AQA A-LEVEL HISTORY 7042/1A ||Component 2A Royal Authority and the Angevin Kings, 1154–1216||QUESTIONS & MARKING SCHEME MERGED|| GRADED A+

Section A Answer Question 01. Extract A Outremer was never likely to last. For it to survive, in the midst of enemy territory, it was necessary to have a steady renewal of manpower from the West. Rulers of Jerusalem had to appease the Byzantines and had to plot with infidel princes to ensure Muslim disunity. Whilst a few adventurers from the West arrived hoping to carve out estates for themselves, most of the reinforcements making the journey believed that it was their holy duty to fight the infidel. When they found their cousins in Outremer intriguing and trading with Muslims and allying with schismatic Greeks they were shocked. Either they returned home in disgust, or they insisted upon a more aggressive policy, thus damaging the settlers’ chances of survival. It was not easy to persuade recruits to continue to journey eastward when they disliked what they saw on arrival. The Second Crusade was a miserable failure and meant that no great expedition would set out again until Saladin had reunited the Muslim world and recaptured Jerusalem itself. Adapted from S Runciman, The Decline of the Crusading Ideal, 1971 5 10 Extract B In 1187 Jerusalem’s military might was as strong as it ever had been. True, there was vicious infighting among the Christian elites, but the kingdom’s resources were strong and intact. The disaster of Hattin is not a tale of one declining Christian kingdom being crushed by an ascendant Muslim power. It is rather the story of a still-strong Christian power being out-competed by a dynamic Muslim ruler. The roots of the kingdom’s fall need to be located with the Muslims. Saladin’s great achievement was to unite Egypt’s wealth with Syria’s manpower. This gave him the resources to out-compete the Christian armies in open battle. The crucial moment occurred in 1174. In this year Saladin left Egypt and forced his way into Damascus. This was risky but the gamble worked and, with Damascus under his control, he had a firm foothold in Syria from which he could not easily be dislodged. From this moment onwards Saladin was able to contemplate the overthrow of the crusader kingdom. Adapted from N Morton, Three Perspectives on the Crusades, 2015 5 10 3 IB/M/Jun23/7042/1A Turn over ► Extract C The instability within the court worsened during the first six years of King Baldwin IV’s reign. So long as it was uncertain whether the King’s health would permit him personally to govern there was tension within the court. During the years 1180 to 1182 this tension increased, causing open division and two hostile factions. The situation facing Jerusalem by 1187 was the most serious in its history. While internal dissension brought the kingdom to the verge of a suicidal civil war, Saladin had taken the last steps in preparation for his great offensive. However, despite this, Saladin’s victory was not inevitable. In many respects Saladin’s control of Muslim Syria was more apparent than real. The Franks were expert in trying to get Saladin to attack in unfavourable terrain. But the plan was not carried out because of renewed outbursts of Christian infighting. The tragedy of Hattin is that it was a battle that perhaps need not have been fought and certainly should not have been lost. Adapted from MW Baldwin, A History of the Crusades, 1955 5 10 0 1 Using your understanding of the historical context, assess how convincing the arguments in these three extracts are in relation to the situation in Outremer by 1187. [30 m