,© 2019 University of South Africa
All rights reserved
Printed and published by the
University of South Africa
Muckleneuk, Pretoria
PVL3704/2/2019-2021
70733538
Shutterstock.com images used
Editor and Styler
HSY_Style
, CONTENTS
LEARNING UNIT 1: GENERAL OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION TO
ESTOPPEL 1
1.1 GENERAL OVERVIEW 1
1.2 INTRODUCTION TO ESTOPPEL 3
1.2.1 Meaning of the concept “estoppel” 3
LEARNING UNIT 2: THE ENGLISH AND SOUTH AFRICAN LAW OF ESTOPPEL 6
2.1 ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF ESTOPPEL IN ENGLISH LAW 6
2.2 RECEPTION OF THE ENGLISH LAW PRINCIPLES OF ESTOPPEL BY
REPRESENTATION (PRESCRIBED READING) 9
2.3 REQUIREMENTS OF ENGLISH LAW FOR ESTOPPEL BY
REPRESENTATION 12
LEARNING UNIT 3: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: INTRODUCTION; MISREPRESENTATION 14
3.1 INTRODUCTION 16
3.2 MISREPRESENTATION 16
3.2.1 Representation 17
3.2.2 Misrepresentation 18
3.2.3 Misrepresentation by omission (omissio) 20
3.2.4 Misrepresentation in terms of which an owner entrusts his or her property to the
possession of another 22
3.2.5 The person to whom the misrepresentation must be made 24
LEARNING UNIT 4: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: FAULT 27
4.1 INTRODUCTION: INTENT AND NEGLIGENCE 29
4.2 THE NEGLIGENCE REQUIREMENT IN SOUTH AFRICAN CASE LAW 30
4.3 CASES WHERE NEGLIGENCE IS NOT REQUIRED 35
4.3.1 Cases where the rei vindicatiois not applicable 35
4.3.2 A possible exception: the agent for sale or factor 38
4.4 FAULT ON THE PART OF THE DECEIVED PERSON 38
LEARNING UNIT 5: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: PREJUDICE 41
5.1 INTRODUCTION 42
5.2 TWO APPROACHES 42
LEARNING UNIT 6: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: CAUSATION 47
6.1 INTRODUCTION: FACTUAL AND LEGAL CAUSATION 48
6.2 THE “PROXIMATE CAUSE” TEST 49
LEARNING UNIT 7: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: THE RELIANCE ON ESTOPPEL MUST BE PERMISSIBLE
IN LAW 53
7.1 INTRODUCTION 55
7.2 ILLEGAL OR INVALID ACTS 55
7.3 ULTRA VIRES ACTS 57
7.4 STATUS AND LEGAL CAPACITY 58
7.5 HIRE-PURCHASE CONTRACTS (CREDIT AGREEMENTS) 58
7.5.1 Introduction 58
PVL3704/2/2019-2021 (iii)
, CONTENTS
7.5.2 Hire-purchase transactions in case law 59
7.5.3 Conclusion 64
LEARNING UNIT 8: THE APPLICATION OF ESTOPPEL IN CERTAIN PRACTICAL
INSTANCES 67
8.1 INTRODUCTION 69
8.2 ESTOPPEL AND THE REI VINDICATIO 70
8.2.1 The effect of a successful reliance on estoppel against the rei vindicatio 70
8.3 ESTOPPEL AND REPRESENTATION IN TERMS OF MANDATE 72
8.4 ESTOPPEL AND PARTNERSHIP 73
8.5 ESTOPPEL AND THE CONCLUSION OF A CONTRACT 73
8.6 ESTOPPEL AND WAIVER OF RIGHTS 77
LEARNING UNIT 9: THE BASIS AND NATURE OF ESTOPPEL 79
9.1 INTRODUCTION 80
9.2 THE EXCEPTIO DOLI 80
9.3 THE MAXIM NEMO CONTRA SUUM FACTUM VENIRE DEBET 82
9.4 PROTECTION OF GOOD FAITH 83
9.5 MISREPRESENTATION 84
9.6 ESTOPPEL AS A RULE OF EVIDENCE 87
9.7 ESTOPPEL AS A LEGAL REMEDY SUI GENERIS 87
(iv)
All rights reserved
Printed and published by the
University of South Africa
Muckleneuk, Pretoria
PVL3704/2/2019-2021
70733538
Shutterstock.com images used
Editor and Styler
HSY_Style
, CONTENTS
LEARNING UNIT 1: GENERAL OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION TO
ESTOPPEL 1
1.1 GENERAL OVERVIEW 1
1.2 INTRODUCTION TO ESTOPPEL 3
1.2.1 Meaning of the concept “estoppel” 3
LEARNING UNIT 2: THE ENGLISH AND SOUTH AFRICAN LAW OF ESTOPPEL 6
2.1 ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF ESTOPPEL IN ENGLISH LAW 6
2.2 RECEPTION OF THE ENGLISH LAW PRINCIPLES OF ESTOPPEL BY
REPRESENTATION (PRESCRIBED READING) 9
2.3 REQUIREMENTS OF ENGLISH LAW FOR ESTOPPEL BY
REPRESENTATION 12
LEARNING UNIT 3: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: INTRODUCTION; MISREPRESENTATION 14
3.1 INTRODUCTION 16
3.2 MISREPRESENTATION 16
3.2.1 Representation 17
3.2.2 Misrepresentation 18
3.2.3 Misrepresentation by omission (omissio) 20
3.2.4 Misrepresentation in terms of which an owner entrusts his or her property to the
possession of another 22
3.2.5 The person to whom the misrepresentation must be made 24
LEARNING UNIT 4: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: FAULT 27
4.1 INTRODUCTION: INTENT AND NEGLIGENCE 29
4.2 THE NEGLIGENCE REQUIREMENT IN SOUTH AFRICAN CASE LAW 30
4.3 CASES WHERE NEGLIGENCE IS NOT REQUIRED 35
4.3.1 Cases where the rei vindicatiois not applicable 35
4.3.2 A possible exception: the agent for sale or factor 38
4.4 FAULT ON THE PART OF THE DECEIVED PERSON 38
LEARNING UNIT 5: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: PREJUDICE 41
5.1 INTRODUCTION 42
5.2 TWO APPROACHES 42
LEARNING UNIT 6: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: CAUSATION 47
6.1 INTRODUCTION: FACTUAL AND LEGAL CAUSATION 48
6.2 THE “PROXIMATE CAUSE” TEST 49
LEARNING UNIT 7: REQUIREMENTS FOR A SUCCESSFUL RELIANCE ON
ESTOPPEL: THE RELIANCE ON ESTOPPEL MUST BE PERMISSIBLE
IN LAW 53
7.1 INTRODUCTION 55
7.2 ILLEGAL OR INVALID ACTS 55
7.3 ULTRA VIRES ACTS 57
7.4 STATUS AND LEGAL CAPACITY 58
7.5 HIRE-PURCHASE CONTRACTS (CREDIT AGREEMENTS) 58
7.5.1 Introduction 58
PVL3704/2/2019-2021 (iii)
, CONTENTS
7.5.2 Hire-purchase transactions in case law 59
7.5.3 Conclusion 64
LEARNING UNIT 8: THE APPLICATION OF ESTOPPEL IN CERTAIN PRACTICAL
INSTANCES 67
8.1 INTRODUCTION 69
8.2 ESTOPPEL AND THE REI VINDICATIO 70
8.2.1 The effect of a successful reliance on estoppel against the rei vindicatio 70
8.3 ESTOPPEL AND REPRESENTATION IN TERMS OF MANDATE 72
8.4 ESTOPPEL AND PARTNERSHIP 73
8.5 ESTOPPEL AND THE CONCLUSION OF A CONTRACT 73
8.6 ESTOPPEL AND WAIVER OF RIGHTS 77
LEARNING UNIT 9: THE BASIS AND NATURE OF ESTOPPEL 79
9.1 INTRODUCTION 80
9.2 THE EXCEPTIO DOLI 80
9.3 THE MAXIM NEMO CONTRA SUUM FACTUM VENIRE DEBET 82
9.4 PROTECTION OF GOOD FAITH 83
9.5 MISREPRESENTATION 84
9.6 ESTOPPEL AS A RULE OF EVIDENCE 87
9.7 ESTOPPEL AS A LEGAL REMEDY SUI GENERIS 87
(iv)