ILW1501
1. What is the Law?
• is a set of rules / norms that governs human behaviour / conduct.
• should be obeyed by all of society & is binding
• is enforced by the state / state organs &
• when you do something wrong, you may be prosecuted & punished or be ordered to compensate the
other party you have injured
2. Legal norms (a norm is a standard of human conduct or a rule of human behavior).
• There is a difference between a legal norm and a moral norm. In the case of a legal norm, the
whole community is bound, and this is what separates the legal norm from the moral norm.
3. There are two methods which are used to divide the South Africa law into two main divisions.
Name them:
3.1 Main division Public law & Private law
3.1.1 Public law deals with the relationship between the state/state organs and the individual
3.1.2 Private law with the relationship between individuals and other individuals.
3.2 Main division Formal (procedural) law & Substantive (material) law
3.2.1 Formal or procedural law is that part of the law which deals with the procedures that must
be followed in legal proceedings. These are rules that govern the way we act in courts, the
kinds of evidence that are allowed, and so on.
If the formal law meets certain basic requirements and is always applied in exactly the same
way, we say that formal justice has been achieved.
These basic requirements with which formal law must comply in order to achieve
formal justice are the following:
1. There must be explicit rules laid down to show how people must be treated in specific
cases.
2. The rules must apply generally. This means that the rules must apply to all people in the
group in the same circumstances.
3. The rules must be applied impartially by a legal institution. This basically means that the
judge may not be biased – he or she may not apply the rules unequally.
, lOMoARcPSD|46224805
3.2.2 Substantive or material law is that part of the law which determines the content and the
meaning of the different legal rules. Substantive justice concerns the content of the rule,
and not the way in which it is applied (procedure). To establish whether substantive
justice has been done, the content of the rule itself is looked at to determine whether it
is just and fair.
4. Questions and Solutions
1. The fact that Roman law had been collected in a__________, resulted in the study thereof by
medieval universities in the 12th century
a) Constitution
b) Placaet
c) Codification
d) Promulgation
2. The following legal disciples fall within the private law
a) Law of criminal procedure, law of evidence, law of persons
b) Administrative law, constitutional law, international law
c) Law of persons, law of personality, law of patrimony, family law
d) Mercantile law, criminal law, enrichment
3. The following legal disciples fall within the public law
a) Law of criminal procedure, law of evidence, law of persons
b) Administrative law, constitutional law, international law
c) Law of procedure, criminal law, constitutional law, administrative law, international law
d) Mercantile law, criminal law, enrichment
4. Law of succession, law of property and law of obligations are subdivisions of ____________ in
private law
a) Law of patrimony
b) Law of persons
c) Family law
d) Law of personality
5. Law of _____________ deals with unlawful act that causes harm to another person or their
property
a) personality
b) persons
c) delict
, lOMoARcPSD|46224805
d) contracts
6. Law of _______________concentrates on the means or assets of people (inheritance,
ownership, contracts)
a) patrimony
b) persons
c) delict
d) personality
7. Which one of these other laws is a branch of law that looks at other ideologies or perspectives
(such as natural law, feminism etc)
a) Labour law
b) Mercantile law
c) Legal philosophy (jurisprudence)
d) Conflict of laws
8. Which main division of South African law will be applicable in this scenario?
Larry and Peter are friends. One day they argue over a girl which they both wish to date. Larry
beats Peter up. Peter report the incident to the police. Larry is later prosecuted in terms of a
stature that prohibits the crime of assault and has to appear in court for his trial
a) Private law, because it deals with the relationship between individuals
b) Public law, because he is prosecuted under a stature that prohibits the crime of assault,
therefore it involves the state and the individuals
9. Name one division of your answer in 8 (which falls under substantive/material law) that will be
applicable to this scenario
a) Criminal law – since is the one that states the punishment or penalty that must be imposed
by the state for this kind of crime
b) Administrative law – since it is concerned with general administration of the state eg ministers
10. With reference to your answer in 9, identify the subdivision of law of procedure that will be
applicable in our scenario
a) Law of criminal procedure – tell us how civil cases are carried out
11. If the states decides to call a witness during Larry’s trial, which further subdivision of the law of
procedure will be applicable?
a) Law of evidence – because it outlines what kind of evidence is permitted and how it should
be presented
12. Is there any possibility that the law of civil procedure can be applicable in the scenario above,
Give a reason for your answer
, lOMoARcPSD|46224805
a) No – because civil law procedure is a process by which private law disputes are brought
before the courts, so in this case of assault it is public law case it involves assault which
makes it a criminal law procedure matter.
13. Statutory law is a written law, which state body is responsible for this law?
a) Legislature or parliament
14. Suppose the Supreme Court of appeal has just been hearing a case similar to Peter and Larry’s
and has set a precedent in a case similar to our scenario above. Which court or courts will have
to follow this precedent?
a) Lower courts are bound by the decisions of the higher court, which means the high courts
and magistrate courts will be bound under judicial precedent
15. Name the two requirements for the operation of the precedent system
a) There should be a law reporting system that is effective so that the lower courts will be able
to see the decisions of the higher courts
b) There should be a hierarchy of courts to be feasible
16. Following the decision made in the Constitutional Court in 2005 where it was found that the
definition of marriage was unconstitutional, the Civil Union Act 17 of 2006 was implemented. How
has this act changed the way in which permanent cohabitation relationships of homo and
heterosexual are viewed?
a) the Civil Union Act 17 of 2006 allows same sex to enter into marriages in terms of the Act
and it is up to the partners to decide if they want their union to be called a marriage or a civil
union. The union has the same consequences as the marriages act
17. The Constitutional Court found the definition of marriage to be unconstitutional on the grounds of
infringement of certain fundamental rights. Name these fundamental rights.
a) Right to equality
b) Right to human dignity
18. What gives a person the claim to fundamental rights?
a) By virtue of being born humans we have that dignity that should be maintained
19. Explain what fundamental rights entail
a) For every person is born has human dignity and it is this dignity that gives a person a claim to
fundamental rights. They are natural rights for every human being. Fundamental rights can
categorized into first generation rights (guard against abuse of state powers), second
generation rights (social economic issues), third generation (related to group instead of
individual issues).
20. Name the measures set out in Section 36 of the Constitutions in terms of which a right is limited
a) The law which limit the right must apply to everyone
b) The limitation must be reasonable and justifiable in a democratic society (peace and freedom
prevail)