• ¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis
  • Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
  • Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
  • Leer en línea o como PDF
Vender
¿Dónde estudias?
Tu idioma
Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 6 páginas
Resumen

Summary Defences

Document preview thumbnail
Vista previa 1 fuera de 6 páginas

Considers the defences available to those accused of a tortious act.

Vista previa del contenido

Chapter 26

Defences

26.1 The basics:

 D denying that he is liable to the C because he did nothing wrong-> Volenti non fit injuria (no
wrong is done to the willing)
 D arguing he is not liable to the C because, even if he did something wrong to the C, the C
still cannot sue him for reasons of public policy, or the proper administration of justice.
 The distinction ^ is important for the purpose of evaluating whether or not a particular
defence should be recognised or not.
 The NWDs need no justification.
 PPDs (Illegality (ex turpi causa non oritur action)) are in need of very strong justification if
they are to be recognised-> ‘the rule of public policy that has first claim on the loyalty of the
law [is] that wrongs should be remedied.’

26.9 Volenti non fit injuria (no wrong is done to the willing; consent)

A. The rule:
- 1. Fully consenting
- 2. If C willingly took the risk that she would suffer that kind of loss in the way she
suffered it. 2=more controversial
- Morris v Murray [1991] -> two guys getting drunk. D suggests to ‘go on a flight on the
plane’. C agrees. They get on the plane-> it crashes; C very injured. C simply agreed. It
wasn’t going on the plane that caused the injury-> it was D’s careless driving. C didn’t
consent to the specific manoeuvre that resulted in the wreckage. Only consented to
risky actions. The claim fails-> court states that there was enough consent there-> the
consent of getting onto a plane with a drunk pilot is consenting to this kind of risk.
- C consents to, or goes along with, some activity which poses a risk to C if D is negligent
- C must know of the risk and voluntarily take it (cf rescue)
- Depends on gravity of the risk
B. Exceptions to the rule:
- Paternalistic duties-> A owed B a duty to stop B harming herself.
- Traffic accidents-> Road Traffic Act 1988-> “The fact that a [passenger] has
willingly accepted as his the risk of negligence eon the part of the [driver] shall
not be treated as negativing any… liability of the [driver].”
- The fireman’s rule=non exception. Some American states have adopted what is
known as the fireman’s rule under which someone whose job involves the risk of
suffering a particular kind of loss cannot seek to recover compensatory damages
if he actually suffers that kind of loss in doing his job.
- Objectively risky doesn’t count-> C has to know what they are getting into-> free
and voluntary choice to do so. Doesn’t cover cases of rescue
- Attempting to rescue someone and getting injured-> you’ve introduced yourself
to the danger
- Not acting voluntarily there ^-> acting under moral compulsion
- Voluntary=can reasonable say no but choose to get involved-> not the type in
rescue
- Rescuers want to be rewarded
- Certain sorts of risks aren’t pinned on the C who took them

Libro relacionado
 image
Nicholas J. Mcbride, Roderick Bagshaw Tort Law
Editorial: Desconocido ISBN: 9781292071237 Edición: 5

Información del documento

Estudio
¿Un libro?
Desconocido
Subido en
27 de septiembre de 2019
Número de páginas
6
Escrito en
2017/2018
Tipo
Resumen
$4.71

¿Documento equivocado? Cámbialo gratis Dentro de los 14 días posteriores a la compra y antes de descargarlo, puedes elegir otro documento. Puedes gastar el importe de nuevo.
Escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron
Inmediatamente disponible después del pago
Leer en línea o como PDF

Seller avatar
Los indicadores de reputación están sujetos a la cantidad de artículos vendidos por una tarifa y las reseñas que ha recibido por esos documentos. Hay tres niveles: Bronce, Plata y Oro. Cuanto mayor reputación, más podrás confiar en la calidad del trabajo del vendedor.
topqualitynotes
4.5
(2)
Vendido
59
Seguidores
43
Artículos
97
Última venta
2 semanas hace



Por qué los estudiantes eligen Stuvia

Creado por compañeros estudiantes, verificado por reseñas

Calidad en la que puedes confiar: escrito por estudiantes que aprobaron y evaluado por otros que han usado estos resúmenes.

¿No estás satisfecho? Elige otro documento

¡No te preocupes! Puedes elegir directamente otro documento que se ajuste mejor a lo que buscas.

Paga como quieras, empieza a estudiar al instante

Sin suscripción, sin compromisos. Paga como estés acostumbrado con tarjeta de crédito y descarga tu documento PDF inmediatamente.

Student with book image

“Comprado, descargado y aprobado. Así de fácil puede ser.”

Alisha Student

Preguntas frecuentes