SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with
questions and answers (100% solved)
,SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
Cyber Article 5 Aff File
When you are the affirmative, the first speaker on your team reads all the
affirmative and will be cross examined for 3 minutes after. Remember your
2 advantages which are cyberattack advantage and international law
advantage.
The idea is that Article 5 in NATO needs to be clear about what is armed
attack. Right now it is ambiguous so every country could interpret it
differently. If it is becomes clearer then the countries can have a united
front against Russia’s cyber attacks on countries and companies.
If it is unclear as far as international law and countries react differently, then
their could be great confusion leading to war.
,SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
Top Level
This file and the associated lessons were produced by Jacob Wilkus (Lawrence Free State High School
and the University of Kansas). Below are detailed explanations of all parts of this file, which should
work to help you understand the file and the components of it.
The solvency mechanism for the affirmative is described in detail in the Frydenborg evidence, which is
the last piece of evidence on the first advantage. There is also explanation of how the international
framework would be created in the Hill and West cards in the second advantage. The Frydenborg card
describes that the affirmative would clearly define cyberwarfare within the North Atlantic Treaty, as
well as what operations would trigger an “armed attack” threshold. It also argues for the development
of non-Article 5 responses to attacks that do not meet that threshold, but still have an impact, creating
a clear response doctrine for all adversarial operations in cyberspace.
, SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
1AC
questions and answers (100% solved)
,SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
Cyber Article 5 Aff File
When you are the affirmative, the first speaker on your team reads all the
affirmative and will be cross examined for 3 minutes after. Remember your
2 advantages which are cyberattack advantage and international law
advantage.
The idea is that Article 5 in NATO needs to be clear about what is armed
attack. Right now it is ambiguous so every country could interpret it
differently. If it is becomes clearer then the countries can have a united
front against Russia’s cyber attacks on countries and companies.
If it is unclear as far as international law and countries react differently, then
their could be great confusion leading to war.
,SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
Top Level
This file and the associated lessons were produced by Jacob Wilkus (Lawrence Free State High School
and the University of Kansas). Below are detailed explanations of all parts of this file, which should
work to help you understand the file and the components of it.
The solvency mechanism for the affirmative is described in detail in the Frydenborg evidence, which is
the last piece of evidence on the first advantage. There is also explanation of how the international
framework would be created in the Hill and West cards in the second advantage. The Frydenborg card
describes that the affirmative would clearly define cyberwarfare within the North Atlantic Treaty, as
well as what operations would trigger an “armed attack” threshold. It also argues for the development
of non-Article 5 responses to attacks that do not meet that threshold, but still have an impact, creating
a clear response doctrine for all adversarial operations in cyberspace.
, SCHOOL as a community of care DUDL Cyber A5 Affirmative exam with questions
and answers (100% solved)
1AC
