100% satisfaction guarantee Immediately available after payment Both online and in PDF No strings attached 4.2 TrustPilot
logo-home
Exam (elaborations)

MRL3701 MAY/ JUNE 2023 ANSWERS/ SOLUTIONS (10 JUNE 2023) - INSOLVENCY LAW

Rating
-
Sold
1
Pages
12
Grade
A+
Uploaded on
10-06-2023
Written in
2022/2023

ANSWERS/ SOLUTIONS WITH REFERENCES & PREVIEW: Question 1 1.1 Explain the purpose of a sequestration order. (5) 1.2 “A sequestration order may not be granted if a debtor has only one creditor and there are not enough assets to cover the costs of sequestration.” Indicate whether this statement is true or false, and then provide the reasons for your answer. (5) 1.3 David approaches you for advice. He informs you that his brother, Samuel, owes him R15 000 for painting services rendered by his company. David explains to you that despite various attempts to get Samuel to pay his debts, he has yet to make any payment. David is especially upset because he has heard a rumour that Samuel owes money to several people, amongst them a mutual best friend, Lenny. Lenny informed David that Samuel wrote him a letter stating that he is unable to pay his debts to him (Lenny) and asked in the letter whether they could make arrangements to pay him back in instalments. David now wants to know from you whether you can assist him to apply for the compulsory sequestration of Samuel‘s estate. Explain the conduct above and refer to relevant legislation. (10) 1.4 Critically discuss Harksen v Lane 1998 (1) SA 300 (CC). (10) 1.5 Explain how section 27 of the Insolvency Act 24 of 1936 has the potential to violate section 9(3) of the Constitution. (10) 1.6 Critically discuss Sarrahwitz v Maritz NO and Another 2015 (4) SA 491 (CC). (10) TOTAL QUESTION 1: [50] CONFIDENTIAL 8 of 9 MRL3701 May/June 2023 Question 2 2.1 Explain the difference between a secured claim and a preferent claim. (10) 2.2 Rachel is an insolvent. She very much wishes to stand as a candidate in the upcoming municipal elections for the SAD party. Her trustee is of the opinion that she should not begin her political career at this stage. Explain whether Rachel’s trustee may interfere with her intended political career. (5) 2.3 What must a plaintiff prove to succeed in bringing the actio Pauliana action? (5) 2.4 The Master may, under certain circumstances, remove a trustee from office. Name and discuss these instances. (5) TOTAL QUESTION 2: [25] Question 3 3.1 Critically discuss the important issues the court had to consider regarding the abuse of the sequestration process in Ex Parte Snooke 2014 (5) SA 426 (FB). (10) 3.2 Daniel’s estate was sequestrated in 2022. His concurrent creditors received no dividend and even had to pay contributions. Daniel has not yet been rehabilitated. He has just won a motorcar to the value of R250 000 in a competition. The trustee of Daniel’s insolvent estate has heard about his good fortune and claims delivery of the car. Explain whether Daniel has to deliver the car to the trustee. (5) CONFIDENTIAL 9 of 9 MRL3701 May/June 2023 3.3 With reference to Close Corporations, explain how many members a Close Corporation must consist of. In your answer you must refer to whether juristic persons may be appointed as members. (5) 3.4 Explain whether a director of a company can apply for a winding-up of a company. (5) TOTAL QUESTION 3: [25] TOTAL MARKS: [100]

Show more Read less









Whoops! We can’t load your doc right now. Try again or contact support.

Document information

Uploaded on
June 10, 2023
Number of pages
12
Written in
2022/2023
Type
Exam (elaborations)
Contains
Questions & answers

Subjects

Content preview

NAME:

STUDENT NUMBER:

MRL3701 INSOLVENCY LAW

, QUESTION 1
1.1. According to Hockly’s Insolvency Law book, the purpose of a sequestration order is
to ensure the orderly and equitable distribution of a debtor’s assets among all the
creditors, according to a predetermined order of preference.
A sequestration order is a formal declaration that a debtor is insolvent. The order is granted
either at the instance of the debtor himself (voluntary surrender) or at the instance of one or
more of the debtor’s creditors (compulsory sequestration).
The sequestration order triggers a series of legal consequences, such as:

 The debtor is divested of his or her estate and legal capacity and may not burden it
with any further debts.
 A trustee is appointed to administer the insolvent estate and liquidate the assets.
 The creditors have to prove their claims against the insolvent estate and rank
according to their preference.
 The insolvent may apply for rehabilitation after a certain period of time, subject to
certain conditions.

The sequestration order aims to protect the interests of creditors as a group, as well as to
grant relief to the insolvent in certain respects.




1.2. This statement is false. A sequestration order may be granted even if a debtor has
only one creditor and there are not enough assets to cover the costs of
sequestration, provided that certain requirements are met.
According to Hockly’s Insolvency Law book, the requirements for a sequestration order are
different depending on whether it is voluntary or compulsory.
For a voluntary surrender, the debtor must prove that:

 He or she is insolvent, meaning that his or her liabilities exceed his or her assets.
 There is a reasonable probability that the sequestration will be to the advantage of
the creditors, meaning that the creditors will receive a dividend from the insolvent
estate.
 He or she has made a full disclosure of his or her affairs in the application.
 He or she owns realisable property of a sufficient value to defray all costs of the
sequestration which will be incurred by the Master and the trustee.

For a compulsory sequestration, the creditor must prove that:

 The debtor has committed an act of insolvency, or is deemed to have committed an
act of insolvency, as defined in the Insolvency Act.
 The debtor is actually insolvent, meaning that his or her liabilities exceed his or her
assets.
 There is reason to believe that it will be to the advantage of creditors if the debtor’s
estate is sequestrated.

Therefore, it is possible for a debtor with only one creditor and insufficient assets to be
sequestrated, either voluntarily or compulsorily, as long as the other requirements are
satisfied.

Get to know the seller

Seller avatar
Reputation scores are based on the amount of documents a seller has sold for a fee and the reviews they have received for those documents. There are three levels: Bronze, Silver and Gold. The better the reputation, the more your can rely on the quality of the sellers work.
AriaLawTutor Teachme2-tutor
View profile
Follow You need to be logged in order to follow users or courses
Sold
871
Member since
3 year
Number of followers
505
Documents
83
Last sold
1 year ago

4,6

194 reviews

5
159
4
16
3
12
2
0
1
7

Recently viewed by you

Why students choose Stuvia

Created by fellow students, verified by reviews

Quality you can trust: written by students who passed their exams and reviewed by others who've used these notes.

Didn't get what you expected? Choose another document

No worries! You can immediately select a different document that better matches what you need.

Pay how you prefer, start learning right away

No subscription, no commitments. Pay the way you're used to via credit card or EFT and download your PDF document instantly.

Student with book image

“Bought, downloaded, and aced it. It really can be that simple.”

Alisha Student

Frequently asked questions