LPL4802
NOTES
, STUDY NOTES:
CHAPTER 1:
Definition, nature and scope of the law of damages
Definition:
The law of damage is that part of the law which indicates how the existence and
extent of damage, as well as the proper amount of damages are to be
determined in the case of delict, breach of contract and other legal principles
providing for the payment of damages.
Nature and scope
The law of damages should be defined as constituting of principles regarding
the compensation of all forms of damage.
The law of damages determines the content of an obligation to paydamages
or satisfaction.
The object of the law of damages should be seen as the provision ofjust,
logical and practical rules and principles in solving problems regarding the
determination of damage, damages and satisfaction.
What will give rise to a claim for damages?
1) Delictual remedies:
a) The actio legis aquiliae which provides for damages on account
for unlawful and culpable causing of any patrimonial loss
b) Actio inuriarum: satisfaction may be recovered forunlawful
and intentional personality infringement
c) Action for pain and suffering: damages for non- patrimonial loss
on account of the unlawful and culpableinfringement of the
physical-mental integrity
2) Liability without fault and liability based on risk:
a) The actio de pauperie: damages for patrimonial and non-
patrimonial loss caused by animals are recoverable
b) Actio de pastu: compensation for patrimonial loss may be recovered
where an animal has caused damage through eating and
damaging plants
c) Vicarious liability: a duty to pay damages or satisfaction is placed
on the defendant because of a delict of another
3) Legislation
4) Breach of contract
5) Contract and realization of risk (insurance contract): the conclusion of a
contract and the subsequent realization of riskare a source for the claim
of damages where an insurer has given a contractual undertaking to
indemnify the insured in terms of a policy if the realization of risk causes
damage
6) Claims based on a right of recourse or adjustment
,Definitions – NB!!
Damage: is the reduction as a result of the damage causing event, of the use or
quality of a patrimonial or personality interest in satisfying
the legally recognized needs of the person involved
Patrimonial loss: is the diminution in the utility of a patrimonial interest in satisfying
the recognized needs of the person entitled to such interest. It may be defined as
the loss or reduction of a positive asset in someone’s patrimony or the creation or
increase of a negative
element
Patrimony: consists of all subjective rights having a monetary value as well as
the expectation of acquiring such rights.
In a factual and economic sense its everything of an individual which has a
monetary value and which may be used by him in satisfying his
legally recognized needs
Non-patrimonial loss: is the reduction in the quality of a highly personal interest
of an individual in satisfying his legally recognized
needs but which does not affect his patrimony
Damage-causing event: it’s a factual situation of an uncertain nature, which has
brought about damage. The factual situation consists of conduct which may in
principle lead to delictual liability orliability for breach of contract, which may bring
about a duty to pay
compensation
Affective loss: this is someone’s emotional reaction caused by having
to suffer any kind of damage or invasion of his rights
Damages: Is the monetary equivalent of damage awarded to a person with the
object of eliminating as fully as possible his past as well as
his future damage.
Compensation: in a narrow sense compensation denotes damage – in
general it’s the reparation of any patrimonial or non-patrimonial loss
Satisfaction: means that the law is upheld through penance and it denotes
the psychological gratification, which the victim of an injustice receives.
It implies the reparation of damage in the for of injury to personality by effecting
retribution for the wrong suffered by the plaintiff and by
satisfying the plaintiffs and the communities sense of justice
Compensation for non-patrimonial loss: an appropriate amount of money is
awarded to someone who has suffered non-patrimonial loss, in an attempt to
neutralize his loss through the fact that the money may bring happiness or
comfort to him to assist him in overcoming
his loss
Solatium: money
Sum-formula: is a method in which damage is determined by subtracting the
plaintiffs present patrimonial position (after the occurrence of the damage causing
event) from a hypothetical patrimonial position which he would presently have
enjoyed had the
damage causing event not occurred
Concrete concept of damage: damage is determined by comparing
the utility of an element of the plaintiffs patrimony before the damage
, causing event occurred with its utility after the damage causing event.
“Once and for all” rule: plaintiff may in general only once claim damages or
satisfaction for all the damage based on a single cause of action – he therefore e
has to claim for loss already suffered as well as
all prospective loss
Cause of action: this means that all the elements or facts necessary to found a
claim for damages or satisfaction are present. A cause of action accrues (if all
other facts are present) as soon as some damage
is suffered.
Collateral benefits: this refers to a situation where the plaintiff also receives some
benefit as a result of the damage-causing event. If such benefit is taken into
account in reducing his recoverable damages, it is
said that the collateral source rule doesn’t apply. This means the
defendant’s liability to pay damages is accordingly reduced.
Res inter alios acta: this is a situation where the collateral source
rule does apply
General and special damage: general damage is usually that damagewhich is
presumed to flow from an unlawful act – in contract general damage is the
damage that flows naturally from a breach of contract and which the law presumes
that the parties have contemplated would result from such a breach.
Special damage refers to damage which the law doesn’t presume to be the
necessary consequence of the act complained of and which must be specially
pleaded and established by evidence – in contract special damage refers to loss
which is normally too remote and for which
damages may be recovered only if the parties actually or presumably foresaw
that it would result
Nominal damages: this is the payment of a small amount of money to
a plaintiff that has proved an invasion of his rights but no damage
Nominalism: Legal concept that an obligation to pay a certain sum remains
unchanged whether or not the currency in which it was to be paid appreciates or
depreciates.
Id quod interest, interesse: this is the full patrimonial damage or
loss sustained by the plaintiff for which damages are recoverable
Damnum emergens, lucrum cessans: damnum emergens – means damage
(patrimonial loss) which has been suffered and for which damages are claimed –
refers to loss already sustained.
Lucrum cessans – means loss of profits and some forms of prospective loss.
Prospective loss: this is damage in the form of patrimonial and non-patrimonial
loss which will, with a sufficient degree of probability, materialize after the time of
assessment of damage on account of an
earlier damage causing event
Positive and negative interesse: in contract – positive interesse usually refers to
the total interests which a contractual party has in the other party fulfilling his
contractual obligations = all damage which he has already suffered and will
probably suffer in the future as
a result of the breach.
NOTES
, STUDY NOTES:
CHAPTER 1:
Definition, nature and scope of the law of damages
Definition:
The law of damage is that part of the law which indicates how the existence and
extent of damage, as well as the proper amount of damages are to be
determined in the case of delict, breach of contract and other legal principles
providing for the payment of damages.
Nature and scope
The law of damages should be defined as constituting of principles regarding
the compensation of all forms of damage.
The law of damages determines the content of an obligation to paydamages
or satisfaction.
The object of the law of damages should be seen as the provision ofjust,
logical and practical rules and principles in solving problems regarding the
determination of damage, damages and satisfaction.
What will give rise to a claim for damages?
1) Delictual remedies:
a) The actio legis aquiliae which provides for damages on account
for unlawful and culpable causing of any patrimonial loss
b) Actio inuriarum: satisfaction may be recovered forunlawful
and intentional personality infringement
c) Action for pain and suffering: damages for non- patrimonial loss
on account of the unlawful and culpableinfringement of the
physical-mental integrity
2) Liability without fault and liability based on risk:
a) The actio de pauperie: damages for patrimonial and non-
patrimonial loss caused by animals are recoverable
b) Actio de pastu: compensation for patrimonial loss may be recovered
where an animal has caused damage through eating and
damaging plants
c) Vicarious liability: a duty to pay damages or satisfaction is placed
on the defendant because of a delict of another
3) Legislation
4) Breach of contract
5) Contract and realization of risk (insurance contract): the conclusion of a
contract and the subsequent realization of riskare a source for the claim
of damages where an insurer has given a contractual undertaking to
indemnify the insured in terms of a policy if the realization of risk causes
damage
6) Claims based on a right of recourse or adjustment
,Definitions – NB!!
Damage: is the reduction as a result of the damage causing event, of the use or
quality of a patrimonial or personality interest in satisfying
the legally recognized needs of the person involved
Patrimonial loss: is the diminution in the utility of a patrimonial interest in satisfying
the recognized needs of the person entitled to such interest. It may be defined as
the loss or reduction of a positive asset in someone’s patrimony or the creation or
increase of a negative
element
Patrimony: consists of all subjective rights having a monetary value as well as
the expectation of acquiring such rights.
In a factual and economic sense its everything of an individual which has a
monetary value and which may be used by him in satisfying his
legally recognized needs
Non-patrimonial loss: is the reduction in the quality of a highly personal interest
of an individual in satisfying his legally recognized
needs but which does not affect his patrimony
Damage-causing event: it’s a factual situation of an uncertain nature, which has
brought about damage. The factual situation consists of conduct which may in
principle lead to delictual liability orliability for breach of contract, which may bring
about a duty to pay
compensation
Affective loss: this is someone’s emotional reaction caused by having
to suffer any kind of damage or invasion of his rights
Damages: Is the monetary equivalent of damage awarded to a person with the
object of eliminating as fully as possible his past as well as
his future damage.
Compensation: in a narrow sense compensation denotes damage – in
general it’s the reparation of any patrimonial or non-patrimonial loss
Satisfaction: means that the law is upheld through penance and it denotes
the psychological gratification, which the victim of an injustice receives.
It implies the reparation of damage in the for of injury to personality by effecting
retribution for the wrong suffered by the plaintiff and by
satisfying the plaintiffs and the communities sense of justice
Compensation for non-patrimonial loss: an appropriate amount of money is
awarded to someone who has suffered non-patrimonial loss, in an attempt to
neutralize his loss through the fact that the money may bring happiness or
comfort to him to assist him in overcoming
his loss
Solatium: money
Sum-formula: is a method in which damage is determined by subtracting the
plaintiffs present patrimonial position (after the occurrence of the damage causing
event) from a hypothetical patrimonial position which he would presently have
enjoyed had the
damage causing event not occurred
Concrete concept of damage: damage is determined by comparing
the utility of an element of the plaintiffs patrimony before the damage
, causing event occurred with its utility after the damage causing event.
“Once and for all” rule: plaintiff may in general only once claim damages or
satisfaction for all the damage based on a single cause of action – he therefore e
has to claim for loss already suffered as well as
all prospective loss
Cause of action: this means that all the elements or facts necessary to found a
claim for damages or satisfaction are present. A cause of action accrues (if all
other facts are present) as soon as some damage
is suffered.
Collateral benefits: this refers to a situation where the plaintiff also receives some
benefit as a result of the damage-causing event. If such benefit is taken into
account in reducing his recoverable damages, it is
said that the collateral source rule doesn’t apply. This means the
defendant’s liability to pay damages is accordingly reduced.
Res inter alios acta: this is a situation where the collateral source
rule does apply
General and special damage: general damage is usually that damagewhich is
presumed to flow from an unlawful act – in contract general damage is the
damage that flows naturally from a breach of contract and which the law presumes
that the parties have contemplated would result from such a breach.
Special damage refers to damage which the law doesn’t presume to be the
necessary consequence of the act complained of and which must be specially
pleaded and established by evidence – in contract special damage refers to loss
which is normally too remote and for which
damages may be recovered only if the parties actually or presumably foresaw
that it would result
Nominal damages: this is the payment of a small amount of money to
a plaintiff that has proved an invasion of his rights but no damage
Nominalism: Legal concept that an obligation to pay a certain sum remains
unchanged whether or not the currency in which it was to be paid appreciates or
depreciates.
Id quod interest, interesse: this is the full patrimonial damage or
loss sustained by the plaintiff for which damages are recoverable
Damnum emergens, lucrum cessans: damnum emergens – means damage
(patrimonial loss) which has been suffered and for which damages are claimed –
refers to loss already sustained.
Lucrum cessans – means loss of profits and some forms of prospective loss.
Prospective loss: this is damage in the form of patrimonial and non-patrimonial
loss which will, with a sufficient degree of probability, materialize after the time of
assessment of damage on account of an
earlier damage causing event
Positive and negative interesse: in contract – positive interesse usually refers to
the total interests which a contractual party has in the other party fulfilling his
contractual obligations = all damage which he has already suffered and will
probably suffer in the future as
a result of the breach.