoogovens/Matex................................................................................................................ 66
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 66
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 66
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 67
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 68
14. Rabobank/Reuvers.............................................................................................................. 70
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 70
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 71
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 72
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 75
Week 5a – Levering registergoederen en derdenbescherming...................................................77
15. Eelder Woningbouw/Van Kammen c.s.................................................................................77
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 77
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 77
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 78
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 78
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 79
Week 6a – Levering vorderingen op naam (bij voorbaat) en derdenbescherming......................81
16. WUH/Emmerig q.q............................................................................................................... 81
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 81
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 81
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 81
Noot..................................................................................................................................... 82
17. De Liser de Morsain/Rabobank...........................................................................................85
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 85
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 85
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 85
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 86
18. Coface/Intergamma.............................................................................................................88
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 88
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 88
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 89
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 93
19. X Holding/Heijmans Infra.....................................................................................................94
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 94
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 94
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 94
3
, Het bepaaldheidsvereiste.............................................................................................94
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 96
Week 6b – Gemeenschap..........................................................................................................97
20. Warnaar/Wubben c.s...........................................................................................................97
Essentie............................................................................................................................... 97
Samenvatting...................................................................................................................... 97
Conclusie A-G..................................................................................................................... 98
Hoge Raad.......................................................................................................................... 99
Week 7a – Natrekking, zaaksvorming en (oneigenlijke) vermenging........................................101
21. Texeira de Mattos.............................................................................................................. 101
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 101
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 101
Noot................................................................................................................................... 102
22. Breda/Antonius..................................................................................................................105
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 105
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 105
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 105
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 107
Noot................................................................................................................................... 108
23. Dépex/Curatoren Bergel c.s...............................................................................................110
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 110
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 110
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 110
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 111
24. Portacabin......................................................................................................................... 113
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 113
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 113
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 114
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 114
25. Zalco III.............................................................................................................................. 117
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 117
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 117
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 119
(i) Het stellen van een redelijke termijn.......................................................................119
Beschikkingsbevoegdheid pandgever........................................................................120
Zaaksvorming.............................................................................................................121
Natrekking van roerende zaken..................................................................................121
4
, Verbinding/samensmelting.........................................................................................122
Vermenging................................................................................................................122
Pandrecht................................................................................................................... 122
Cassatie..................................................................................................................... 123
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 125
Week 7b – Verjaring en bezit....................................................................................................127
26. Rodewijn/Bouwman...........................................................................................................127
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 127
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 127
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 129
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 129
27. Mulder q.q./Hoogheemraadschap van Schieland en de Krimpenerwaard..........................131
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 131
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 131
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 132
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 134
28. Vogelzang c.s./Gemeente Landgraaf.................................................................................135
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 135
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 135
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 136
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 138
29. Gemeente Heusden/M. c.s................................................................................................139
Essentie............................................................................................................................. 139
Samenvatting..................................................................................................................... 139
Conclusie A-G................................................................................................................... 141
Hoge Raad........................................................................................................................ 143
5
