MAN 4054 VERIFIED STUDY GUIDE
Collaboration Strategies for Innovation
Solo - Answers - Control and capture all rewards
Collaborate - Answers - Access to more resources (skills and capital), Faster, Shared
costs and increased flexibility, Build a common standard, Less Risky
Questions to ask - Answers - Availability of capabilities? Protecting proprietary
technologies? Controlling technology development and use? Building and renewing
capabilities?
Strategic Alliances - Answers - (in)formal agreements between >2 orgs to cooperate
Joint Ventures - Answers - Alliance with equity investment, & maybe new legal entity
Licensing - Answers - Contract for the rights to use another's IP, typically for royalties
Outsourcing - Answers - Organization procures services/products from another entity
Collective Research Organizations - Answers - Org to facilitate collaboration among a
group of firms
Crowdsourcing - Answers - Outsourcing tasks over distributed entities
Choosing Partners - Answers -
Resource Fit - Answers - Does the potential partner fit the resource needs of the
project? Are resources complementary or supplementary? Would it enhance a firm's
strengths?
Strategic Fit - Answers - Does the potential partner have compatible objectives and
styles? Would it help achieve strategic intent?
Impact on Opportunities and Threats - Answers - Would collaboration create more
opportunities than threats (Porter 5-Forces)?
Monitor what is going on - Answers - Clear and Flexible mechanisms (Contract for rights
and obligations?)
Inputs - Answers - Contribution; Control; Targets
Outputs - Answers - Rewards; Exit Plan
, Protection - Answers - Control, Appropriation of rents
No Protection - Answers - Encourage others to support technology, Likelihood of
dominant design
Appropriability - Answers - The degree to which a firm I able to capture the rents from its
innovation
Ease or swiftness competitors copy - Answers - Racing to capture rents
Barriers to copy - Answers - Nature of tech, (Tacit, socially complex), Legally (patents,
trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets)
Patent System - Answers - A. "encourage invention and technical progress both by
providing a temporary monopoly for the inventor" B. "and by forcing the early disclosure
of the information necessary for the production of this item or the operation of the new
process"
R&D spillovers - Answers - the benefits that one company or industry receives from the
R&D activity of another
Patenting Changes - Answers - Software Algorithms became eligible (1998), but
difficult, Global Treaties to harmonize
Paris Convention for the Protection of industrial Property - Answers - Foreign nationals
can apply for the patent rights in each member country, Right of "priority"- apply in one
country, back-date in others (within certain time period)
Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) - Answers - Apply for patent in a single PCT receiving
office and reserve right to apply in more than 100 countries for up to 2 ½ years.
Simultaneous and uniform
US VS Other Patents - Answers - Used to be that the US had more Patents in the US
than foreign businesses but foreign patents in the US have surpassed US based US
patents
Patents = Small amounts $ - Answers - On average, $ from patenting is low
Is patenting and R&D useless? - Answers - Loose Standards: 2/3 Patent applications
granted. But, some do very well (skewed). Most patents are renewed (10% decay)
Appropriability - Answers - The degree to which a frim is able to capture the rents from
its innovation
It is stronger for patents if patents - Answers - Are strongly enforced through litigation,
Have a broad scope, Have a patent thicket - "an overlapping set of patents requiring
Collaboration Strategies for Innovation
Solo - Answers - Control and capture all rewards
Collaborate - Answers - Access to more resources (skills and capital), Faster, Shared
costs and increased flexibility, Build a common standard, Less Risky
Questions to ask - Answers - Availability of capabilities? Protecting proprietary
technologies? Controlling technology development and use? Building and renewing
capabilities?
Strategic Alliances - Answers - (in)formal agreements between >2 orgs to cooperate
Joint Ventures - Answers - Alliance with equity investment, & maybe new legal entity
Licensing - Answers - Contract for the rights to use another's IP, typically for royalties
Outsourcing - Answers - Organization procures services/products from another entity
Collective Research Organizations - Answers - Org to facilitate collaboration among a
group of firms
Crowdsourcing - Answers - Outsourcing tasks over distributed entities
Choosing Partners - Answers -
Resource Fit - Answers - Does the potential partner fit the resource needs of the
project? Are resources complementary or supplementary? Would it enhance a firm's
strengths?
Strategic Fit - Answers - Does the potential partner have compatible objectives and
styles? Would it help achieve strategic intent?
Impact on Opportunities and Threats - Answers - Would collaboration create more
opportunities than threats (Porter 5-Forces)?
Monitor what is going on - Answers - Clear and Flexible mechanisms (Contract for rights
and obligations?)
Inputs - Answers - Contribution; Control; Targets
Outputs - Answers - Rewards; Exit Plan
, Protection - Answers - Control, Appropriation of rents
No Protection - Answers - Encourage others to support technology, Likelihood of
dominant design
Appropriability - Answers - The degree to which a firm I able to capture the rents from its
innovation
Ease or swiftness competitors copy - Answers - Racing to capture rents
Barriers to copy - Answers - Nature of tech, (Tacit, socially complex), Legally (patents,
trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets)
Patent System - Answers - A. "encourage invention and technical progress both by
providing a temporary monopoly for the inventor" B. "and by forcing the early disclosure
of the information necessary for the production of this item or the operation of the new
process"
R&D spillovers - Answers - the benefits that one company or industry receives from the
R&D activity of another
Patenting Changes - Answers - Software Algorithms became eligible (1998), but
difficult, Global Treaties to harmonize
Paris Convention for the Protection of industrial Property - Answers - Foreign nationals
can apply for the patent rights in each member country, Right of "priority"- apply in one
country, back-date in others (within certain time period)
Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) - Answers - Apply for patent in a single PCT receiving
office and reserve right to apply in more than 100 countries for up to 2 ½ years.
Simultaneous and uniform
US VS Other Patents - Answers - Used to be that the US had more Patents in the US
than foreign businesses but foreign patents in the US have surpassed US based US
patents
Patents = Small amounts $ - Answers - On average, $ from patenting is low
Is patenting and R&D useless? - Answers - Loose Standards: 2/3 Patent applications
granted. But, some do very well (skewed). Most patents are renewed (10% decay)
Appropriability - Answers - The degree to which a frim is able to capture the rents from
its innovation
It is stronger for patents if patents - Answers - Are strongly enforced through litigation,
Have a broad scope, Have a patent thicket - "an overlapping set of patents requiring