FIPAC: A FIRST APPROACH TO UNDERSTAND THE STRUCTURE OF A
JUDGEMENT:
Facts
Issue
Principles (Applicable law)
Application
Conclusion
General principles to bear in mind:
It is not enough to understand what was decided in a case; you must learn to ‘make sense’ of
judgments to understand and evaluate the reasoning (ratio decidendi) in the case. You then need to
be able to make links with other law in this area: legislation, other cases etc
Ultimately, you are aiming to be a quick and analytic case reader, who can identify what was
decided, and why, and whether a case has any application to the legal problem your client is facing.
Developing a strategy for reading cases:
Pre-reading:
Be clear WHY you are reading this case: what is the purpose?
Put the case in CONTEXT – think before you read. Create prior knowledge (if you don’t have any in
this area) by looking closely at the citation, the headnote, the fly notes.
Create a picture / diagram to come back to, to keep track of who’s who.
Quickly scan the case for an overview. Be alert to the usual structure of a judgment:
- the facts of the case (including summary of the previous legal proceedings)
- what the legal issue or dispute is in this case
- a review of the existing and/or applicable law
- the judge’s application of the law to the facts
- court order (factual decision and allocation of legal costs)
Reading technique to create a quick overview:
Skim the first few words of each paragraph
Use the linguistic clues to help you to predict what part of the judgment this is
‘Chunk’ the case into its structural elements (fact, issue, principles, application, conclusion)
Use these predictions to guide how you read the case: where do you need to slow down and where
can you speed up?
JUDGEMENT:
Facts
Issue
Principles (Applicable law)
Application
Conclusion
General principles to bear in mind:
It is not enough to understand what was decided in a case; you must learn to ‘make sense’ of
judgments to understand and evaluate the reasoning (ratio decidendi) in the case. You then need to
be able to make links with other law in this area: legislation, other cases etc
Ultimately, you are aiming to be a quick and analytic case reader, who can identify what was
decided, and why, and whether a case has any application to the legal problem your client is facing.
Developing a strategy for reading cases:
Pre-reading:
Be clear WHY you are reading this case: what is the purpose?
Put the case in CONTEXT – think before you read. Create prior knowledge (if you don’t have any in
this area) by looking closely at the citation, the headnote, the fly notes.
Create a picture / diagram to come back to, to keep track of who’s who.
Quickly scan the case for an overview. Be alert to the usual structure of a judgment:
- the facts of the case (including summary of the previous legal proceedings)
- what the legal issue or dispute is in this case
- a review of the existing and/or applicable law
- the judge’s application of the law to the facts
- court order (factual decision and allocation of legal costs)
Reading technique to create a quick overview:
Skim the first few words of each paragraph
Use the linguistic clues to help you to predict what part of the judgment this is
‘Chunk’ the case into its structural elements (fact, issue, principles, application, conclusion)
Use these predictions to guide how you read the case: where do you need to slow down and where
can you speed up?