RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
HMPYC80
RRI REVISED CRITERIA GUIDE
Perfectionist Notes
PRIVATE TUTOR FOR HONOURS IN PSYCHOLOGY - UNISA
helping you achieve your best results
,HOW TO USE THE RESEARCH REVIEW INVENTORY (revised)
The review inventory consists of a number of items, numbered sequentially from 1 up to 58.
For research proposals: 1-45.
You can download the UNISA version on MyUnisa. Document title: “Review Log for the
Research Review Inventory MS WORD FILE Unisa HMPYC80”.
RATING SCALE :
Items should be reviewed and rated on a three-point rating scale from 1 to 3.
The ratings are defined as follows:
1: Absent, incorrect, or completely wrong.
2: Only partially addressed. It does not attain the item requirement or criteria.
3: Sufficiently up to standard in terms of the item criteria.
Every relevant item should be reviewed and rated on this three-point scale (1 to 3).
KEEP A RECORD OF YOUR ANSWERS
Use the R.R.I. (revised): Review Log to document and keep a record of your ratings ON THE
ONLINE SITE
REVIEWER COMMENTS AND THE FEEDBACK REPORT
Each rating is associated with general comments.
For example, suppose a reviewer reviews a particular proposal and gives a rating of “3” for the
clarification of the proposed study. The general comment would be: “The research question is
formulated. A research question is derived from the research issue.”
IMPORTANT NOTES
Remember, where the item criterion is not explicitly addressed then allocate a low rating (1).
Good academic writing is clear and transparent. If a reader needs to guess at whether an issue
has been implemented and addressed or not, then the writing is neither clear nor transparent.
Only give a high rating (3) if the item criteria have been explicitly addressed.
, Property of Perfectionist Notes
Plagiarism/distribution/illegal use/selling of these notes will be prosecuted
Guide for RESEARCH REVIEW INVENTORY
A. THE TITLE
Title of the article:
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
01. The title contains at least one central psychological construct from the research proposal or
study.
What is a psychological construct?
Intelligence, motivation, anxiety, and fear are all examples of constructs. In psychology, a
construct is a skill, attribute, or ability that is based on one or more established theories.
EXAMPLE Answer:
The influence of emotional intelligence and resilience on work engagement amongst nurses in
public hospitals
Therefore it meets the criteria.
=3
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
02. The title indicates the research setting or demographic information of the sample
population.
Any one of the following is sufficient: where, who, when, under what circumstances, or the
phenomenon that is being investigated.
EXAMPLE Answer:
This title indicates:
where = public hospitals
who = nurses
phenomenon = emotional intelligence and resilience on work engagement
Therefore it meets the criteria.
=3
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
03. The title points to, or refers to, the research method, design or paradigm.
This may be signalled by a keyword or phrase such as: “lived experiences”, “perceptions”,
“attitudes”, “constructions”, “discourses”, “quasi-experimental”, “critical study”, “psychometric
properties”, “correlational study”, “inferential study”, and so on.
2
HMPYC80
RRI REVISED CRITERIA GUIDE
Perfectionist Notes
PRIVATE TUTOR FOR HONOURS IN PSYCHOLOGY - UNISA
helping you achieve your best results
,HOW TO USE THE RESEARCH REVIEW INVENTORY (revised)
The review inventory consists of a number of items, numbered sequentially from 1 up to 58.
For research proposals: 1-45.
You can download the UNISA version on MyUnisa. Document title: “Review Log for the
Research Review Inventory MS WORD FILE Unisa HMPYC80”.
RATING SCALE :
Items should be reviewed and rated on a three-point rating scale from 1 to 3.
The ratings are defined as follows:
1: Absent, incorrect, or completely wrong.
2: Only partially addressed. It does not attain the item requirement or criteria.
3: Sufficiently up to standard in terms of the item criteria.
Every relevant item should be reviewed and rated on this three-point scale (1 to 3).
KEEP A RECORD OF YOUR ANSWERS
Use the R.R.I. (revised): Review Log to document and keep a record of your ratings ON THE
ONLINE SITE
REVIEWER COMMENTS AND THE FEEDBACK REPORT
Each rating is associated with general comments.
For example, suppose a reviewer reviews a particular proposal and gives a rating of “3” for the
clarification of the proposed study. The general comment would be: “The research question is
formulated. A research question is derived from the research issue.”
IMPORTANT NOTES
Remember, where the item criterion is not explicitly addressed then allocate a low rating (1).
Good academic writing is clear and transparent. If a reader needs to guess at whether an issue
has been implemented and addressed or not, then the writing is neither clear nor transparent.
Only give a high rating (3) if the item criteria have been explicitly addressed.
, Property of Perfectionist Notes
Plagiarism/distribution/illegal use/selling of these notes will be prosecuted
Guide for RESEARCH REVIEW INVENTORY
A. THE TITLE
Title of the article:
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
01. The title contains at least one central psychological construct from the research proposal or
study.
What is a psychological construct?
Intelligence, motivation, anxiety, and fear are all examples of constructs. In psychology, a
construct is a skill, attribute, or ability that is based on one or more established theories.
EXAMPLE Answer:
The influence of emotional intelligence and resilience on work engagement amongst nurses in
public hospitals
Therefore it meets the criteria.
=3
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
02. The title indicates the research setting or demographic information of the sample
population.
Any one of the following is sufficient: where, who, when, under what circumstances, or the
phenomenon that is being investigated.
EXAMPLE Answer:
This title indicates:
where = public hospitals
who = nurses
phenomenon = emotional intelligence and resilience on work engagement
Therefore it meets the criteria.
=3
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
03. The title points to, or refers to, the research method, design or paradigm.
This may be signalled by a keyword or phrase such as: “lived experiences”, “perceptions”,
“attitudes”, “constructions”, “discourses”, “quasi-experimental”, “critical study”, “psychometric
properties”, “correlational study”, “inferential study”, and so on.
2
