Document analysis = legal provision (usually article from treatises) & recent document
as an illustration & few questions about the document
Timetable for preparations on Toledo!
Exam questions = exact same type of exercises! One difference: on the exam
you are ought to know the law <-> in analysis the law is given
1 CHAPTER 1: THE FOUNDATIONS OF EUROPEAN LAW
1.1 EUROPEAN INTEGRATION: OBJECTIVE, PRINCIPLES AND VALUES
Art 1 §2 of the TEU: “an ever closer union among the peoples of Europe”
2 founding principles (art 4 TEU):
1. Equality of the Member States
2. Sincere cooperation
Importance: initially founded as an economic union after WWII
if we want to construct a closer union, we need to insert equality, so that there
will be no domination of certain states over other states; we also need to act in
good faith towards the EU (and vice versa: the institution will act in good faith
towards the states)
article 2 TEU
= values of the EU
<-> article 3 = objectives: difference between those 2 articles!
DA1 1a) Do you think the same values apply in Belgium or other EU
countries?
As mentioned in article 2 TEU, these values are common to the
member states. However, these values are not so closely followed in
other member states of the EU (i.e. Hungary). The values are very
important, but they need to be monitored.
Article 6 & 11 TEU: complementary source (because art 2 doesn’t define the values,
you can find more explanations in other articles of the TEU)
!!! necessary presumption: mutual trust
sometimes the trust doesn’t work, but these are exceptions. The member states of the
EU are under a duty to assume that the other member states also respect the
fundamental rights
1.2 A UNIQUE FORM OF INTEGRATION
Usually when states come together to form an integration, the integration has an
economic nature. There are different degrees:
- Free trade area (lowest degree)
- Customs union = free trade area, but also a common approach towards
foreign trade (checks at the border)
1
, o For example: EU is a customs union: same checks for a Chinese car
whether it enters the EU through Belgium or through Portugal
- Common market = free trade area + common customs + free movement of
workers, capital, establishment, …
- Internal market (most advanced degree): has been introduced in 1986 by
the EU.
= area in which a free movement of goods, capital, persons, … is ensured
without internal controls.
o Difference with common market: NO INTERNAL BORDER CONTROLS! In
common markets you have a right to move, but this doesn’t mean you
have a right to move without being checked. In an internal market, you
have no internal frontiers.
Note: this wil also require the approach on the movement of third-country nationals, …
We are not just talking about the economic market, but police area of freedom,
security and justice!!
So it started as an economic integration, but today the objectives are way broader! It
was established in 1992 that nationals of the member states are ALSO EU citizens!
You have a citizenship on EU level, that is derived from your national citizenship. This
EU citizenship comes with a right to vote, …
- Freedom, security and justice
- Common foreign and security police
- EU citizenship
- Common economic and monetary policy (euro)
DA1: 2a) What are the key objectives in the current TEU?
these are mentioned in art 3 TEU!
Because of its objectives, the EU is unique in the world. Some even argue that it is not
an IO anymore, but very close to the structure of a state.
Regional organizations:
- EFTA (Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway & Switzerland)
rules on transport, ... SO they are not part of the EU, but they do have a very
advanced form of economic integration
o Except for Switzerland, these EFTA states are also connected to the EU
through the EEA (European Economic Area)
Importance: This allows these 3 EFTA states to be part of the EU internal
market. They have a free trade area in between them AND they are
connected to the EU internal market.
=> Norway is NOT an EU state, but because it is an EEA state we as
Belgians for example can trade goods, services, … with Norway in the
same way as we can trade with EU states
o Switzerland is also in many ways part of the common market, just not as
advanced as the other 3 ones!
o Many of the EFTA states, and Norway in particular, have other close
relationships with the EU!
example: No passport control for going to Norway because of the
Schengen agreement
The EU is not the only IO, BUT it is the most sophisticated one!
2
,1.2.1 Tools for integration
1. Intergovernmental method: representatives of different state governments
come together to negotiate an international agreement. = standard way to form
international law
2. Supranational / community method: organization above the states will also
create organs/institutions that will make decisions themselves, autonomously
from the will of each member state. = most common for the EU!
3. Integration through law: choice of method to integrate the rules formed by
supranationalism: member states get closer to each other through the adoption
of new norms.
Supranational bodies of the EU:
Parliament = Directly elected by EU citizens
Role:
- co-decide on the EU budget
- co-legislator
- political control (of other EU institutions and bodies ->
monitoring role)
European = Heads of State or Government + own President + Commission’s
Council President (not the king, but the person that has political power!)
Role:
- impetus
- general political directions and priorities
Council = Representatives of the Member States at ministerial level
Role:
- co-decides on EU budget
- co-legislator
- policy-making & coordination
Commission = Independent members promoting EU general interest
Role:
- proposes legislation (to be adopted by Parliament & Council)
- ensures application of EU law
Court of = Independent members
Justice of the
European Role :
Union - ensures that, in the interpretation and application of the
Treaties, EU law is observed
- last interpreter of the EU law
3
, 1.3 EVOLUTION
Treaty reforms & enlargements (2 categories of evolution, now we will only talk about
treaty reforms, for enlargements: chapter 2)
Treaty of Rome: established the EEC. History towards this treaty:
1. 1946: Churchill’s vision: pacifying and reconstructing Europe will require
bringing the states together
2. Years that followed: several initiatives to stimulate the cooperation, some
succeeded and some didn’t.
a. Council of Europe (1949)
(NOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH EUROPEAN COUNCIL AND COUNCIL !). This
council is NOT an EU body. It’s objective was promoting human rights and
democracy.
i. ECHR, 1950
(European Convention of Human Rights and Fundamental
Freedoms). Relevant to the EU because all EU states are part of
this convention, although it is NOT made by a EU institution.
ii. ECtHR
(European Court of Human Rights) was set up, not to be confused
with the Court of Justice of the EU!
= much less sophisticated than the EU, but it has a Parliamentary
Assembly, Court of Human Rights, … so for that time, it was quite
sophisticated!
b. The Schuman Declaration (1950, Paris)
Schuman exposes his vision on how states should come together -> we
need to create little by little, step by step in order to get former enemies
to work together. This should lead in long term to legal integration.
c. ECSC (1951, Paris)
Why coal and steel? Because these are necessary for reconstruction AND
also for war. Transparency on coal and steel production will therefore
lead to more trust.
This treaty has an assembly, court, high authority of independent
members and a council of ministers. This looks a lot like the EU! It set a
template for what could from then on be used for economic integration.
3. Creation of the EEC (European Economic Community) in 1957
= free movement of goods and services (common market). We now have the
EEC next to the ECSC and the Euratom (community for atomic energy), also
signed in 1957 in Rome.
By the late 1950s we have 3 international communities, each of them with similar
institutions. In the early 1960s it is decided to keep the 3 communities, but to merge
the institutions.
DA1 2b) what were the key objectives in the Treaty of Rome?
art 2 TEEC: economic integration in order to accelerate the
4