Foundations of the European Union
HOORCOLLEGE I
1.1. The EU and its institutions
the EU
- Started of as peace project after WOII
- Closer economic, social and political ties
o EEC
- Originally Western Europe
o Now 27 states
- European cooperation
o Marshall plan
o OEEC (organization for European Economic Co-operation)
o OECD (organization for Economic Cooperation and Development)
o NATO
o WEU (Western European Union)
o Council of Europe
Changes over time
- Expansion of power
o Increase in competence
o Through treaties
Maastricht treaty 1992
Lisbon treaty 2007
treaties still in force today
EURATOM: treaty establishing the European Atomic
Energy Community
TEU, TFEU, EU Charter: unified legal personality, formal
abolition of pillar structure
EU institutions overview
- Listed in art 13 TEU
Institution Legal basis TEU Legal basis TFEU
European Parliament Art 14 TEU Art 223-234 TFEU
European Council Art 15 TEU Art 235-236 TFEU
Council Art 16 TEU Art 237-243 TFEU
European Commission Art 17 TEU Art 244-250 TFEU
Court of Justice of the Art 19 TEU Art 251-281 TFEU
European Union
European Central Bank / Art 282-284 TFEU
Court of Auditors / Art 285-287 TFEU
1
,Other EU bodies
- Advisory bodies (art 300-307 TFEU)
o Economic and social committee
o Committee of the regions
Politically not the biggest role
- Executive agencies (commission’s long arm)
- Decentralized agencies
o More independent
o Get a say on certain parts of EU law
- European investment bank
o Connected to EU but not an institution
1.1.1. European commission
The “government” of the EU
Still one commissioner per member state
- 27 (including president & high representative)
- Exception art 17(5) TEU
- Can limit to 2/3
- Not really used
o Prefer using the exception
Led by the president (art 17 (6) TEU and 248 TFEU)
- Ursula von der Leyen
Considerable powers (art 17 (1)-(2) TEU)
- Legislative initiative
o Most important
o Some exceptional cases
- Ensuring application of EU law
- Executing the EU budget
2
, - External representation
o When negotiating with EU, you are negotiating with the commission
o Except foreign affairs and security policy
High representative (is part of the commission)
Treaty of Amsterdam: part of the council
Treaty of Lisbon: part of the commission
Appointment in 2 steps (art 17(7) TEU)
- Election of president
o Proposed by the council while taking in account the election votes
o System: spitzenkandidaten
Every political party chose 1 person as candidate
o Approved by the parliament
Easy to get approval because of the system
Biggest party in the parliament behind the candidate
- Choice of Commissioners
o President-elect and council provide list of commissioners
o Approved by European parliament
Need to approve all of them
Can ask for substitutes
Special procedure for high representatives (art 17(7)-(8) and 18 TEU)
Commissioners = college
- Each commissioner is allocated a portfolio
o = ministerportefeuille
- Decisions are adopted ‘collegially’
- Bureaucracy divided into directorates-general
o Vergelijkbaar met FOD’s
- Once appointed, independence from national instructions (art 17(3) TEU)
- Acts totally independent
o From other institutions
o National politics
o Can be instructed
Doesn’t guarantee they will follow
1.1.2. European parliament
Only elected body of EU (art 14 TEU)
‘MEPs’ are directly elected every five years
Shall not exceed 751 representatives
- Max 96 per member states
- Currently 720
3
, Representation = degressively proportional to the detriment of bigger member
states
- Smaller states overrepresented
- So that big ones don’t just take over
Next election May 2029
Legislative function: co-legislator with council
- No initiative
Budgetary function: adoption and control
Function of political control of commission (art 17 TEU and 230 TFEU)
Consultation/ consent function:
try to convince constitution to do things
- Special legislative procedures
- International agreements (art 218 TFEU)
- Treaty amendment (art 48 TFEU)
- Accession and withdrawal (art 49-50 TFEU)
Elects its own president (art 14(4) TEU)
Adopts rules of procedure
Default voting mechanism
- Majority if the votes cast (simple majority) (art 231 TFEU)
- When explicity provided
o Majority of component members (absolute majority)
o Quarter of component members
o 2/3 majority of votes cast and majority of component members
(double majority)
1.1.3. Council of the EU
Co-legislator
Representation of national governments -> 27 members
Composed of national ministers (art 16(2) TEU)
- For a certain matter
- Multiple council/ different configurations
o General affairs
o Foreign affairs (high representative)
o Economic and financial affairs
o Justice and home affairs
o …
- Depends on the content of the file (art 16(6) TEU)
Legislative functions (art 16(1) TEU)
4
HOORCOLLEGE I
1.1. The EU and its institutions
the EU
- Started of as peace project after WOII
- Closer economic, social and political ties
o EEC
- Originally Western Europe
o Now 27 states
- European cooperation
o Marshall plan
o OEEC (organization for European Economic Co-operation)
o OECD (organization for Economic Cooperation and Development)
o NATO
o WEU (Western European Union)
o Council of Europe
Changes over time
- Expansion of power
o Increase in competence
o Through treaties
Maastricht treaty 1992
Lisbon treaty 2007
treaties still in force today
EURATOM: treaty establishing the European Atomic
Energy Community
TEU, TFEU, EU Charter: unified legal personality, formal
abolition of pillar structure
EU institutions overview
- Listed in art 13 TEU
Institution Legal basis TEU Legal basis TFEU
European Parliament Art 14 TEU Art 223-234 TFEU
European Council Art 15 TEU Art 235-236 TFEU
Council Art 16 TEU Art 237-243 TFEU
European Commission Art 17 TEU Art 244-250 TFEU
Court of Justice of the Art 19 TEU Art 251-281 TFEU
European Union
European Central Bank / Art 282-284 TFEU
Court of Auditors / Art 285-287 TFEU
1
,Other EU bodies
- Advisory bodies (art 300-307 TFEU)
o Economic and social committee
o Committee of the regions
Politically not the biggest role
- Executive agencies (commission’s long arm)
- Decentralized agencies
o More independent
o Get a say on certain parts of EU law
- European investment bank
o Connected to EU but not an institution
1.1.1. European commission
The “government” of the EU
Still one commissioner per member state
- 27 (including president & high representative)
- Exception art 17(5) TEU
- Can limit to 2/3
- Not really used
o Prefer using the exception
Led by the president (art 17 (6) TEU and 248 TFEU)
- Ursula von der Leyen
Considerable powers (art 17 (1)-(2) TEU)
- Legislative initiative
o Most important
o Some exceptional cases
- Ensuring application of EU law
- Executing the EU budget
2
, - External representation
o When negotiating with EU, you are negotiating with the commission
o Except foreign affairs and security policy
High representative (is part of the commission)
Treaty of Amsterdam: part of the council
Treaty of Lisbon: part of the commission
Appointment in 2 steps (art 17(7) TEU)
- Election of president
o Proposed by the council while taking in account the election votes
o System: spitzenkandidaten
Every political party chose 1 person as candidate
o Approved by the parliament
Easy to get approval because of the system
Biggest party in the parliament behind the candidate
- Choice of Commissioners
o President-elect and council provide list of commissioners
o Approved by European parliament
Need to approve all of them
Can ask for substitutes
Special procedure for high representatives (art 17(7)-(8) and 18 TEU)
Commissioners = college
- Each commissioner is allocated a portfolio
o = ministerportefeuille
- Decisions are adopted ‘collegially’
- Bureaucracy divided into directorates-general
o Vergelijkbaar met FOD’s
- Once appointed, independence from national instructions (art 17(3) TEU)
- Acts totally independent
o From other institutions
o National politics
o Can be instructed
Doesn’t guarantee they will follow
1.1.2. European parliament
Only elected body of EU (art 14 TEU)
‘MEPs’ are directly elected every five years
Shall not exceed 751 representatives
- Max 96 per member states
- Currently 720
3
, Representation = degressively proportional to the detriment of bigger member
states
- Smaller states overrepresented
- So that big ones don’t just take over
Next election May 2029
Legislative function: co-legislator with council
- No initiative
Budgetary function: adoption and control
Function of political control of commission (art 17 TEU and 230 TFEU)
Consultation/ consent function:
try to convince constitution to do things
- Special legislative procedures
- International agreements (art 218 TFEU)
- Treaty amendment (art 48 TFEU)
- Accession and withdrawal (art 49-50 TFEU)
Elects its own president (art 14(4) TEU)
Adopts rules of procedure
Default voting mechanism
- Majority if the votes cast (simple majority) (art 231 TFEU)
- When explicity provided
o Majority of component members (absolute majority)
o Quarter of component members
o 2/3 majority of votes cast and majority of component members
(double majority)
1.1.3. Council of the EU
Co-legislator
Representation of national governments -> 27 members
Composed of national ministers (art 16(2) TEU)
- For a certain matter
- Multiple council/ different configurations
o General affairs
o Foreign affairs (high representative)
o Economic and financial affairs
o Justice and home affairs
o …
- Depends on the content of the file (art 16(6) TEU)
Legislative functions (art 16(1) TEU)
4