PVL3704
EXAM PACK
,UNJUSTIFIED ENRICHMENT LIABILITY AND
ESTOPPEL - PVL3704
MAY/JUNE 2026
EXAM ANSWERS
QUESTION 1
Indicate whether each statement is correct or incorrect and provide a reason.
1.1 The condictio causa data causa non secuta may be instituted where the plaintiff’s
property was alienated or consumed by somebody else. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
The condictio causa data causa non secuta is an enrichment action used where
property or performance was transferred for an anticipated purpose or future event that
subsequently failed to materialise. The plaintiff must have transferred the benefit in
anticipation of a particular outcome, and that outcome must not have occurred.
Where property has been alienated or consumed by another person, the appropriate
enrichment remedy may instead be the condictio sine causa specialis, depending on the
circumstances. The two remedies must therefore be distinguished according to the
reason why restitution is sought.
1.2 A leaves R1 000 000 in his will to a church to build a new church building, but the
church uses the money to build the pastor a new house. The condictio ob finitam
causam may be used to claim the money back. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
,The condictio ob finitam causam applies where an enrichment initially had a lawful
basis, but that basis subsequently falls away. In this situation, the church received the
money for a specified purpose, namely the construction of a church building.
The church's use of the money to build the pastor's house amounts to a failure to fulfil
the stipulated purpose. The appropriate remedy would ordinarily be the condictio causa
data causa non secuta, because the purpose for which the money was transferred was
not achieved.
1.3 In Union Government v National Bank of SA Ltd 1921 AD 121, the court confirmed
that the mere entrusting of one's property to another person does not amount to a
representation that the possessor is the owner or entitled to dispose of the property. (2)
Answer: Correct.
The principle is that merely handing property to another person does not necessarily
create the impression that such person is its owner or has authority to dispose of it. For
estoppel to operate, there must be a representation attributable to the true owner,
whether through words, conduct or culpable silence, which reasonably creates a
particular impression in the mind of another person.
The mere fact that possession has been transferred is therefore insufficient, without
additional circumstances establishing the required representation.
1.4 In regard to the use of estoppel in the conclusion of a contract, it is undesirable to
use estoppel in cases of mistake to bring a contract into existence because it creates a
fiction or an appearance which only applies between the parties. (2)
Answer: Correct.
Estoppel generally prevents a person from denying a representation where another
person has reasonably relied on it and suffered prejudice. It does not ordinarily create a
contract where the parties have not genuinely reached agreement.
, Using estoppel to overcome a mistake in the formation of a contract may create a
fictional agreement that exists only between the parties. This may undermine the actual
requirements for contractual consensus and the distinction between contractual and
estoppel liability.
1.5 In Kommissaris van Binnelandse Inkomste v Willers 1994 (3) SA 283 (A) the
Appellate Division rejected the existence of a general enrichment action in South Africa
and also disallowed the idea that courts can extend enrichment liability to circumstances
where it is deemed necessary. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
The decision in Kommissaris van Binnelandse Inkomste v Willers 1994 (3) SA 283 (A)
must be understood in the context of the development of South African enrichment law.
Although South African law has traditionally recognised specific enrichment actions
rather than an unrestricted general enrichment action, the courts have acknowledged
the importance of the general principles underlying enrichment liability.
The statement is therefore too broad in suggesting that the courts have no scope to
develop enrichment liability. The development of the law must, however, take place
within the recognised requirements and limitations of unjustified enrichment.
QUESTION 2 (15 marks)
A's car is stolen. Later, at an auction where A is present, he recognises his car which
has been put up for sale, but he remains silent. B buys the car for R50 000. A now
claims the car from B with the actio rei vindicatio. Identify the element of estoppel that is
most applicable to this set of facts and discuss the element in full. Refer to the relevant
case law in your answer.
Answer
EXAM PACK
,UNJUSTIFIED ENRICHMENT LIABILITY AND
ESTOPPEL - PVL3704
MAY/JUNE 2026
EXAM ANSWERS
QUESTION 1
Indicate whether each statement is correct or incorrect and provide a reason.
1.1 The condictio causa data causa non secuta may be instituted where the plaintiff’s
property was alienated or consumed by somebody else. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
The condictio causa data causa non secuta is an enrichment action used where
property or performance was transferred for an anticipated purpose or future event that
subsequently failed to materialise. The plaintiff must have transferred the benefit in
anticipation of a particular outcome, and that outcome must not have occurred.
Where property has been alienated or consumed by another person, the appropriate
enrichment remedy may instead be the condictio sine causa specialis, depending on the
circumstances. The two remedies must therefore be distinguished according to the
reason why restitution is sought.
1.2 A leaves R1 000 000 in his will to a church to build a new church building, but the
church uses the money to build the pastor a new house. The condictio ob finitam
causam may be used to claim the money back. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
,The condictio ob finitam causam applies where an enrichment initially had a lawful
basis, but that basis subsequently falls away. In this situation, the church received the
money for a specified purpose, namely the construction of a church building.
The church's use of the money to build the pastor's house amounts to a failure to fulfil
the stipulated purpose. The appropriate remedy would ordinarily be the condictio causa
data causa non secuta, because the purpose for which the money was transferred was
not achieved.
1.3 In Union Government v National Bank of SA Ltd 1921 AD 121, the court confirmed
that the mere entrusting of one's property to another person does not amount to a
representation that the possessor is the owner or entitled to dispose of the property. (2)
Answer: Correct.
The principle is that merely handing property to another person does not necessarily
create the impression that such person is its owner or has authority to dispose of it. For
estoppel to operate, there must be a representation attributable to the true owner,
whether through words, conduct or culpable silence, which reasonably creates a
particular impression in the mind of another person.
The mere fact that possession has been transferred is therefore insufficient, without
additional circumstances establishing the required representation.
1.4 In regard to the use of estoppel in the conclusion of a contract, it is undesirable to
use estoppel in cases of mistake to bring a contract into existence because it creates a
fiction or an appearance which only applies between the parties. (2)
Answer: Correct.
Estoppel generally prevents a person from denying a representation where another
person has reasonably relied on it and suffered prejudice. It does not ordinarily create a
contract where the parties have not genuinely reached agreement.
, Using estoppel to overcome a mistake in the formation of a contract may create a
fictional agreement that exists only between the parties. This may undermine the actual
requirements for contractual consensus and the distinction between contractual and
estoppel liability.
1.5 In Kommissaris van Binnelandse Inkomste v Willers 1994 (3) SA 283 (A) the
Appellate Division rejected the existence of a general enrichment action in South Africa
and also disallowed the idea that courts can extend enrichment liability to circumstances
where it is deemed necessary. (2)
Answer: Incorrect.
The decision in Kommissaris van Binnelandse Inkomste v Willers 1994 (3) SA 283 (A)
must be understood in the context of the development of South African enrichment law.
Although South African law has traditionally recognised specific enrichment actions
rather than an unrestricted general enrichment action, the courts have acknowledged
the importance of the general principles underlying enrichment liability.
The statement is therefore too broad in suggesting that the courts have no scope to
develop enrichment liability. The development of the law must, however, take place
within the recognised requirements and limitations of unjustified enrichment.
QUESTION 2 (15 marks)
A's car is stolen. Later, at an auction where A is present, he recognises his car which
has been put up for sale, but he remains silent. B buys the car for R50 000. A now
claims the car from B with the actio rei vindicatio. Identify the element of estoppel that is
most applicable to this set of facts and discuss the element in full. Refer to the relevant
case law in your answer.
Answer