,TAX2601 Assignment 1 (COMPLETE ANSWERS)
Semester 1 2025 - DUE 7 April 2025; 100% TRUSTED
Complete, trusted solutions and explanations.
QUESTION 1
Mr Xhumalo lives in Gqeberha, South Africa. He manufactures and sells
various grass baskets and placemats from a street stall. Due to the high
demand for his products, he concluded a sales agreement with a well-
known houseware retailer in South Africa. In terms of the agreement, the
retailer will purchase R25 000 worth of products from Mr Xhumalo on 15
February 2025 on credit. The goods must be manufactured and delivered
by 15 March 2025, with payment scheduled for 31 March 2025. The
agreement clearly states that Mr Xhumalo will only become entitled to
payment once he has delivered the goods. Mr Xhumalo’s accountant is
uncertain in which year of assessment the R25 000 must be declared for tax
purposes and contacted you for advice. REQUIRED MARKS Discuss whether
the R25 000 of the sale will constitute gross income in the hands of Mr
Xhumalo for the 2025 year of assessment. Note: • You can support the main
issue in the question with relevant case law from the module's prescribed
case law. 12
To determine whether the R25,000 from Mr. Xhumalo’s sale will constitute gross
income in the 2025 year of assessment, we need to consider the principles
surrounding the recognition of income for tax purposes. Specifically, we need to
understand when income is considered to have been "earned" in terms of South
African tax law, and how this applies to Mr. Xhumalo's situation.
Relevant Principles of Taxation
In South Africa, the Income Tax Act No. 58 of 1962, particularly section 1, defines
gross income as "the total amount, in cash or otherwise, received by or accrued to
a taxpayer during a year of assessment, excluding any receipts or accruals of a
capital nature."
, When determining when income should be recognized for tax purposes, the key
considerations typically revolve around:
1. The accrual basis of taxation – Income is generally included in gross
income when it accrues to a taxpayer, meaning when the taxpayer becomes
entitled to the income, irrespective of when the cash is received.
2. The realization of income – Income accrues when the taxpayer has
performed the necessary actions to earn it, as per the agreement or
transaction.
3. The completion of the sale – In terms of the specific tax rules, income from
the sale of goods typically becomes taxable when the transaction has been
completed, which generally occurs when the goods have been delivered and
ownership has passed to the buyer.
Application to Mr. Xhumalo's Case
In the case of Mr. Xhumalo, we know the following details:
The retailer agrees to purchase R25,000 worth of products from Mr.
Xhumalo on 15 February 2025 on credit.
The goods must be delivered by 15 March 2025.
Payment is scheduled for 31 March 2025, but Mr. Xhumalo will only be
entitled to payment once the goods have been delivered.
From these facts, we can determine the following:
1. Accrual of the sale – The agreement for the sale is concluded on 15
February 2025, but the sale is not yet completed because the goods must still
be manufactured and delivered by 15 March 2025. As per the terms of the
agreement, Mr. Xhumalo is only entitled to payment once the goods are
delivered.
2. Delivery and entitlement to payment – According to South African tax
principles, income from the sale of goods accrues when the seller has
fulfilled their obligations (e.g., delivery). In this case, Mr. Xhumalo will not
be entitled to payment until he has delivered the goods, which is due by 15
March 2025. The key event for the accrual of income, according to the
agreement, is the delivery of the goods.
3. Date of accrual for tax purposes – The R25,000 will likely be recognized
as gross income for Mr. Xhumalo for the year of assessment in which the
goods are delivered. Since the goods must be delivered by 15 March 2025,
Semester 1 2025 - DUE 7 April 2025; 100% TRUSTED
Complete, trusted solutions and explanations.
QUESTION 1
Mr Xhumalo lives in Gqeberha, South Africa. He manufactures and sells
various grass baskets and placemats from a street stall. Due to the high
demand for his products, he concluded a sales agreement with a well-
known houseware retailer in South Africa. In terms of the agreement, the
retailer will purchase R25 000 worth of products from Mr Xhumalo on 15
February 2025 on credit. The goods must be manufactured and delivered
by 15 March 2025, with payment scheduled for 31 March 2025. The
agreement clearly states that Mr Xhumalo will only become entitled to
payment once he has delivered the goods. Mr Xhumalo’s accountant is
uncertain in which year of assessment the R25 000 must be declared for tax
purposes and contacted you for advice. REQUIRED MARKS Discuss whether
the R25 000 of the sale will constitute gross income in the hands of Mr
Xhumalo for the 2025 year of assessment. Note: • You can support the main
issue in the question with relevant case law from the module's prescribed
case law. 12
To determine whether the R25,000 from Mr. Xhumalo’s sale will constitute gross
income in the 2025 year of assessment, we need to consider the principles
surrounding the recognition of income for tax purposes. Specifically, we need to
understand when income is considered to have been "earned" in terms of South
African tax law, and how this applies to Mr. Xhumalo's situation.
Relevant Principles of Taxation
In South Africa, the Income Tax Act No. 58 of 1962, particularly section 1, defines
gross income as "the total amount, in cash or otherwise, received by or accrued to
a taxpayer during a year of assessment, excluding any receipts or accruals of a
capital nature."
, When determining when income should be recognized for tax purposes, the key
considerations typically revolve around:
1. The accrual basis of taxation – Income is generally included in gross
income when it accrues to a taxpayer, meaning when the taxpayer becomes
entitled to the income, irrespective of when the cash is received.
2. The realization of income – Income accrues when the taxpayer has
performed the necessary actions to earn it, as per the agreement or
transaction.
3. The completion of the sale – In terms of the specific tax rules, income from
the sale of goods typically becomes taxable when the transaction has been
completed, which generally occurs when the goods have been delivered and
ownership has passed to the buyer.
Application to Mr. Xhumalo's Case
In the case of Mr. Xhumalo, we know the following details:
The retailer agrees to purchase R25,000 worth of products from Mr.
Xhumalo on 15 February 2025 on credit.
The goods must be delivered by 15 March 2025.
Payment is scheduled for 31 March 2025, but Mr. Xhumalo will only be
entitled to payment once the goods have been delivered.
From these facts, we can determine the following:
1. Accrual of the sale – The agreement for the sale is concluded on 15
February 2025, but the sale is not yet completed because the goods must still
be manufactured and delivered by 15 March 2025. As per the terms of the
agreement, Mr. Xhumalo is only entitled to payment once the goods are
delivered.
2. Delivery and entitlement to payment – According to South African tax
principles, income from the sale of goods accrues when the seller has
fulfilled their obligations (e.g., delivery). In this case, Mr. Xhumalo will not
be entitled to payment until he has delivered the goods, which is due by 15
March 2025. The key event for the accrual of income, according to the
agreement, is the delivery of the goods.
3. Date of accrual for tax purposes – The R25,000 will likely be recognized
as gross income for Mr. Xhumalo for the year of assessment in which the
goods are delivered. Since the goods must be delivered by 15 March 2025,
