INDIRECT DISCRIMINATION
Indirect Discrimination-
v Indirect discrimination under s19 of the EqA 2010 occurs where an employer:
o Applies a provision, criterion or practice which
o Puts workers sharing a protected characteristic
o At a particular disadvantage
o As compared with workers who do not possess that characteristic
Indirect discrimination occurs when there is equal treatment of ALL groups but the
effect of the PCP imposed by an employer has a disproportionate adverse impact on
one group, unless the requirement can be justified
STEP 1: IS THE CLAIMANT ELIGIBLE TO BRING A CLAIM?
The Act protects, amongst others:
» Employees (s39)
» Employees after their employment has ended (s108)
» Job applicants (s39).
» Contract workers (s41)
» Office holders (s50)
» Trade union members (s57)
» Employees whose employment has ended (s108).
s83(2): defines ‘Employment’ as “employment under a contract of employment, a
contract of apprenticeship or a contract personally to do work”
**No length of service requirement
Time Limit: 3 months (LESS A DAY) from the date of the unlawful act of discrimination
(s123(1))
The Tribunal has discretion to extend the time period if it thinks it “just and equitable”
(123(1)(b))
, STEP 2: IDENTIFY THE RELEVANT PROTECTED CHARACTERISTIC
s4 sets out the certain ‘protected’ characteristics:
Age (s5); ¾ The Explanatory Notes give the following examples:
• An age group would include ‘over fifties’ or twenty-one year olds.
• A person aged twenty-one does not share the same characteristic of age with ‘people in their forties’.
However, a person aged twenty-one and people in their forties can share the characteristic of being in
the ‘under fifty’ age range.
Disability (s6 and Sch ¾ Unless the parties agree that a claimant is a disabled person at the relevant time, the burden of proof is on the
1); claimant to show that they were a disabled person.
¾ A person has a disability, therefore, if he has:
• a physical or mental impairment, which has
• a substantial and
• long-term adverse effect on his ability to carry out
• normal day-to-day activities (s 6(1))
¾ A ‘disabled person’ means a person who has a disability (s 6(2))
Gender reassignment ¾ I.e. someone who is proposing to undergo, has undergone, or is undergoing gender reassignment
(s7); ¾ There is NO requirement of being under medical supervision
*8.2.5
Marriage and civil ¾ DOES NOT include those who are single and cohabiting
partnership (s8); *8.2.6 ¾ The Explanatory Note gives examples:
§ A person who is engaged to be married is not married and therefore does not have this protected
characteristic.
§ A divorcee or a person whose civil partnership has been dissolved is not married or in a civil
partnership and therefore does not have this protected characteristic.
Pregnancy and ¾ Protects a woman from discrimination because of her current or a previous pregnancy
maternity (s18); ¾ Protects her from maternity discrimination, which includes treating her unfavourably because she is breast-
feeding, for 26 weeks after giving birth, and provides that pregnancy or maternity discrimination as defined
cannot be treated as sex discrimination
Race (s9); ¾ Includes “colour”, “nationality, “ethnic or national origins” (s9(1)(a)-(b))
*8.2.2
¾ The Explanatory Note gives the following examples:
§ Colour includes being black or white
§ Nationality includes being a British, Australian or Swiss citizen
§ Ethnic or national origins include being from a Roma background or of Chinese heritage
§ A racial group could be ‘black Britons’ which would encompass those people who are both black and
who are British citizens
Religion of belief (s10); ¾ Includes reference to a “lack of belief” (s10(2))
*8.2.3 ¾ Includes “philosophical beliefs” (s10(2)) e.g. belief action is urgently needed to address climate change
(Nicholson v Grainger plc [2010] IRLR 4)
¾ Jews may also constitute a racial group under the definition in s9
¾ The Explanatory Note states that the criteria for determining what constitutes a ‘philosophical belief’ are that it
must:
• Be genuinely held;
• Be a belief and not an opinion or a viewpoint based on the present state of information available;
• Be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour;
• Attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance; and
• Be worthy of respect in a democratic society, compatible with human dignity and not conflict with the
fundamental rights of others
¾ Can include political beliefs (Olivier v DWP (ET/1701407/13))
¾ If an employee genuinely believes their faith requires a particular course of action, that is sufficient to make it part
of their religion (Hussain v Bhullar Bros (ET/1806638/04)
Sex (s11); ¾ A reference to a person who has a particular protected characteristic is a reference to a man or to a woman;
*8.2.1 ¾ A reference to persons who share a protected characteristic is a reference to persons of the same sex
Sexual orientation ¾ The Explanatory Note gives the following examples:
(s12) • A man who experiences sexual attraction towards both men and women is ‘bisexual’ in terms of sexual
*8.2.4 orientation even if he has only had relationships with women
• A man and a women who are both attracted only to people of the opposite sex from them share a sexual
orientation
• A man who is attracted only to other men is a gay man
• A woman who is attracted only to other women is a lesbian.
Indirect Discrimination-
v Indirect discrimination under s19 of the EqA 2010 occurs where an employer:
o Applies a provision, criterion or practice which
o Puts workers sharing a protected characteristic
o At a particular disadvantage
o As compared with workers who do not possess that characteristic
Indirect discrimination occurs when there is equal treatment of ALL groups but the
effect of the PCP imposed by an employer has a disproportionate adverse impact on
one group, unless the requirement can be justified
STEP 1: IS THE CLAIMANT ELIGIBLE TO BRING A CLAIM?
The Act protects, amongst others:
» Employees (s39)
» Employees after their employment has ended (s108)
» Job applicants (s39).
» Contract workers (s41)
» Office holders (s50)
» Trade union members (s57)
» Employees whose employment has ended (s108).
s83(2): defines ‘Employment’ as “employment under a contract of employment, a
contract of apprenticeship or a contract personally to do work”
**No length of service requirement
Time Limit: 3 months (LESS A DAY) from the date of the unlawful act of discrimination
(s123(1))
The Tribunal has discretion to extend the time period if it thinks it “just and equitable”
(123(1)(b))
, STEP 2: IDENTIFY THE RELEVANT PROTECTED CHARACTERISTIC
s4 sets out the certain ‘protected’ characteristics:
Age (s5); ¾ The Explanatory Notes give the following examples:
• An age group would include ‘over fifties’ or twenty-one year olds.
• A person aged twenty-one does not share the same characteristic of age with ‘people in their forties’.
However, a person aged twenty-one and people in their forties can share the characteristic of being in
the ‘under fifty’ age range.
Disability (s6 and Sch ¾ Unless the parties agree that a claimant is a disabled person at the relevant time, the burden of proof is on the
1); claimant to show that they were a disabled person.
¾ A person has a disability, therefore, if he has:
• a physical or mental impairment, which has
• a substantial and
• long-term adverse effect on his ability to carry out
• normal day-to-day activities (s 6(1))
¾ A ‘disabled person’ means a person who has a disability (s 6(2))
Gender reassignment ¾ I.e. someone who is proposing to undergo, has undergone, or is undergoing gender reassignment
(s7); ¾ There is NO requirement of being under medical supervision
*8.2.5
Marriage and civil ¾ DOES NOT include those who are single and cohabiting
partnership (s8); *8.2.6 ¾ The Explanatory Note gives examples:
§ A person who is engaged to be married is not married and therefore does not have this protected
characteristic.
§ A divorcee or a person whose civil partnership has been dissolved is not married or in a civil
partnership and therefore does not have this protected characteristic.
Pregnancy and ¾ Protects a woman from discrimination because of her current or a previous pregnancy
maternity (s18); ¾ Protects her from maternity discrimination, which includes treating her unfavourably because she is breast-
feeding, for 26 weeks after giving birth, and provides that pregnancy or maternity discrimination as defined
cannot be treated as sex discrimination
Race (s9); ¾ Includes “colour”, “nationality, “ethnic or national origins” (s9(1)(a)-(b))
*8.2.2
¾ The Explanatory Note gives the following examples:
§ Colour includes being black or white
§ Nationality includes being a British, Australian or Swiss citizen
§ Ethnic or national origins include being from a Roma background or of Chinese heritage
§ A racial group could be ‘black Britons’ which would encompass those people who are both black and
who are British citizens
Religion of belief (s10); ¾ Includes reference to a “lack of belief” (s10(2))
*8.2.3 ¾ Includes “philosophical beliefs” (s10(2)) e.g. belief action is urgently needed to address climate change
(Nicholson v Grainger plc [2010] IRLR 4)
¾ Jews may also constitute a racial group under the definition in s9
¾ The Explanatory Note states that the criteria for determining what constitutes a ‘philosophical belief’ are that it
must:
• Be genuinely held;
• Be a belief and not an opinion or a viewpoint based on the present state of information available;
• Be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour;
• Attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance; and
• Be worthy of respect in a democratic society, compatible with human dignity and not conflict with the
fundamental rights of others
¾ Can include political beliefs (Olivier v DWP (ET/1701407/13))
¾ If an employee genuinely believes their faith requires a particular course of action, that is sufficient to make it part
of their religion (Hussain v Bhullar Bros (ET/1806638/04)
Sex (s11); ¾ A reference to a person who has a particular protected characteristic is a reference to a man or to a woman;
*8.2.1 ¾ A reference to persons who share a protected characteristic is a reference to persons of the same sex
Sexual orientation ¾ The Explanatory Note gives the following examples:
(s12) • A man who experiences sexual attraction towards both men and women is ‘bisexual’ in terms of sexual
*8.2.4 orientation even if he has only had relationships with women
• A man and a women who are both attracted only to people of the opposite sex from them share a sexual
orientation
• A man who is attracted only to other men is a gay man
• A woman who is attracted only to other women is a lesbian.
