- Research Methods -
Types of Experiment
1) Laboratory Experiment
The aim of all lab experiments is to control all revel vent variables expect for one key variable,
which is altered to see what the effect of this is. The variable altered is called the IV and the result
of this which is being measured is called the DV. Lab experiments are conducted in artificial
settings.
Strengths:
- Control : The effects of confounding variables (those that have an effect in addition to the
variable of interest.
- Replication : Strict controls mean that the study can be ran again to check the findings
- Causal Relationships : Ideally its possible to establish whether one variable actually causes
change in another
Limitations:
- Artificial : Experiments may lack ecological validity
- Demand Characteristics : Participants may respond according to what they think is being
investigated, which can bias the results.
- Ethics - Deception is often used, making informed consent difficult
2) Field Experiments
Field experiments are conducted outside of the laboratory. Behaviour is measured in a natural
environment like a school, the street or in a train. A key variable is still altered so that its effect can
be measured.
Strengths:
- Casual Relationship : You can still establish a causal relationship by manipulating the key
variable and measuring its effect, although it is very hard to do in a field experiment
- Ecologically valid - Field experiments are less artificial than those done in a lab, so they relate
to life better
- Demand Characteristics - (participants trying to guess what the researcher expects from them
and performing differently because of it) - These can be avoided if the participants don’t know
they're in a study
Limitations:
- Less control : Confounding variables may be more likely in a natural environment
- Ethics : Participants who didn't agree to take part might expense distress and often cant be
debriefed. Observation must respect privacy.
3) Natural Experiments
This is where the researcher looks at how the independent variable, which isn't being manipulated
by the researcher affects the dependent variable. The independent variable isn't manipulated
because its an event which occurs naturally. An example is research into the effect of single-sex
schools and a mix set school on behaviour. Participants are usually allocated to each condition
randomly.
, Strengths:
- Ethics : It is possible to study variables that it would be unethical to manipulate e.g. you can
compare a community that had TV with a community that doesn't have TV and compare who's
more aggressive.
- Demand Characteristics : Participants might not know they're in a study, so their behaviour is
likely to be more natural
- Ecological Validity : They tend to be less artificial than laboratory experiments
Limitations:
- Causal relationships : Because you don’t manipulate the IV then other factors can play a part
in the outcome of the DV, as a result it is hard to conclude a causal relationship between the
factors.
- Ethics : Deception is often used, making informed consent difficult. Also, confidentiality may
be compromised if the community is identifiable.
4) Quasi Experiment
In a quasi experiment the researcher isn't able to randomly allocate participants into different
conditions. This is usually because the independent variable is a particular feature of the
participants such as gender or the existence of a mental disorder.
Strengths:
- Control : Quasi Experiments are often carried out under controlled conditions
- Ecological Validity : The research is often less artificial than laboratory studies, so you're more
likely to be able to generalise the results to real life.
Limitations :
- Participant allocation : You cant randomly allocate participants to each condition, and so
confounding variables (e.g. where the participants live) may affect the results. Lets face it -
you've got no control over these variables and its hard to say whats caused by what.
- Causal relationships : It can be hard to establish cause and effect because the independent
variable isn't being directly manipulated.
Observational Techniques involve observing - not interfering
Naturalistic Observation:
Strengths:
Ecological Validity - The participants’ behaviour is natural and there are no demand
characteristics, as the participant is unaware of being observed
Theory Development - These studies can be useful to develop ideas about behaviour that
could be tested in more controlled conditions later
Limitations:
Extraneous Variables - You cant control the variables that may affect behaviour
Observer Bias - The observers’ expectations may affect what they focus on and record.
This means the reliability of the results may be a problem. Another observer may have
come up with a different conclusion.
Types of Experiment
1) Laboratory Experiment
The aim of all lab experiments is to control all revel vent variables expect for one key variable,
which is altered to see what the effect of this is. The variable altered is called the IV and the result
of this which is being measured is called the DV. Lab experiments are conducted in artificial
settings.
Strengths:
- Control : The effects of confounding variables (those that have an effect in addition to the
variable of interest.
- Replication : Strict controls mean that the study can be ran again to check the findings
- Causal Relationships : Ideally its possible to establish whether one variable actually causes
change in another
Limitations:
- Artificial : Experiments may lack ecological validity
- Demand Characteristics : Participants may respond according to what they think is being
investigated, which can bias the results.
- Ethics - Deception is often used, making informed consent difficult
2) Field Experiments
Field experiments are conducted outside of the laboratory. Behaviour is measured in a natural
environment like a school, the street or in a train. A key variable is still altered so that its effect can
be measured.
Strengths:
- Casual Relationship : You can still establish a causal relationship by manipulating the key
variable and measuring its effect, although it is very hard to do in a field experiment
- Ecologically valid - Field experiments are less artificial than those done in a lab, so they relate
to life better
- Demand Characteristics - (participants trying to guess what the researcher expects from them
and performing differently because of it) - These can be avoided if the participants don’t know
they're in a study
Limitations:
- Less control : Confounding variables may be more likely in a natural environment
- Ethics : Participants who didn't agree to take part might expense distress and often cant be
debriefed. Observation must respect privacy.
3) Natural Experiments
This is where the researcher looks at how the independent variable, which isn't being manipulated
by the researcher affects the dependent variable. The independent variable isn't manipulated
because its an event which occurs naturally. An example is research into the effect of single-sex
schools and a mix set school on behaviour. Participants are usually allocated to each condition
randomly.
, Strengths:
- Ethics : It is possible to study variables that it would be unethical to manipulate e.g. you can
compare a community that had TV with a community that doesn't have TV and compare who's
more aggressive.
- Demand Characteristics : Participants might not know they're in a study, so their behaviour is
likely to be more natural
- Ecological Validity : They tend to be less artificial than laboratory experiments
Limitations:
- Causal relationships : Because you don’t manipulate the IV then other factors can play a part
in the outcome of the DV, as a result it is hard to conclude a causal relationship between the
factors.
- Ethics : Deception is often used, making informed consent difficult. Also, confidentiality may
be compromised if the community is identifiable.
4) Quasi Experiment
In a quasi experiment the researcher isn't able to randomly allocate participants into different
conditions. This is usually because the independent variable is a particular feature of the
participants such as gender or the existence of a mental disorder.
Strengths:
- Control : Quasi Experiments are often carried out under controlled conditions
- Ecological Validity : The research is often less artificial than laboratory studies, so you're more
likely to be able to generalise the results to real life.
Limitations :
- Participant allocation : You cant randomly allocate participants to each condition, and so
confounding variables (e.g. where the participants live) may affect the results. Lets face it -
you've got no control over these variables and its hard to say whats caused by what.
- Causal relationships : It can be hard to establish cause and effect because the independent
variable isn't being directly manipulated.
Observational Techniques involve observing - not interfering
Naturalistic Observation:
Strengths:
Ecological Validity - The participants’ behaviour is natural and there are no demand
characteristics, as the participant is unaware of being observed
Theory Development - These studies can be useful to develop ideas about behaviour that
could be tested in more controlled conditions later
Limitations:
Extraneous Variables - You cant control the variables that may affect behaviour
Observer Bias - The observers’ expectations may affect what they focus on and record.
This means the reliability of the results may be a problem. Another observer may have
come up with a different conclusion.