, PUB2617
ASSIGNMENT 3 SEMESTER 2
(PORTFOLIO) 2026
DUE 21 OCTOBER 2026
PROJECT CONTROL AND EVALUATION IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR
Public sector projects are entrusted with public resources and are expected to deliver tangible
benefits to citizens, yet they routinely confront complexity, uncertainty, and accountability
pressures that exceed those of private ventures. Project control and evaluation constitute the
essential management architecture through which governments seek to convert policy intent into
delivered outcomes (Kerzner, 2017:4).
The Role of Project Control and Evaluation in Public Sector Management
Project control encompasses the processes of monitoring progress, comparing actual performance
against plans, and initiating corrective action, while evaluation involves the systematic assessment
of relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, impact, and sustainability (PMI, 2021:12). In the public
sector, these functions are not merely technical exercises but instruments of democratic
accountability. Governments must demonstrate to legislatures, audit institutions, and citizens that
resources have been used for intended purposes and have achieved value for money (National
Treasury, 2019:23).
The evidence linking evaluation practices to project completion is compelling. Mwangi and Ngugi
(2019:67) conducted a study of county government projects in Kitui County, Kenya, and found that
evaluation practices had a statistically significant positive effect on project completion (B = 0.623, p
= 0.000), leading the authors to conclude that systematic assessment fosters organisational
learning and accountability, thereby driving superior project outcomes. This empirical finding
substantiates the theoretical proposition advanced by Crawford and Bryce (2003:45) that
evaluation is not an overhead cost but a value-adding management function.
Nevertheless, the translation of evaluation findings into improved performance is contingent upon
institutional capacity and political will. Boyle (2016:112) examined Ireland's Value for Money and
Policy Review process and found that, while well-established, it suffered from administrative
burdensomeness, with some reviews taking several years from start to completion, and a lack of
uniform reporting standards that impeded their utility for resource allocation. This illustrates a
critical tension in public sector control: the demand for comprehensive accountability can produce
bureaucratic processes that are themselves inefficient and disconnected from decision-making
cycles (Flyvbjerg, 2014:38).
ASSIGNMENT 3 SEMESTER 2
(PORTFOLIO) 2026
DUE 21 OCTOBER 2026
PROJECT CONTROL AND EVALUATION IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR
Public sector projects are entrusted with public resources and are expected to deliver tangible
benefits to citizens, yet they routinely confront complexity, uncertainty, and accountability
pressures that exceed those of private ventures. Project control and evaluation constitute the
essential management architecture through which governments seek to convert policy intent into
delivered outcomes (Kerzner, 2017:4).
The Role of Project Control and Evaluation in Public Sector Management
Project control encompasses the processes of monitoring progress, comparing actual performance
against plans, and initiating corrective action, while evaluation involves the systematic assessment
of relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, impact, and sustainability (PMI, 2021:12). In the public
sector, these functions are not merely technical exercises but instruments of democratic
accountability. Governments must demonstrate to legislatures, audit institutions, and citizens that
resources have been used for intended purposes and have achieved value for money (National
Treasury, 2019:23).
The evidence linking evaluation practices to project completion is compelling. Mwangi and Ngugi
(2019:67) conducted a study of county government projects in Kitui County, Kenya, and found that
evaluation practices had a statistically significant positive effect on project completion (B = 0.623, p
= 0.000), leading the authors to conclude that systematic assessment fosters organisational
learning and accountability, thereby driving superior project outcomes. This empirical finding
substantiates the theoretical proposition advanced by Crawford and Bryce (2003:45) that
evaluation is not an overhead cost but a value-adding management function.
Nevertheless, the translation of evaluation findings into improved performance is contingent upon
institutional capacity and political will. Boyle (2016:112) examined Ireland's Value for Money and
Policy Review process and found that, while well-established, it suffered from administrative
burdensomeness, with some reviews taking several years from start to completion, and a lack of
uniform reporting standards that impeded their utility for resource allocation. This illustrates a
critical tension in public sector control: the demand for comprehensive accountability can produce
bureaucratic processes that are themselves inefficient and disconnected from decision-making
cycles (Flyvbjerg, 2014:38).